#Comicsgate - The Culture Wars Hit The Funny Books!

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Probably not the place to mention this but...here you go fellas https://wegotthiscovered.com/movies/x-men-marvel-mcu-professor-x-magneto/

The comments section:
lolwut Magneto.PNG


The KKK?! The Klan has been irrelevant and toothless for decades now. How is the audience supposed to relate to the characters if you bring up something only a fraction of the populace even experiences on a daily basis? This person must be a boomer or an SJW (or both).
 
Probably not the place to mention this but...here you go fellas https://wegotthiscovered.com/movies/x-men-marvel-mcu-professor-x-magneto/

Any bets on Idris Elba getting picked?

Elba IIRC has been signed for Suicide Squad, playing Bronze Tiger (a formerly brainwashed and crazy fury who ran around with a fursuit tiger costume head on that killed Batwoman but then got deprogrammed and became one of the token good guys on SS). So most likely not going to happen. Especially since he got snubbed for Black Panther.
 
Elba IIRC has been signed for Suicide Squad, playing Bronze Tiger (a formerly brainwashed and crazy fury who ran around with a fursuit tiger costume head on that killed Batwoman but then got deprogrammed and became one of the token good guys on SS). So most likely not going to happen. Especially since he got snubbed for Black Panther.
Wasn't he already in three Thor movies and Avengers: Infinity War anyway?
 
Elba IIRC has been signed for Suicide Squad, playing Bronze Tiger (a formerly brainwashed and crazy fury who ran around with a fursuit tiger costume head on that killed Batwoman but then got deprogrammed and became one of the token good guys on SS). So most likely not going to happen. Especially since he got snubbed for Black Panther.
If Bats shows up in that one too, I wanna see Bronze Tiger hand him his ass since he one of the few martial characters that is actually allowed to do that and get away with it.

Wasn't he already in three Thor movies and Avengers: Infinity War anyway?
Yeah, but I think that character is still dead
 
The comments section:
View attachment 935087

The KKK?! The Klan has been irrelevant and toothless for decades now. How is the audience supposed to relate to the characters if you bring up something only a fraction of the populace even experiences on a daily basis? This person must be a boomer or an SJW (or both).

I'm pretty sure the Klan was never known for its prowess with scientific experiments or, for that matter, even having teeth.
 
But where is the flashdrive of porn?
That was Randy Pitchford, the Borderlands guy.

As for Magneto, I believe one of the changes Marvel has introduced to their history (in part designed by Waid) is that, to keep their timeframe working, instead of real wars like WW2 and Vietnam as being part of characters' history, there's going to have been a nebulous, fictional war against a fictional country that will have permanently been around 15 years ago, that all the characters who have war ties, I imagine from Red Skull to Magneto to original Nick Fury and so on, will have been part of.

It's an interesting creative move, but I think very stupid, especially for characters from the Second World War like Magneto. What makes him such an interesting villain and sympathetic character who you can see changing sides like he has repeatedly is that he has a deep, personal connection to the attempts to wipe out an entire race, and that informs how he sees mutants versus humanity. The analogy just doesn't work as well with any other group or time period in the last century of history, so trying to change it to the struggles of African Americans in the 60s isn't nearly the same as genocide.

Who'd have thought, Waid would be involved in a story-telling decision that sounds like it solves some problems while actually deeply damaging legacy characters...
 
It's an interesting creative move, but I think very stupid, especially for characters from the Second World War like Magneto. What makes him such an interesting villain and sympathetic character who you can see changing sides like he has repeatedly is that he has a deep, personal connection to the attempts to wipe out an entire race, and that informs how he sees mutants versus humanity. The analogy just doesn't work as well with any other group or time period in the last century of history, so trying to change it to the struggles of African Americans in the 60s isn't nearly the same as genocide.
I agree with you 100%.

If they just want to reference a more recent conflict I would go with Bosnia and Herzegovina which would put him in his 30s to 40s and would still have some effective recognition due to the war crimes and ethnic cleanse. If I were going to make a change to Magneto's back story and heritage to something new with a more modern reference, with the stipulation that it is done so they can execute a race swap and get similar effect, it would depend on what age they want him now. If want him in his late 30s to 40s make him Rwandan or in his 20s to early 30s make him Darfurian, both of those conflicts have some decent recognition factor and both included accusations of genocides/ethnic cleansing too.

But still prefer his original back story, it just so effective as a shorthand to get a person unfamiliar with the character to completely understand him.
 
That was Randy Pitchford, the Borderlands guy.

As for Magneto, I believe one of the changes Marvel has introduced to their history (in part designed by Waid) is that, to keep their timeframe working, instead of real wars like WW2 and Vietnam as being part of characters' history, there's going to have been a nebulous, fictional war against a fictional country that will have permanently been around 15 years ago, that all the characters who have war ties, I imagine from Red Skull to Magneto to original Nick Fury and so on, will have been part of.

It's an interesting creative move, but I think very stupid, especially for characters from the Second World War like Magneto. What makes him such an interesting villain and sympathetic character who you can see changing sides like he has repeatedly is that he has a deep, personal connection to the attempts to wipe out an entire race, and that informs how he sees mutants versus humanity. The analogy just doesn't work as well with any other group or time period in the last century of history, so trying to change it to the struggles of African Americans in the 60s isn't nearly the same as genocide.

Who'd have thought, Waid would be involved in a story-telling decision that sounds like it solves some problems while actually deeply damaging legacy characters...
It's just another pointless retcon that will be abandoned the next time Marvel has an editorial shakeup like all the other stupid shit they've done over the decades.

Don't know why they bothered though, kids don't read comics these days.
 
...so Cap never punched Hitler.

Also: would this new fictional conflict somehow involve the Nazis in order to create the updated Magneto...or will Marvel's woke creative staff have to admit that Africans generally have no problem genociding other Africans for shits and giggles?

The more I think about this whole thing, the worse it becomes. So they're seriously going to just shove everyone into a single conflict despite there being no shortage of wars in the real world?

"The World Outside Your Window", my ass.
 
...so Cap never punched Hitler.

Also: would this new fictional conflict somehow involve the Nazis in order to create the updated Magneto...or will Marvel's woke creative staff have to admit that Africans generally have no problem genociding other Africans for shits and giggles?

The more I think about this whole thing, the worse it becomes. So they're seriously going to just shove everyone into a single conflict despite there being no shortage of wars in the real world?

"The World Outside Your Window", my ass.

I would assume that Cap's story is kept intact since he was always frozen for an inordinate amount of time and then revived. You don't have to change WW2 for him because he didn't age while frozen.
 
I would assume that Cap's story is kept intact since he was always frozen for an inordinate amount of time and then revived. You don't have to change WW2 for him because he didn't age while frozen.
If they want to keep him young, just have one of the dozens of immortality ploys they've invented over the years to rationalize it away; be it a clone body, the fountain of youth, or anything you can dig up, you should be fine with him. It's not hard to make up reasons for this too; have Magneto just take it so he can ensure that mutants finally have their place in the world since he believes and so wants to see that day himself.

Seriously, it's not that hard to rationalize it in a world where fucking Romulus Augustulus is still kicking as a villain.
 
He is seriously pulling a "I'm not mad, I'm just disappointed."

Curtis: "Vox day is a Nazzzi and you shouldn't asociate with him"

Edwin: "Lol, I do what I want"

Curtis: Makes a 20 minute video about how assblasted he is

Edit: It's also important to point out the amazing "They aren't true Christians! I'm a better Christian then them!" statement he makes. Exceptional tactics.
 
So Zack said in a video today that Jawbreakers is fully lettered and he thinks it may still be possible to ship by the end of September. I will not be even remotely surprised if people start receiving Jawbreakers before Cyberfrog even ships.
 
Back
Top Bottom