The Hugos don't have judges, much less final ones. They're purely a write-in popularity contest accessible to anyone who wants to pay the $50 to be a supporting member of the World Science Fiction Society. That's why the "all awards for NK Jemisin forever" crowd lost their shit at the idea of other people merely getting organized to vote for people they didn't like and counter-organized to vote "No Award" in the categories where nobody meeting their approval made it onto the ballot. But it's also kind of bullshit to pretend the Puppies were solely interested in getting good ol' fashioned adventure scifi (as opposed to message scifi) into the awards when they're the ones who nominated Chuck Tingle onto the slate, while anyone familiar with Chuck's grift would have known he was a liberal and likely to pull something tediously "zany" to spite them.