Opinion Why We Need More Trans Journalists

  • ⚙️ Performance issue identified and being addressed.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Link

Why We Need More Trans Journalists​


VICE World News' series ‘Transnational’ follows trans journalists around the world as they tell stories in places like Detroit, Mexico City, and Lagos.
By Alyza Enriquez
June 18, 2021, 10:03 am
It’s been over six years since TIME Magazine notoriously declared that America had reached the “Transgender Tipping Point” with a cover featuring Orange is the New Black star Laverne Cox. And yet, data compiled by the Human Rights Campaign shows that 2021 is on track to be the deadliest ever for reported trans murders in the U.S., with 28 murders so far this year. And according to the ACLU, with the recent slew of anti-trans sports and healthcare bills targeting trans youth, 2021 has seen more legislation limiting the rights of trans people passed this year than in the last decade combined.

These bills largely rely on a tangle of myths and misinformation related to trans people, such as the incorrect argument that puberty blockers are inherently dangerous, or the inaccurate assumption that trans women have an inherent advantage over cis women athletes. Kam Burns, a founding member of the Trans Journalists Association, believes that journalism for and by trans people is key to correcting the misinformation that contributes to such violence and legislative attacks, as well as adding humanistic context to such issues.

“We know the terminology, but we also know how to humanize trans sources because we know what it’s like to be dehumanized,” said Burns. “So many stories on trans people, whether it’s related to legislation or healthcare or something else entirely, center cis people. Trans people can write stories about and for other trans people, which you don’t see that often.”

VICE World News’ Transnational launches amid this media landscape. First and foremost, the six-part series was born out of a mission to create more opportunities for trans people both in front of and behind the camera and, in doing so, tell trans stories in the most nuanced and accurate way possible. The series also takes viewers around the world, following trans correspondents as they explore cities where stories about trans rights and movements are under-represented in media—Detroit, Mexico City, and Lagos among them. There, correspondents embed within the activist community, learning about the particular issues that trans people face in that place and the consistently innovative ways that the queer and trans community there are fighting back.

According to Human Rights Watch, at least 69 countries have laws criminalizing same-sex relations between consenting adults and at least nine countries have laws criminalizing forms of gender expression that target transgender and gender nonconforming people. While the law is explicit in some of these countries, many are purposefully vague and euphemistic, often reflecting antiquated language from colonial-era “buggery” and “sodomy” laws. Amid this context, queer and trans people across the world are constantly devising ways to survive.

Transnational moves beyond the typical violence of trans news stories to understand the unseen movement work that often follows, whether it be providing one another with alternative forms of healthcare, establishing safe houses for recently outed trans people, or offering rehabilitation services for trans people who are struggling to survive. It also aims to make clear that, although Western media outlets tend to dominate stories about trans activism, trans people are building movements all over the world.
 
Vice's next story: Why are Detroit, Mexico City, and Lagos so violent for trans people?

Fucking Detroit lmao.
 
I'm all for this, because this means that we could be rid of two evils at once when they 41% themselves, a journo and a troon.
 
Because otherwise they can’t find enough narcissistic, chronically dishonest, sociopaths to fill out their writing pools.
 
Keep it coming Vice.
You just keep making it harder for my Demi Lovato-loving, "Vice-is-still-real-counter-culture", neo-centrist cousin to justify you. It makes for great Thursday lunch talk.

such as the incorrect argument that puberty blockers are inherently dangerous
Stop making it so obvious you hate children.

...or the inaccurate assumption that trans women have an inherent advantage over cis women athletes.
lol give a russian inmate that hasn't seen a woman in 10 years a wig and let him have 5 minutes alone with your sister.

This bit in particular is great in laughing at contemporary feminists who have low-key regrets of endorsing ill men.
 
Last edited:
Is there even a single one that in the real world would be considered a journalist?
 
Here's the really dumb thing, I've been to Detroit a lot. There's a gay community there, it's just across 8 mile and called Ferndale. It's a whole fucking city ffs.

No one runs ads and all that shit because there's no one there and the ones who are fucking broke. Great journalism there Vice.
 
We're dealing with less than 1% of the population, significantly less so if we only count people who have or are transitioning (so we don't count all the weird permutations of 'queer' and we just settle on people who are transitioning from one gender to the other).
So that's already a small pool. Now you further shrink that pool by those who want to be journalists, unless they're inferring that they'll somehow force people to be journalists.

So where are these trans journalists suppose to come from?

I think I know what's happening. Some years ago I remember a survey in which they asked people to guess what percentage of the population is gay and lesbian https://psmag.com/social-justice/there-arent-as-many-gay-people-as-you-think
The study's first finding is that "the public tends to consistently overestimate the size of the gay and lesbian population." The average guess in 1977 was between 10 and 19 percent; in 2013, it had increased to 23 percent.

Gallup reported in 2015 that 3.8 percent of Americans identify as gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender.

I suspect what we have here is stupid people who only learn about the world through social media, where there is a concerted effort to over represent LGBTQQIAA2SP+ individuals, and so they've developed a distorted view on reality to the point where they're vastly over estimating the number of trans people.
 
Yeah, All jurnos should be trannies. I mean it wouldn't change much, but perhaps increase the T level of said blogging nobodies.
It’s been over six years since TIME Magazine notoriously declared that America had reached the “Transgender Tipping Point” with a cover featuring Orange is the New Black star Laverne Cox.
Yeah, it just appeared out of nowhere and got spammed hard by propaganda outlets.
These bills largely rely on a tangle of myths and misinformation related to trans people, such as the incorrect argument that puberty blockers are inherently dangerous
Why it incorrect? It is designed to mess up the natural development of the body, thus it is harmful.
 
You fucking heathens, can't you see the transgender community is in pain? Why must you deny them the dream of being journalists?

Then if roughly half of transgender journalists were to kill themselves who are we to stand in their way and deny their end of life wishes?

The only question then is what happens to the other 50%.
 
We're dealing with less than 1% of the population, significantly less so if we only count people who have or are transitioning (so we don't count all the weird permutations of 'queer' and we just settle on people who are transitioning from one gender to the other).
So that's already a small pool. Now you further shrink that pool by those who want to be journalists, unless they're inferring that they'll somehow force people to be journalists.

So where are these trans journalists suppose to come from?

I think I know what's happening. Some years ago I remember a survey in which they asked people to guess what percentage of the population is gay and lesbian https://psmag.com/social-justice/there-arent-as-many-gay-people-as-you-think
The study's first finding is that "the public tends to consistently overestimate the size of the gay and lesbian population." The average guess in 1977 was between 10 and 19 percent; in 2013, it had increased to 23 percent.

Gallup reported in 2015 that 3.8 percent of Americans identify as gay, lesbian, bisexual, or transgender.

I suspect what we have here is stupid people who only learn about the world through social media, where there is a concerted effort to over represent LGBTQQIAA2SP+ individuals, and so they've developed a distorted view on reality to the point where they're vastly over estimating the number of trans people.

They are way too over represented in the media. It's even bleeding into shows for toddlers. Just look at that freak who sang about tranny animals on Blues Clues. If they are trying to increase their numbers by normalizing degeneracy it's working. All the kids identifying as trans who wouldn't have done so even a decade ago is horrifying.

Stop normalizing puberty blockers. :mad:
 
Back
Top Bottom