The Quest for... Win?: White-Kettle Shufflepunk Reads Harry Potter

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
I like how Barty basically explains his own plan for no other reason than to pat himself on the back. "Only a badass dark wizard with the cleverest mind and the biggest dick could have pulled off such a scheme!"
Supposedly Crowley is such a good actor that he can fool even Dumbledore, so this is just how he talks. Although, Moody doesn't strike me as the "grudging respect for the enemy" sort. I guess that means that the ferret incident was entirely in-character.
 
When Harry woke up on Sunday morning, it took him a moment to remember why he felt so miserable and worried.

1772780782897.png


I bet I could do an entire post in Simpsons bits.

Harry dressed and went down the spiral staircase into the common room. The moment he appeared, the people who had already finished breakfast broke into applause again. The prospect of going down into the Great Hall and facing the rest of the Gryffindors, all treating him like some sort of hero, was not inviting; it was that, however, or stay here and allow himself to be cornered by the Creevey brothers, who were both beckoning frantically to him to join them.

1772780902814.png

You can't stop me.

They went downstairs, crossed the entrance hall quickly without looking in at the Great Hall, and were soon striding across the lawn toward the lake, where the Durmstrang ship was moored, reflected blackly in the water. It was a chilly morning, and they kept moving, munching their toast, as Harry told Hermione exactly what had happened after he had left the Gryffindor table the night before. To his immense relief, Hermione accepted his story without question.

“Well, of course I knew you hadn’t entered yourself,” she said when he’d finished telling her about the scene in the chamber off the Hall. “The look on your face when Dumbledore read out your name!

(Fine, I'll do my job)

Hear that? It's a million Harmonian shippers drooling. Hermione naturally starts speculating who could've tricked the Goblet, but Harry has other things on his mind.

“Have you seen Ron?” Harry interrupted.
“Erm … yes … he was at breakfast,” she said.

“Does he still think I entered myself?”

“Well … no, I don’t think so … not really,” said Hermione awkwardly.

“What’s that supposed to mean, ‘not really’?”

“Oh Harry, isn’t it obvious?” Hermione said despairingly. “He’s jealous!”

“Jealous?” Harry said incredulously. “Jealous of what? He wants to make a prat of himself in front of the whole school, does he?”

Fred and/or George would probably be down to compete in clown outfits. They'd still try their best, but they'd definitely meme it up a bit.

“Look,” said Hermione patiently, “it’s always you who gets all the attention, you know it is. I know it’s not your fault,” she added quickly, seeing Harry open his mouth furiously. “I know you don’t ask for it … but — well — you know, Ron’s got all those brothers to compete against at home, and you’re his best friend, and you’re really famous — he’s always shunted to one side whenever people see you, and he puts up with it, and he never mentions it, but I suppose this is just one time too many. …”

“Great,” said Harry bitterly. “Really great. Tell him from me I’ll swap any time he wants. Tell him from me he’s welcome to it. … People gawping at my forehead everywhere I go. …”

The great irony here is that Rowling is writing this conflict from an adult's perspective--one whose job once involved observing teenagers all day, no less. She understands perfectly well that Ron is being unreasonable and unfair, but also that his emotions come from a human Fanfic writers, meanwhile, are mostly teenagers themselves, or people who still write in the mode of teenagers, who cannot possibly imagine forgiving Ron's slight. This sort of petty squabble really hits home for them, but they don't have the distance or maturity to see it for what it is. Thus, Harry eventually forgiving Ron and moving on seems unthinkable. Of course, a silent majority of young readers probably do see what Rowling is getting at, but that type of person is somewhat less motivated to go online and write a twenty-four chapter fanfic about how it's not a big deal two long time friends had an ugly fight when they were fourteen.

Actually, that sums up the difference between Rowling and a lot of the authors we've covered together. Authors like the Casts or Card understand their readers enough to mirror their emotions, but all they do is validate them without interrogation. Yes, being an attractive, socially popular teenage girl at a posh private school is the hardest thing in the world. Yes, you are a genius trapped in a child's body, and all the adults in your either don't understand you or want to use you for their own grubby ends. It's emotional onanism.

Rowling, conversely, sees your pain, empathises, and gently--with all the kindness in the world--tells you to grow up, dear. No wonder the internet turned on her.
“I’m not telling him anything,” Hermione said shortly. “Tell him yourself. It’s the only way to sort this out.”

“I’m not running around after him trying to make him grow up!” Harry said, so loudly that several owls in a nearby tree took flight in alarm. “Maybe he’ll believe I’m not enjoying myself once I’ve got my neck broken or —”

“That’s not funny,” said Hermione quietly. “That’s not funny at all.”

Don't think Hermione gets off scot free either. While many fanfics do pair up Harry and Hermione against red headed step-child Ron, many also take this demonstration of clear-thinking emotional intelligence as proof she also hates Harry and is plotting to do Camp of the Saints but for mudbloods.

Since she's on a break from being dumb, Hermione tells Harry he should maybe he should write Sirius. Harry balks, but Hermione points out that Sirius is definitely going to find out whatever Harry does or doesn't do.

Whose owl am I going to use?” Harry said as they climbed the stairs. “He told me not to use Hedwig again.”

“Ask Ron if you can borrow —”

“I’m not asking Ron for anything,” Harry said flatly.

“Well, borrow one of the school owls, then, anyone can use them,” said Hermione.

I'd say that's fucking stupid but Dumbledore knows Sirius is innocent. Harry sends Sirius a letter that says exactly what you'd expect it to.

“Finished,” he told Hermione, getting to his feet and brushing straw off his robes. At this, Hedwig came fluttering down onto his shoulder and held out her leg.

“I can’t use you,” Harry told her, looking around for the school owls. “I’ve got to use one of these. …”

Hedwig gave a very loud hoot and took off so suddenly that her talons cut into his shoulder. She kept her back to Harry all the time he was tying his letter to the leg of a large barn owl. When the barn owl had flown off, Harry reached out to stroke Hedwig, but she clicked her beak furiously and soared up into the rafters out of reach.

“First Ron, then you,” said Harry angrily. “This isn’t my fault.

One issue both writers and performers have to deal with is that anger--being an often irrational thing--can be very funny to outside observers. I absolutely get Harry, I've been there, but there's no way him sulking about his owl betraying him isn't going to be at least a little funny.

If Harry had thought that matters would improve once everyone got used to the idea of him being champion, the following day showed him how mistaken he was. He could no longer avoid the rest of the school once he was back at lessons — and it was clear that the rest of the school, just like the Gryffindors, thought Harry had entered himself for the tournament. Unlike the Gryffindors, however, they did not seem impressed.

As I mentioned in book one, in most installments, Harry tends to spend much of the term being the school outcast. So far the only exception has been book three, but there he was the sad freak boy who couldn't go on the class trip, so it evened out. This time, the Hufflepuffs especially aren't so hot on Harry, for much the same reasons fans of The Batman sometimes give that Gunnverse Batman thing dirty looks.

(They should make Mr. Freeze the baddie in The Batman 2. It'd kill)

He would have been looking forward to seeing Hagrid under normal circumstances, but Care of Magical Creatures meant seeing the Slytherins too — the first time he would come face-to-face with them since becoming champion.

Predictably, Malfoy arrived at Hagrid’s cabin with his familiar sneer firmly in place.

You'd think Malfoy would've transferred after last year. Eh, maybe he had a plan to get Hagrid fired this year, but decided that the Skrewts would probably do it for him. Also, speaking of the Skrewts, you know Harry is a good friend when seeing them doesn't outweigh seeing Hagrid.

Crabbe and Goyle guffawed sycophantically, but Malfoy had to stop there, because Hagrid emerged from the back of his cabin balancing a teetering tower of crates, each containing a very large Blast-Ended Skrewt. To the class’s horror, Hagrid proceeded to explain that the reason the skrewts had been killing one another was an excess of pent-up energy, and that the solution would be for each student to fix a leash on a skrewt and take it for a short walk. The only good thing about this plan was that it distracted Malfoy completely.

The trio, having their blood drained by a broody Blast-Ended Skrewt: At least Draco isn't happy!

Hagrid’s real intention, however, was to talk to Harry away from the rest of the class. He waited until everyone else had set off with their skrewts, then turned to Harry and said, very seriously, “So — yer competin’, Harry. In the tournament. School champion.”

“One of the champions,” Harry corrected him.

Hagrid’s beetle-black eyes looked very anxious under his wild eyebrows.

“No idea who put yeh in fer it, Harry?”

“You believe I didn’t do it, then?” said Harry, concealing with difficulty the rush of gratitude he felt at Hagrid’s words.

“ ’Course I do,” Hagrid grunted. “Yeh say it wasn’ you, an’ I believe yeh — an’ Dumbledore believes yer, an’ all.”

"If Dumbledore thought yeh did it, tho, I'd 'ave terned on yeh like that!"

The pair of them looked out over the lawn; the class was widely scattered now, and all in great difficulty. The skrewts were now over three feet long, and extremely powerful. No longer shell-less and colorless, they had developed a kind of thick, grayish, shiny armor. They looked like a cross between giant scorpions and elongated crabs — but still without recognizable heads or eyes. They had become immensely strong and very hard to control.

“Look like they’re havin’ fun, don’ they?” Hagrid said happily. Harry assumed he was talking about the skrewts, because his classmates certainly weren’t; every now and then, with an alarming bang, one of the skrewts’ ends would explode, causing it to shoot forward several yards, and more than one person was being dragged along on their stomach, trying desperately to get back on their feet.

I guess if you want to argue for this as anything but a demented waste of time, if these kids can handle skrewts, they can handle anything.

(And then a dragon steps on them)

“Ah, I don’ know, Harry,” Hagrid sighed suddenly, looking back down at him with a worried expression on his face. “School champion … everythin’ seems ter happen ter you, doesn’ it?”

Oh, God, he's seen us!

The next few days were some of Harry’s worst at Hogwarts. The closest he had ever come to feeling like this had been during those months, in his second year, when a large part of the school had suspected him of attacking his fellow students.

Really? I'd have compared it to the hundred and fifty points loss in book one. At least nobody right now thinks you're liable to petrify them.

But Ron had been on his side then. He thought he could have coped with the rest of the school’s behavior if he could just have had Ron back as a friend, but he wasn’t going to try and persuade Ron to talk to him if Ron didn’t want to.

See, Rowling knows the worst thing about not having Ron on your side is a lack of Ron!

e could understand the Hufflepuffs’ attitude, even if he didn’t like it; they had their own champion to support. He expected nothing less than vicious insults from the Slytherins —he was highly unpopular there and always had been, because he had helped Gryffindor beat them so often, both at Quidditch and in the Inter-House Championship. But he had hoped the Ravenclaws might have found it in their hearts to support him as much as Cedric. He was wrong, however. Most Ravenclaws seemed to think that he had been desperate to earn himself a bit more fame by tricking the goblet into accepting his name.

Nobody at this school has much pattern recognition. "Yeah, he may have saved us all from horror and death twice over, but this time he's definitely just being a little shit!"

(I don't think you can say Harry saved the school or anything last book. Even if anyone knew what really went on, if anything, Crookshanks was the hero of that story.)

Professor Trelawney was predicting his death with even more certainty than usual, and he did so badly at Summoning Charms in Professor Flitwick’s class that he was given extra homework — the only person to get any, apart from Neville.

To be fair, it gets a lot easier once you unlock the ability to flick through multiple sets of spell, even if you have to do that dumb quest first.

When he and Hermione arrived at Snape’s dungeon after lunch, they found the Slytherins waiting outside, each and every one of them wearing a large badge on the front of his or her robes. For one wild moment Harry thought they were S.P.E.W. badges

To be fair, Draco wouldn't be the first privileged little prick to hitch himself to some radical cause. Plus, as we established, Draco is at least spiritually Pakistani; I'm pretty sure they're they've got their own stripe on the progress flag.

-- then he saw that
they all bore the same message, in luminous red letters that burnt brightly in the dimly lit underground passage:

Support CEDRIC DIGGORY —

The REAL Hogwarts Champion

“Like them, Potter?” said Malfoy loudly as Harry approached. “And this isn’t all they do — look!”

He pressed his badge into his chest, and the message upon it vanished, to be replaced by another one, which glowed green:

POTTER STINKS

The Slytherins howled with laughter. Each of them pressed their badges too, until the message POTTER STINKS was shining brightly all around Harry. He felt the heat rise in his face and neck.

Imagine being Cedric Diggory--a top bloke, to be clear--and you find out Draco Malfoy of all fucking people is selling your merch. Next people are going to think he actually liked Twilight.

"Want one, Granger?” said Malfoy, holding out a badge to Hermione. “I’ve got loads. But don’t touch my hand, now. I’ve just washed it, you see; don’t want a Mudblood sliming it up.”

The Draco Trilogy went so far as to literally steal Blackadder's dialogue (and we're talking the smart Blackadder, not series one Blackadder, who was much closer to actual Draco) and give it to Draco. Meanwhile the best canon Draco can do is "I don't want to get your nigger germs on me!"

Some of the anger Harry had been feeling for days and days seemed to burst through a dam in his chest. He had reached for his wand before he’d thought what he was doing. People all around them scrambled out of the way, backing down the corridor.

“Harry!” Hermione said warningly.

“Go on, then, Potter,” Malfoy said quietly, drawing out his own wand. “Moody’s not here to look after you now — do it, if you’ve got the guts —”

For a split second, they looked into each other’s eyes, then, at exactly the same time, both acted.

“Furnunculus!” Harry yelled.

You know Harry is pissed when he remembers a second spell exists. Also, Harry, that wasn't your anger, Ron just lent you some of his.

“Densaugeo!” screamed Malfoy.

Jets of light shot from both wands, hit each other in midair, and ricocheted off at angles — Harry’s hit Goyle in the face, and Malfoy’s hit Hermione. Goyle bellowed and put his hands to his nose, where great ugly boils were springing up — Hermione, whimpering in panic, was clutching her mouth.

Notice this is way cooler than just doing a DBZ style Beam-O-War like the movies do.

“Hermione!”

Ron had hurried forward to see what was wrong with her; Harry turned and saw Ron dragging Hermione’s hand away from her face. It wasn’t a pretty sight. Hermione’s front teeth — already larger than average — were now growing at an alarming rate; she was looking more and more like a beaver as her teeth elongated, past her bottom lip, toward her chin — panic-stricken, she felt them and let out a terrified cry.

1772813146123.png


Every occasion. It's like the Bible.

It's okay, though, Snape's here. He might be a crotchety old geezer, but he's not going to stand--

Snape examined Goyle, whose face now resembled something that would have been at home in a book on poisonous fungi.

“Hospital wing, Goyle,” Snape said calmly.

“Malfoy got Hermione!” Ron said. “Look!”

He forced Hermione to show Snape her teeth — she was doing her best to hide them with her hands, though this was difficult as they had now grown down past her collar. Pansy Parkinson and the other Slytherin girls were doubled up with silent giggles, pointing at Hermione from behind Snape’s back.

Snape looked coldly at Hermione, then said, “I see no difference.”

Oh yeah, Snape's just kind of horrible.

Hermione let out a whimper; her eyes filled with tears, she turned on her heel and ran, ran all the way up the corridor and out of sight.

It was lucky, perhaps, that both Harry and Ron started shouting at Snape at the same time; lucky their voices echoed so much in the stone corridor, for in the confused din, it was impossible for him to hear exactly what they were calling him. He got the gist, however.

“Let’s see,” he said, in his silkiest voice. “Fifty points from Gryffindor and a detention each for Potter and Weasley. Now get inside, or it’ll be a week’s worth of detentions.”

I feel like it says something about how the books have changed that the boys losing a hundred points is just punctuation now.

Harry’s ears were ringing. The injustice of it made him want to curse Snape into a thousand slimy pieces.

I wouldn't. Aside from getting you in hot water, I bet being murdered by Lily and James's son would fulfil some psychosexual complex on Snape's part.

He passed Snape, walked with Ron to the back of the dungeon, and slammed his bag down onto the table. Ron was shaking with anger too — for a moment, it felt as though everything was back to normal between them, but then Ron turned and sat down with Dean and Seamus instead, leaving Harry alone at his table.

Tragic. They could've teamed up and tortured Snape to death together.

Harry sat there staring at Snape as the lesson began, picturing horrific things happening to him. … If only he knew how to do the Cruciatus Curse … he’d have Snape flat on his Harry sat there staring at Snape as the lesson began, picturing horrific things happening to him. … If only he knew how to do the Cruciatus Curse … he’d have Snape flat on his back like that spider, jerking and twitching.

See, the difference between Harry and Danny Tozer is Harry doesn't know the fuck he's talking about. Yet.

“Antidotes!” said Snape, looking around at them all, his cold black eyes glittering unpleasantly. “You should all have prepared your recipes now. I want you to brew them carefully, and then, we will be selecting someone on whom to test one. …”

Snape’s eyes met Harry’s, and Harry knew what was coming. Snape was going to poison him. Harry imagined picking up his cauldron, and sprinting to the front of the class, and bringing it down on Snape’s greasy head —

I'm guessing the poison is some whimsically unpleasant shit like Potion of Itching, but imagine if Snape just murdered Harry in the middle of class one day.

And then a knock on the dungeon door burst in on Harry’s thoughts.

It was Colin Creevey; he edged into the room, beaming at Harry, and walked up to Snape’s desk at the front of the room.

Snape: Well, Potter, will you be able to save--

Harry: This is way less scary for me than you might think, Professor.

Nah, Colin is here with a message.

“Please, sir, I’m supposed to take Harry Potter upstairs.”

Snape stared down his hooked nose at Colin, whose smile faded from his eager face.

“Potter has another hour of Potions to complete,” said Snape coldly. “He will come upstairs when this class is finished.”

Colin went pink.

“Sir — sir, Mr. Bagman wants him,” he said nervously. “All the champions have got to go, I think they want to take photographs. …”

Harry would have given anything he owned to have stopped Colin saying those last few words. He chanced half a glance at Ron, but Ron was staring determinedly at the ceiling.

“Very well, very well,” Snape snapped. “Potter, leave your things here, I want you back down here later to test your antidote.”

Snape then spent the rest of the class angrily masturbating in full view of everyone.

Bagman suddenly spotted Harry, got up quickly, and bounded forward.

“Ah, here he is! Champion number four! In you come, Harry, in you come … nothing to worry about, it’s just the wand weighing ceremony, the rest of the judges will be here in a moment —”

“Wand weighing?” Harry repeated nervously.

“We have to check that your wands are fully functional, no problems, you know, as they’re your most important tools in the tasks ahead,” said Bagman. “The expert’s upstairs now with Dumbledore. And then there’s going to be a little photo shoot. This is Rita Skeeter,” he added, gesturing toward the witch in magenta robes. “She’s doing a small piece on the tournament for the Daily Prophet. …”

The woman; the legend; Uncle Vernon's love interest in that one comedy edit!

“Maybe not that small, Ludo,” said Rita Skeeter, her eyes on Harry.

Her hair was set in elaborate and curiously rigid curls that contrasted oddly with her heavy-jawed face. She wore jeweled spectacles. The thick fingers clutching her crocodile-skin handbag ended in two-inch nails, painted crimson.

Yeah, Rita is often brought up as evidence of Rowling being the Transphobic Riddler and seeding it through her books. However, I would remind you all this book was written in 1999 and 2000. Barely anyone was thinking about trans stuff back then. A handsome or mannish woman was probably just an allegory for a handsome or mannish woman. If I were to guess, Rowling was probably picturing like, Dame Edna or one of the Pythons, like a less horny version of when lazier writers outright tell you a character looked like X movie star.

Rita would like to speak to Harry before the proceedings. In a closet. Alone. Okay, maybe I was wrong.

“Testing … my name is Rita Skeeter, Daily Prophet reporter.”

Harry looked down quickly at the quill. The moment Rita Skeeter had spoken, the green quill had started to scribble, skidding across the parchment:

Attractive blonde Rita Skeeter, forty-three, whose savage quill has punctured many inflated reputations —

Rowling: Let's see, it's 1994, she's forty-three years old... that must mean she was born in... 1878!

Okay, is the quill tethered to Rita via telepathy, or is it essentially a chatbot that could probably Rita's job for her long after she's dead?

“Lovely,” said Rita Skeeter, yet again, and she ripped the top piece of parchment off, crumpled it up, and stuffed it into her handbag. Now she leaned toward Harry and said, “So, Harry … what made you decide to enter the Triwizard Tournament?”

“Er —” said Harry again, but he was distracted by the quill. Even though he wasn’t speaking, it was dashing across the parchment, and in its wake he could make out a fresh sentence:

An ugly scar, souvenir of a tragic past, disfigures the otherwise charming face of Harry Potter, whose eyes —


I wonder if Rita was inspired by Rowling's first encounters with the press. Harry insists he didn't enter himself, but Rita brushes this off.

“Of course, you’ve looked death in the face before, haven’t you?” said Rita Skeeter, watching him closely. “How would you say that’s affected you?”

“Er,” said Harry, yet again.

“Do you think that the trauma in your past might have made you keen to prove yourself? To live up to your name? Do you think that perhaps you were tempted to enter the Triwizard Tournament because —”

“I didn’t enter,” said Harry, starting to feel irritated.

“Can you remember your parents at all?” said Rita Skeeter, talking over him.

“No,” said Harry.

Again, hard not to imagine Rowling had some similar experiences being interviewed as a new author with a somewhat heavy past.

“How do you think they’d feel if they knew you were competing in the Triwizard Tournament? Proud? Worried? Angry?”

Harry was feeling really annoyed now. How on earth was he to know how his parents would feel if they were alive? He could feel Rita Skeeter watching him very intently. Frowning, he avoided her gaze and looked down at words the quill had just written:

Tears fill those startling green eyes as our conversation turns to the parents he can barely remember.

Is Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire the most prescient cyberpunk novel ever written?

“I have NOT got tears in my eyes!” said Harry loudly.

Before Rita Skeeter could say a word, the door of the broom cupboard was pulled open. Harry looked around, blinking in the bright light. Albus Dumbledore stood there, looking down at both of them, squashed into the cupboard.

“Dumbledore!” cried Rita Skeeter, with every appearance of delight — but Harry noticed that her quill and the parchment had suddenly vanished from the box of Magical Mess Remover, and Rita’s clawed fingers were hastily snapping shut the clasp of her crocodile-skin bag. “How are you?” she said, standing up and holding out one of her large, mannish hands to Dumbledore. “I hope you saw my piece over the summer about the International Confederation of Wizards’ Conference?”
“Enchantingly nasty,” said Dumbledore, his eyes twinkling. “I particularly enjoyed your description of me as an obsolete dingbat.”

Rita Skeeter didn’t look remotely abashed.

“I was just making the point that some of your ideas are a little old-fashioned, Dumbledore, and that many wizards in the street —”

I do kind of like that that Rita isn't at all flustered when face-to-face with one of her punching bags. Even bad people can have a kind of virtue. Anyway, it's time to inspect everyone's wands.

“May I introduce Mr. Ollivander?” said Dumbledore, taking his place at the judges’ table and talking to the champions. “He will be checking your wands to ensure that they are in good condition before the tournament.”

Harry looked around, and with a jolt of surprise saw an old wizard with large, pale eyes standing quietly by the window. Harry had met Mr. Ollivander before — he was the wand-maker from whom Harry had bought his own wand over three years ago in Diagon Alley.

I'm not going to hold it against the film for cutting this particular scene--it's exactly the sort of scene that gets cut--but it's a shame we didn't get more John Hurt. Also, I should've mentioned this during the last book, but movie three also saw a change in how wands were depicted. In the first couple of films, the wand props were, for lack of a better word, fairly utilitarian. There were differences in colour and length, sure, but they were all pretty simple polished wooden rods with fairly plain handles. Fun fact, the reason Seamus Finnegan was always blowing shit up in the movies wasn't because of Rowling's Pearl-esque hatred for the Irish, but rather because his actor had a habit of breaking his wands.

When he was making the third film, Alfonso Cuarón decided to spice things up by introducing more customised wand props, which I'm sure Rowling appreciates, because you can now buy replicas of them. He even had a bunch of different designs made up, and had each of the trio's actors pick the one they felt best suited the character, which is pretty rad.

“Mademoiselle Delacour, could we have you first, please?” said Mr. Ollivander, stepping into the empty space in the middle of the room.

Fleur Delacour swept over to Mr. Ollivander and handed him her wand.

“Hmmm …” he said.

He twirled the wand between his long fingers like a baton and it emitted a number of pink and gold sparks. Then he held it close to his eyes and examined it carefully.

“Yes,” he said quietly, “nine and a half inches … inflexible … rosewood … and containing … dear me …”

“An ’air from ze ’ead of a veela,” said Fleur. “One of my grandmuzzer’s.”

So Fleur was part veela, thought Harry, making a mental note to tell Ron … then he remembered that Ron wasn’t speaking to him.

"Veela" is an alternate spelling of vila, a type of Slavic fairy-thing, a bit like a friendlier rusalka. They usually appear as attractive women, and sometimes do the whole lure men to their doom shtick, but are also known to aid people and intermarry with humans, producing offspring with unusual beauty or powers. In fact, in some places, vila was specifically a term for magicians whose powers derived from fairies in some way. Your basic nature spirit or nymph, basically. I'm guessing the part about Fleur's grandmother is a bit of a dark joke on Rowling's part, because according to some legends, if a vila's hair was plucked, they'd either die or turn into a monster. Eh, maybe they got it from her shower drain.

Is a bit funny that Fleur, the Frenchiest of French girls, is part Slavic monster person. Of course, someone having a grandmother from another country doesn't really qualify as an error or a plot hole, but if Rowling had wanted to make Fleur even more French, she could have made her gran a melusine, a kind of French water spirit or mermaid, though maybe that would've been an unfair advantage later.

Yes,” said Mr. Ollivander, “yes, I’ve never used veela hair myself, of course. I find it makes for rather temperamental wands … however, to each his own, and if this suits you …”

Mr. Ollivander ran his fingers along the wand, apparently checking for scratches or bumps; then he muttered, “Orchideous!” and a bunch of flowers burst from the wand tip.

I love how fanfic has all these unique wand cores, and canonically Ollivander doesn't use them because they're not as good.

“Ah, now, this is one of mine, isn’t it?” said Mr. Ollivander, with much more enthusiasm, as Cedric handed over his wand. “Yes, I remember it well. Containing a single hair from the tail of a particularly fine male unicorn … must have been seventeen hands; nearly gored me with his horn after I plucked his tail. Twelve and a quarter inches … ash … pleasantly springy. It’s in fine condition. … You treat it regularly?”

“Polished it last night,” said Cedric, grinning.

Harry looked down at his own wand. He could see finger marks all over it. He gathered a fistful of robe from his knee and tried to rub it clean surreptitiously. Several gold sparks shot out of the end of it. Fleur Delacour gave him a very patronizing look, and he desisted.

I don't blame Harry for neglecting his wand, he uses it much less than you'd expect. Also, Fleur may be patronising, but imagine if she was an African witch.

(She'd probably still own a wand because it's way easier using one to clean your socks than slaughtering a live chicken)

Viktor Krum got up and slouched, round-shouldered and duck-footed, toward Mr. Ollivander. He thrust out his wand and stood scowling, with his hands in the pockets of his robes.

“Hmm,” said Mr. Ollivander, “this is a Gregorovitch creation, unless I’m much mistaken? A fine wand-maker, though the styling is never quite what I … however …”

He lifted the wand and examined it minutely, turning it over and over before his eyes.

“Yes … hornbeam and dragon heartstring?” he shot at Krum, who nodded. “Rather thicker than one usually sees … quite rigid … ten and a quarter inches … Avis!”
The hornbeam wand let off a blast like a gun, and a number of small, twittering birds flew out of the end and through the open window into the watery sunlight.

Now I'm imagining Krum's wand basically being a truncheon.

Mr. Ollivander explained that the phoenix feather in Harry’s wand had come from the same bird that had supplied the core of Lord Voldemort’s.

Harry had never shared this piece of information with anybody. He was very fond of his wand, and as far as he was concerned its relation to Voldemort’s wand was something it couldn’t help — rather as he couldn’t help being related to Aunt Petunia.

Just as Harry couldn't help Petunia siphoning his blood every night to try and steal his powers. Harry has a very curt encounter with Ron in the common room, who tells him he has mail.

He then walked straight out of the room, not looking at Harry. For a moment, Harry considered going after him — he wasn’t sure whether he wanted to talk to him or hit him

--or kiss him.

Aside from the inevitable letter from Reader's Digest, Harry also got a reply from Sirius, telling him to ensure he's alone by the common room fire on the 22nd of November. I'm guessing Sirius is having Santa do an early weapons run.
 
A handsome or mannish woman was probably just an allegory for a handsome or mannish woman. If I were to guess, Rowling was probably picturing like, Dame Edna or one of the Pythons, like a less horny version of when lazier writers outright tell you a character looked like X movie star.

Yeah, Rita is absolutely inspired by Rowling's first brushes with fame. Also, this may be my Burgerlander bias showing, but I always pictured Rita as a slightly less dumpy Louella Parsons, even if Louella was a bit before Rowling's time (and American).

1772818766569.png
 
You'd think Malfoy would've transferred after last year. Eh, maybe he had a plan to get Hagrid fired this year, but decided that the Skrewts would probably do it for him.
Well, he has found himself in a doss subject where (after the Buckbeak incident) the teacher will be a bit wary of disciplining him in any serious way. It's basically mission accomplished already.

Also, Draco as S1 Blackadder is a quality image, and now I only wish we'd had him ordaining himself 'The Black Vegetable' at some point in book six. And, indeed, Lucius being played by Brian Blessed and constantly forgetting his own son's name.
 
The Draco Trilogy went so far as to literally steal Blackadder's dialogue (and we're talking the smart Blackadder, not series one Blackadder, who was much closer to actual Draco) and give it to Draco. Meanwhile the best canon Draco can do is "I don't want to get your nigger germs on me!"
Malfoy thinks he's Blackadder when, at best, he's a American bootleg Rimmer;
The woman; the legend; Uncle Vernon's love interest in that one comedy edit!
All I remember of Rita is Hermoine's plans for her and the films giving her some weird sexual tension with the underaged boys.
 
I'm back! Went to see the Titanic exhibition in Perth. My main impression was that it was a very good time until it wasn't. Also, if anyone wants to write a woke Titanic story, there was in fact one, solitary black dude onboard. Second class passenger, engineer heading to Haiti with his French wife and two kids, honestly a very sad story.

The prospect of talking face-to-face with Sirius was all that sustained Harry over the next fortnight, the only bright spot on a horizon that had never looked darker.

Uh, sorry, folks, I must've opened one of my shipping fics instead.

He had never suffered nerves like these; they were way beyond anything he had experienced before a Quidditch match, not even his last one against Slytherin, which had decided who would win the Quidditch Cup.

I would point out he fought a dark warlock a bunch of times, but I suppose he didn't have to do it in front of an audience. Although, as it unfolds, Harry doesn't have an audience for most of the tournament, either, but we'll get to that.

In the meantime, life became even worse for Harry within the confines of the castle, for Rita Skeeter had published her piece about the Triwizard Tournament, and it had turned out to be not so much a report on the tournament as a highly colored life story of Harry. Much of the front page had been given over to a picture of Harry; the article (continuing on pages two, six, and seven) had been all about Harry, the names of the Beauxbatons and Durmstrang champions (misspelled) had been squashed into the last line of the article, and Cedric hadn’t been mentioned at all.

Wow, Rita Skeeter seems to care as much about the magical world beyond the UK as Rowling herself.

The article had appeared ten days ago, and Harry still got a sick, burning feeling of shame in his stomach every time he thought about it. Rita Skeeter had reported him saying an awful
ot of things that he couldn’t remember ever saying in his life, let alone in that broom cupboard.

I suppose I get my strength from my parents. I know they’d be very proud of me if they could see me now. … Yes, sometimes at night I still cry about them, I’m not ashamed to admit it. … I know nothing will hurt me during the tournament, because they’re watching over me. …

This is of course quite funny, but it bugs me a little that the story seems to imply this is the first time the gutter press has taken an interest in Harry since he was a baby. If you have any knowledge of British tabloids, that should surprise you. Even if we pretend Harry hasn't saved the school twice, and been a person of interest in a nationwide manhunt for an escaped murderer, since when have tabloids not bothered celebrities who were just minding their own business. It's not like Harry was living a normal, boring wizarding life, either--he was being raised by comically grotesque Muggles. We know admirers were able to track him down, why not Rita or some other yellow journalist? If anything, he should've been a cause celebre. "Save Harry Potter!"

But Rita Skeeter had gone even further than transforming his “er’s” into long, sickly sentences: She had interviewed other people about him too.


Harry has at last found love at Hogwarts. His close friend, Colin Creevey, says that Harry is rarely seen out of the company of one Hermione Granger, a stunningly pretty Muggle-born girl who, like Harry, is one of the top students in the school.

Oh, so that's why Harry finds Colin so annoying--he's a Harmonian!

From the moment the article had appeared, Harry had had to endure people — Slytherins, mainly — quoting it at him as he passed and making sneering comments.

“Want a hanky, Potter, in case you start crying in Transfiguration?”

“Since when have you been one of the top students in the school, Potter? Or is this a school you and Longbottom have set up together?”

“Hey — Harry!”

“Yeah, that’s right!” Harry found himself shouting as he wheeled around in the corridor, having had just about enough. “I’ve just been crying my eyes out over my dead mum, and I’m just off to do a bit more. …”

I have seen people in real life say Harry doesn't mourn or think about his parents enough. I wonder what books they're reading.

“No — it was just — you dropped your quill.”

It was Cho. Harry felt the color rising in his face.

“Oh — right — sorry,” he muttered, taking the quill back.

“Er … good luck on Tuesday,” she said. “I really hope you do well.”

Which left Harry feeling extremely stupid

Hermione had come in for her fair share of unpleasantness too, but she hadn’t yet started yelling at innocent bystanders; in fact, Harry was full of admiration for the way she was handling the situation.

I wonder if this whole thing was inspired by early Harry/Hermione shippers.

But Harry couldn’t ignore it. Ron hadn’t spoken to him at all since he had told him about Snape’s detentions. Harry had half hoped they would make things up during the two hours they were forced to pickle rats’ brains in Snape’s dungeon, but that had been the day Rita’s article had appeared, which seemed to have confirmed Ron’s belief that Harry was really enjoying all the attention.

Hermione was furious with the pair of them; she went from one to the other, trying to force them to talk to each other, but Harry was adamant: He would talk to Ron again only if Ron admitted that Harry hadn’t put his name in the Goblet of Fire and apologized for calling him a liar.

I like to think Hermione is being so concillitory about this because she remembers her rift with Ron last book.

“You miss him!” Hermione said impatiently. “And I know he misses you —”

“Miss him?” said Harry. “I don’t miss him…”

I appreciate also that Harry seems to have some discomfort at the idea of having such girly emotions. I've said this before, but Rowling is really good at writing boys for a woman author.

But this was a downright lie. Harry liked Hermione very much, but she just wasn’t the same as Ron. There was much less laughter and a lot more hanging around in the library when Hermione was your best friend.

"Also, not nearly as good at kissing."

Harry still hadn’t mastered Summoning Charms, he seemed to have developed something of a block about them, and Hermione insisted that learning the theory would help. They consequently spent a lot of time poring over books during their lunchtimes.

Don't try go insinuating the magic here has any depth. I Dream of Jeannie had more theory.

Viktor Krum was in the library an awful lot too, and Harry wondered what he was up to. Was he studying, or was he looking for things to help him through the first task?

I mean... yes? What else would he be doing?

Hermione often complained about Krum being there — not that he ever bothered them — but because groups of giggling girls often turned up to spy on him from behind bookshelves, and Hermione found the noise distracting.

“He’s not even good-looking!” she muttered angrily, glaring at Krum’s sharp profile. “They only like him because he’s famous! They wouldn’t look twice at him if he couldn’t do that Wonky-Faint thing —”

“Wronski Feint,” said Harry, through gritted teeth. Quite apart from liking to get Quidditch terms correct, it caused him another pang to imagine Ron’s expression if he could have heard Hermione talking about Wonky-Faints.

I said "what" not "who." Still, I love that the concept of brushing up on your magic before the Magic Olympics is so opaque to Harry.

On the Saturday before the first task, all students in the third year and above were permitted to visit the village of Hogsmeade. Hermione told Harry that it would do him good to get away from the castle for a bit, and Harry didn’t need much persuasion.

A reminder Harry can now officially go to Hogsmeade because his mass murdering godfather signed his permission form.

“What about Ron, though?” he said. “Don’t you want to go with him?”

“Oh … well …” Hermione went slightly pink. “I thought we might meet up with him in the Three Broomsticks. …”

“No,” said Harry flatly.

“Oh Harry, this is so stupid —”

“I’ll come, but I’m not meeting Ron, and I’m wearing my Invisibility Cloak.”

“Oh all right then …” Hermione snapped, “but I hate talking to you in that cloak, I never know if I’m looking at you or not.”

Bit forced, not going to lie. It's a good thing Harry chose to go with this ridiculous overkill, as it happens, because Rita Skeeter is in the village.

The Three Broomsticks was packed, mainly with Hogwarts students enjoying their free afternoon, but also with a variety of magical people Harry rarely saw anywhere else. Harry supposed that as Hogsmeade was the only all-wizard village in Britain, it was a bit of a haven for creatures like hags, who were not as adept as wizards at disguising themselves.

Because nobody's seen an ugly woman before. Surely goblins would be a better example?

“You know, maybe I should try and get some of the villagers involved in S.P.E.W.,” Hermione said thoughtfully, looking around the pub.

“Yeah, right,” said Harry. He took a swig of butterbeer under his cloak. “Hermione, when are you going to give up on this spew stuff?”

“When house-elves have decent wages and working conditions!” she hissed back. “You know, I’m starting to think it’s time for more direct action. I wonder how you get into the school kitchens?”

This is going to be like when those pro-pallies at Colombia hassled that poor janitor, isn't it?

Moody limped around the table and bent down; Harry thought he was reading the S.P.E.W. notebook, until he muttered, “Nice cloak, Potter.”

Harry stared at him in amazement. The large chunk missing from Moody’s nose was particularly obvious at a few inches’ distance. Moody grinned.

“Can your eye — I mean, can you — ?”

“Yeah, it can see through Invisibility Cloaks,” Moody said quietly. “And it’s come in useful at times, I can tell you.”

I refuse to believe Rowling planned for the cloak to be anything but a handy family heirloom, let alone something that could feasibly have been created by one of the primal forces of the cosmos. Some people have speculated Moody's eye was created by Dumbledore with the Elder Wand, but it still feels weird for one of the Hallows to be able to trump another like that. Hagrid wanders over and tells Harry to meet him by his hut at midnight. This will cut it fine with meeting Sirius by the fireplace, but well, since when has Harry passed up doing something ill-advised after hours?

At half past eleven that evening, Harry, who had pretended to go up to bed early, pulled the Invisibility Cloak back over himself and crept back downstairs through the common room. Quite a few people were still in there. The Creevey brothers had managed to get hold of a stack of Support Cedric Diggory! badges and were trying to bewitch them to make them say Support Harry Potter! instead. So far, however, all they had managed to do was get the badges stuck on POTTER STINKS.

Fandom.txt.

“Got summat ter show yeh,” said Hagrid.

There was an air of enormous excitement about Hagrid. He was wearing a flower that resembled an oversized artichoke in his buttonhole. It looked as though he had abandoned the use of axle grease, but he had certainly attempted to comb his hair — Harry could see the comb’s broken teeth tangled in it.

“What’re you showing me?” Harry said warily, wondering if the skrewts had laid eggs, or Hagrid had managed to buy another giant three-headed dog off a stranger in a pub.

I wonder what happened to Fluffy after the first book. Also, now now Harry, if the skrewts had laid eggs, at least some of your classmates would be missing. Harry tries to make it clear he'll have to be quick tonight, but helping Harry is a mere sidequest.

“Hagrid, what — ?”

“Shhh!” said Hagrid, and he knocked three times on the door bearing the crossed golden wands.

Madame Maxime opened it. She was wearing a silk shawl wrapped around her massive shoulders. She smiled when she saw Hagrid.

“Ah, ’Agrid … it is time?”

“Bong-sewer,” said Hagrid, beaming at her, and holding out a hand to help her down the golden steps.

Bong-Sewer is a Full Moon Feature flick about a stoner who gets turned into a golem made of human shit due to smoking some radioactive weed in a portable toilet.


Madame Maxime closed the door behind her, Hagrid offered her his arm, and they set off around the edge of the paddock containing Madame Maxime’s giant winged horses, with Harry, totally bewildered, running to keep up with them. Had Hagrid wanted to show him Madame Maxime? He could see her any old time he wanted … she wasn’t exactly hard to miss. …

But it seemed that Madame Maxime was in for the same treat as Harry, because after a while she said playfully, “Wair is it you are taking me, ’Agrid?”

“Yeh’ll enjoy this,” said Hagrid gruffly, “worth seein’, trust me. On’y — don’ go tellin’ anyone I showed yeh, right? Yeh’re not s’posed ter know.”

So, how does this not count as Harry getting help from a teacher? I normally wouldn't mind, but the whole premise of this book hinges on the tournament's rules being a magically binding contract. Shouldn't either Harry or Hagrid or both be struck by lightning or sinking forever into a thousand years of wizard shit and piss?


And still they walked, Harry getting more and more irritated as he jogged along in their wake, checking his watch every now and then. Hagrid had some harebrained scheme in hand, which might make him miss Sirius.

This reminds me of when I was small and got really stressed about making it to the movies on time, because I didn't really get that the start time includes previews and shit. But no, Hagrid hasn't dragged Harry out to help him woo Madame Maxime.


Dragons.

Four fully grown, enormous, vicious-looking dragons were rearing onto their hind legs inside an enclosure fenced with thick planks of wood, roaring and snorting — torrents of fire were shooting into the dark sky from their open, fanged mouths, fifty feet above the ground on their outstretched necks. There was a silvery-blue one with long, pointed horns, snapping and snarling at the wizards on the ground; a smooth-scaled green one, which was writhing and stamping with all its might; a red one with an odd fringe of fine gold spikes around its ace, which was shooting mushroom-shaped fire clouds into the air; and a gigantic black one, more lizard-like than the others, which was nearest to them.

I still wonder if there are Asian style dragons in this world. I assume these ones were hatched by Luna.

(Because she has silvery white hair, I'm very clever)

At least thirty wizards, seven or eight to each dragon, were attempting to control them, pulling on the chains connected to heavy leather straps around their necks and legs. Mesmerized, Harry looked up, high above him, and saw the eyes of the black dragon, with vertical pupils like a cat’s, bulging with either fear or rage, he couldn’t tell which. … It was making a horrible noise, a yowling, screeching scream. …

“Keep back there, Hagrid!” yelled a wizard near the fence, straining on the chain he was holding. “They can shoot fire at a range of twenty feet, you know! I’ve seen this Horntail do forty!”

“Is’n’ it beautiful?” said Hagrid softly.

“It’s no good!” yelled another wizard. “Stunning Spells, on the count of three!”

Okay, how has nobody in the castle heard the dragons or seen the great gouts of flame? Hagrid should've just told Harry to look out the window. Among the dragon-keepers is Charlie Weasley, who informs Hagrid, his lovely lady companion, and their invisible stalker that the dragons are a Common Welsh Green (sounds like a kind of Pokemon you have to grind for), a Chinese Fireball (who looks nothing like an Asian dragon, which is a shame), a Swedish Short-Snout (an illegal sex act) and a Hungarian Horntail, which is the breed Norbert was.

“Four …” said Hagrid, “so it’s one fer each o’ the champions, is it? What’ve they gotta do — fight ’em?”

“Just get past them, I think,” said Charlie. “We’ll be on hand if it gets nasty, Extinguishing Spells at the ready. They wanted nesting mothers, I don’t know why … but I tell you this, I don’t envy the one who gets the Horntail. Vicious thing. Its back end’s as dangerous as its front, look.”

You'd think suddenly having to acquire another expectant dragon mum would cause delays. Also, I assume somewhere off screen Donkey is recreating Taken to get his wife and kids back.

Then he said, “How’s Harry?”

“Fine,” said Hagrid. He was still gazing at the eggs.

“Just hope he’s still fine after he’s faced this lot,” said Charlie grimly, looking out over the dragons’ enclosure. “I didn’t dare tell Mum what he’s got to do for the first task; she’s already having kittens about him. …” Charlie imitated his mother’s anxious voice. “ ‘How could they let him enter that tournament, he’s much too young! I thought they were all safe, I thought there was going to be an age limit!’ She was in floods after that Daily Prophet article about him. ‘He still cries about his parents! Oh bless him, I never knew!’ ”

Watch as the dragon Harry has to deal with suddenly succumbs to a heart attack. Harry decides (probably rightly) that he's seen all he needs to.

He didn’t know whether he was glad he’d seen what was coming or not. Perhaps this way was better.

Yes, I think it is in fact better to know you are fighting a vicious, broody dragon in advance, Harry.

The first shock was over now. Maybe if he’d seen the dragons for the first time on Tuesday, he would have passed out cold in front of the whole school … but maybe he would anyway.

I'd say that'd be for the best, but even odds they'd just let the dragon eat or fry Harry where he lay.

He was going to be armed with his wand — which, just now, felt like nothing more than a narrow strip of wood — against a fifty-foot-high, scaly, spike-ridden, fire-breathing dragon.

Maybe if you learned more than two spells...

And he had to get past it. With everyone watching. How?

Of course that's still Harry's concern. That's not a criticism of the character writing, to be clear. Shame is one thing people consistently report fearing more than death.

Harry sped up, skirting the edge of the forest; he had just under fifteen minutes to get back to the fireside and talk to Sirius, and he couldn’t remember, ever, wanting to talk to someone more than he did right now — when, without warning, he ran into something very solid.

Richard Griffiths: They're not getting away with cutting me from the film!

A voice nearby said, “Ouch! Who’s there?”

Harry hastily checked that the cloak was covering him and lay very still, staring up at the dark outline of the wizard he had hit. He recognized the goatee … it was Karkaroff.

“Who’s there?” said Karkaroff again, very suspiciously, looking around in the darkness. Harry remained still and silent. After a minute or so, Karkaroff seemed to decide that he had hit some sort of animal; he was looking around at waist height, as though expecting to see a dog.

...Does Karkaroff somehow know Sirius is an Animagus? Or does he also fear the drunk werewolves in the forest?

He had no doubt whatsoever what Karkaroff was up to. He had sneaked off his ship to try and find out what the first task was going to be. He might even have spotted Hagrid and Madame Maxime heading off around the forest together — they were hardly difficult to spot at a distance … and now all Karkaroff had to do was follow the sound of voices, and he, like Madame Maxime, would know what was in store for the champions.

By the looks of it, the only champion who would be facing the unknown on Tuesday was Cedric.

So, is the only part of the rules that's actually enforced by magic the part where champions can't back out for any reason?

Harry pulled off the Invisibility Cloak and threw himself into an armchair in front of the fire. The room was in semidarkness; the flames were the only source of light. Nearby, on a table, the Support Cedric Diggory! badges the Creeveys had been trying to improve were glinting in the firelight. They now read POTTER REALLY STINKS.

Magic is weird. Or was Draco or whoever enchanted these smart enough to install anti-tampering stuff?

Harry looked back into the flames, and jumped.

Sirius’s head was sitting in the fire. If Harry hadn’t seen Mr. Diggory do exactly this back in the Weasleys’ kitchen, it would have scared him out of his wits. Instead, his face breaking into the first smile he had worn for days, he scrambled out of his chair, crouched down by the hearth, and said, “Sirius — how’re you doing?”

So, has Sirius broken into a house with a Floo link, or does he have his head in a campfire somewhere? The latter would explain why it's only his head, though it still seems weird Amos Diggory didn't just stand in the fire.

Sirius looked different from Harry’s memory of him. When they had said good-bye, Sirius’s face had been gaunt and sunken, surrounded by a quantity of long, black, matted hair — but the hair was short and clean now, Sirius’s face was fuller, and he looked younger, much more like the only photograph Harry had of him, which had been taken at the Potters’ wedding.

Aww shit, Sirius has been feeding on the blood of Englishwomen. Harry explains what's been going on:

Dragons we can deal with, Harry, but we’ll get to that in a minute — I haven’t got long here … I’ve broken into a wizarding house to use the fire, but they could be back at any time. There are things I need to warn you about.”

Nice to have an explanation, but again, still weird it's only the head.

“What?” said Harry, feeling his spirits slip a further few notches. … Surely there could be nothing worse than dragons coming?

You fought a basilisk!

“Karkaroff,” said Sirius. “Harry, he was a Death Eater. You know what Death Eaters are, don’t you?”

"Because it'd be kind of hilariously ignorant of you not to."

“He was caught, he was in Azkaban with me, but he got released. I’d bet everything that’s why Dumbledore wanted an Auror at Hogwarts this year — to keep an eye on him. Moody caught Karkaroff. Put him into Azkaban in the first place.”

So, the implication is however long Karkaroff was in Azkaban for, it was long enough for him to discover Sirius could turn into a dog. Probably other inmates saw it, too. And this information never made it to the Ministry. Somehow I am not surprised.

Also, you might have missed it, but Igor Karkaroff is not in fact British. From what we see off Voldemort, his goals do not and did not seem to stretch beyond the borders of the UK (or possibly even just Great Britain) so Karkaroff is essentially the wizarding equivalent of someone from Europe or America who runs off to to the Middle East to join ISIS. Or someone from the Middle East who runs off to the UK to join ISIS.

Karkaroff got released?” Harry said slowly — his brain seemed to be struggling to absorb yet another piece of shocking information. “Why did they release him?”

“He did a deal with the Ministry of Magic,” said Sirius bitterly. “He said he’d seen the error of his ways, and then he named names … he put a load of other people into Azkaban in his place. … He’s not very popular in there, I can tell you. And since he got out, from what I can tell, he’s been teaching the Dark Arts to every student who passes through that school of his. So watch out for the Durmstrang champion as well.”

The UK sectarianism jokes write themselves. And in case you yanks get too smug, remember, the New York Times just ran a piece by a daughter of some Weather Underground members criticising One Battle After Another for not gassing up domestic terrorists enough.


“Okay,” said Harry slowly. “But … are you saying Karkaroff put my name in the goblet? Because if he did, he’s a really good actor. He seemed furious about it. He wanted to stop me from competing.”
“We know he’s a good actor,” said Sirius, “because he convinced the Ministry of Magic to set him free, didn’t he?

I wonder if there was any diplomatic consideration given Karkaroff was a foreign national with enough sway to get appointed the headmaster of a major magic school.

Now, I’ve been keeping an eye on the Daily Prophet, Harry —”

“— you and the rest of the world,” said Harry bitterly.

“— and reading between the lines of that Skeeter woman’s article last month, Moody was attacked the night before he started at Hogwarts. Yes, I know she says it was another false alarm,” Sirius said hastily, seeing Harry about to speak, “but I don’t think so, somehow. I think someone tried to stop him from getting to Hogwarts. I think someone knew their job would be a lot more difficult with him around. And no one’s going to look into it too closely; Mad-Eye’s heard intruders a bit too often. But that doesn’t mean he can’t still spot the real thing. Moody was the best Auror the Ministry ever had.”

I like it when characters make well reasoned guesses that are wrong.

“I’ve been hearing some very strange things,” he said slowly. “The Death Eaters seem to be a bit more active than usual lately. They showed themselves at the Quidditch World Cup, didn’t they? Someone set off the Dark Mark … and then — did you hear about that Ministry of Magic witch who’s gone missing?”

“Bertha Jorkins?” said Harry.

“Exactly … she disappeared in Albania, and that’s definitely where Voldemort was rumored to be last … and she would have known the Triwizard Tournament was coming up, wouldn’t she?”

By rumours Sirius means there was a tour bus that went past his cave.

“Right — these dragons,” said Sirius, speaking very quickly now. “There’s a way, Harry. Don’t be tempted to try a Stunning Spell — dragons are strong and too powerfully magical
to be knocked out by a single Stunner, you need about half a dozen wizards at a time to overcome a dragon —”

“Yeah, I know, I just saw,” said Harry.

“But you can do it alone,” said Sirius. “There is a way, and a simple spell’s all you need. Just —”
But Harry held up a hand to silence him, his heart suddenly pounding as though it would burst. He could hear footsteps coming down the spiral staircase behind him.

“Go!” he hissed at Sirius. “Go! There’s someone coming!”

What spell do we think Sirius was going to suggest? The one Harry ends up using? Expelliarmus, because it's worked every other time? A spell that turns Harry into a dragon so he can seduce his dragon, fathering a dynasty to rule over Grand Cathay?

Harry heard a tiny pop! in the fire behind him and knew Sirius had gone. He watched the bottom of the spiral staircase. Who had decided to go for a stroll at one o’clock in the morning, and stopped Sirius from telling him how to get past a dragon?

It was Ron. Dressed in his maroon paisley pajamas, Ron stopped dead facing Harry across the room, and looked around.

“Who were you talking to?” he said.

“What’s that got to do with you?” Harry snarled. “What are you doing down here at this time of night?”

This feels like a great object lesson in why you should settle your petty beefs. I always appreciate when children's authors actually weave life lessons into their books gracefully.

“I just wondered where you —” Ron broke off, shrugging. “Nothing. I’m going back to bed.”

“Just thought you’d come nosing around, did you?” Harry shouted. He knew that Ron had no idea what he’d walked in on, knew he hadn’t done it on purpose, but he didn’t care — at this moment he hated everything about Ron, right down to the several inches of bare ankle showing beneath his pajama trousers.

1773499123489.png

“Sorry about that,” said Ron, his face reddening with anger. “Should’ve realized you didn’t want to be disturbed. I’ll let you get on with practicing for your next interview in peace.”

Harry seized one of the POTTER REALLY STINKS badges off the table and chucked it, as hard as he could, across the room. It hit Ron on the forehead and bounced off.

NO SELL.

“There you go,” Harry said. “Something for you to wear on Tuesday. You might even have a scar now, if you’re lucky. … That’s what you want, isn’t it?”

He strode across the room toward the stairs; he half expected Ron to stop him, he would even have liked Ron to throw a punch at him, but Ron just stood there in his too-small pajamas, and Harry, having stormed upstairs, lay awake in bed fuming for a long time afterward and didn’t hear him come up to bed.

The Weasleys having shitty clothes will never not bother me.
 
Last edited:
Second class passenger, engineer heading to Haiti with his French wife and two kids, honestly a very sad story.
The story was good up until the reveal of the French.
This is of course quite funny, but it bugs me a little that the story seems to imply this is the first time the gutter press has taken an interest in Harry since he was a baby.
I'd take as more the first real opportunity to directly harass him. Any time Harry has been in the magical world, he's either been in Hogwarts or with the Weasleys who quickly try to guide him away from the press. The tournament is the time where Rita Skeeter is allowed to fufill her desire to corner little boys in a broom closet.
We know admirers were able to track him down, why not Rita or some other yellow journalist? If anything, he should've been a cause celebre. "Save Harry Potter!"
Well, you should know that there are few journalists left in the Wizarding World after repeated failed attempts to get passed Dudley and his insatiable appetite for human flesh.

Also, do we know that? Only admirers I remember were people who just so happened to cross Harry in the street, which is part of why Vernon makes an effort to act like Harry doesn't exist when he can to the public. I also wouldn't put it past someone like Rita to just be so drama brained that she couldn't imagine Harry staying with regular muggles.
I said "what" not "who." Still, I love that the concept of brushing up on your magic before the Magic Olympics is so opaque to Harry.
Books only teach you magic if they have sparkles and are on a pedestal inside a dungeon, obviously.
Also, I assume somewhere off screen Donkey is recreating Taken to get his wife and kids back.
Hey, if Puss can get a weird spin off with a strangely good sequel, why can't Donkey?
 
"Also, not nearly as good a kissing."

Like Harry, I hold great love in my heart for redheads, but I'm glad he (eventually) found out that women were not only an option, but the superior one.

By rumours Sirius means there was a tour bus that went past his cave.

We never really found out where he was hiding from the end of PoA to the beginning of OotP. Maybe he was hanging around Diagon Alley or some other spellchucker territory, living off discarded fish and chips and reading Daily Prophets stolen from the trash. He does essentially the same at Hogsmeade in this book, so the idea is not too far-fetched.

What spell do we think Sirius was going to suggest?

Asinum evoca!
 
Last edited:
"If Dumbledore thought yeh did it, tho, I'd 'ave terned on yeh like that!"
I mean, Dumbledore is weird, mysterious, and occasionally ruthless, but he's not wrong, and he doesn't seem to ever casually accuse people of stuff. "I'm not bright and don't have access to secret Headmaster wisdom, and Dumbledore is and does, so I'll just trust him unless I've got a solid reason not to." is dangerous, but it's not wrong as an information-processing strategy.


Because nobody's seen an ugly woman before. Surely goblins would be a better example?
How detailed descriptions do we get of hags? They could be humaniform in the way trolls are; could technically be mistaken for human if you don't believe in magical creatures and see them only from a distance. At least, we've got plenty of examples of D&D hags that are definitely not just old women.

Bit forced, not going to lie. It's a good thing Harry chose to go with this ridiculous overkill, as it happens, because Rita Skeeter is in the village.
I don't disagree, but I also feel like this is the kind of stupidity that most people need to work through themselves to have context for how not to be that stupid again later in life. Plus, Harry is very competitive, and doesn't want to be seen as losing to Ron.

So, how does this not count as Harry getting help from a teacher? I normally wouldn't mind, but the whole premise of this book hinges on the tournament's rules being a magically binding contract.
As you say below, I assume that this was a "You can't back out, but murdering the other contestants before the tournament starts is totes legal and actually earns you style points!" historic event, where cheating was expected.
Also, I assume somewhere off screen Donkey is recreating Taken to get his wife and kids back.
I really want to be racist here, but I've got nothing really bad to say against Donkey and his freaky little mutant babies.


Magic is weird. Or was Draco or whoever enchanted these smart enough to install anti-tampering stuff?
Again, I feel like magic items are all vaguely sentient-ish, and this is just like the Marauder's Map coming with its own anti-tampering (which is more just the item itself being willful with its inherited will.)

Clearly the correct answer is to nail the badges to the wall and start torturing them one by one, until either they get the picture or the symbolic children of their enemy have been eradicated.

And in case you yanks get too smug, remember, the New York Times just ran a piece by a daughter of some Weather Underground members criticizing One Battle After Another for not gassing up domestic terrorists enough.
I'm pretty sure that any proud yank will tell you, in complete earnestness, that neither the New York Times, nor the Weather Underground domestic terrorists, nor the justice system that sympathetically worked around them or the liberal establishments that welcomed them, nor all of Hollywood, are real Americans, or anyone we'd expect to be proud of, but yeah, if you are not familiar with the history of the 70s and early 80s in America, look it up, it's a trip, and may hopefully help you feel a little less apocalyptic about the current generations' craziness.
 
The story was good up until the reveal of the French.

Surely we can all relate to being so desperate to leave France, you emigrate to fucking Hati instead.

(that story has a real sad ending. Like many men on the Titanic, the husband got his wife and children onboard a lifeboat and perished on the ship. Then, his wife... went back to France!)

Also, do we know that? Only admirers I remember were people who just so happened to cross Harry in the street, which is part of why Vernon makes an effort to act like Harry doesn't exist when he can to the public. I also wouldn't put it past someone like Rita to just be so drama brained that she couldn't imagine Harry staying with regular muggles.

Like hell the Dursleys register as "regular" to anyone.

Asinum evoca!

Excellent, Donkey knows how to handle this kind of lady.

I really want to be racist here, but I've got nothing really bad to say against Donkey and his freaky little mutant babies.

It's always amused me that Shrek contained an inbuilt rebuttal to the inevitable bad faith Buzzfeed critique of its ending.

Some idiot online: So, what are you saying? That interracial relationships only work if one party literally changes race?

The film: Did you not notice Donkey hooking up with the nonverbal, non shapeshifting dragon?

(Fun fact, apparently the plan for Shrek 2 was for Dragon to have turned into a pegasus when Donkey drank the beautification potion.)

Harry got up on Sunday morning and dressed so inattentively that it was a while before he realized he was trying to pull his hat onto his foot instead of his sock.

Rowling, it's adorable you think anyone pictures Harry in a pointy hat, ever. As you might expect, Harry and Hermione are hard at work trying to think of a way for Harry to not die.

ey walked three times around the lake, trying all the way to think of a simple spell that would subdue a dragon. Nothing whatsoever occurred to them, so they retired to the library instead. Here, Harry pulled down every book he could find on dragons, and both of them set to work searching through the large pile.

“ ‘Talon-clipping by charms … treating scale-rot …’ This is no good, this is for nutters like Hagrid who want to keep them healthy. …”

“ ‘Dragons are extremely difficult to slay, owing to the ancient magic that imbues their thick hides, which none but the most powerful spells can penetrate …’ But Sirius said a simple one would do it. …”

"It's called the Killing Curse, Harry."

I'm almost surprised Harry doesn't consider trying to learn that. I know he's not supposed to kill the dragon, but at this point we're trading style points for survival. Would a standard Killing Curse cast by a single witch or wizard kill a dragon, or would they be able to soak it and get away with like, deep tissue damage?

Also, "ancient magic" makes it sound like dragons have old spells woven into them, like they're ancient wizard war-engines gone feral. Or it's a weak, incongruous plot element in a video-game tied to some admittedly sick kill animations.

“Let’s try some simple spellbooks, then,” said Harry, throwing aside Men Who Love Dragons Too Much.

That feeling when you can't quite tell if that's the narrator being sarcastic or the book's actual title. Also:

Hermione: Please, Harry, we don't have time for an obstacle course!

He returned to the table with a pile of spellbooks, set them down, and began to flick through each in turn, Hermione whispering nonstop at his elbow.

“Well, there are Switching Spells … but what’s the point of Switching it? Unless you swapped its fangs for wine-gums or something that would make it less dangerous.

In case you didn't know, wine gums are a kind of chewy candy popular in the UK and the Commonwealth. No, they don't contain alcohol, nor are most brands shaped like wine bottles. Nobody really knows why they're called wine gums. There are two popular theories. One is that they were meant to be a teetotal alternative to, well, wine--meant to be savoured, with complex flavour profiles like sommalieasts always lie about. The other is that it was marketing designed to make adults feel less juvenile for enjoying candy. Both these sound quite absurd, so I assume they're both true in some way.

The trouble is, like that book said, not much is going to get through a dragon’s hide. I’d say Transfigure it, but something that big, you really haven’t got a hope, I doubt even Professor McGonagall...

She prefers her victims small and helpless.
unless you’re supposed to put the spell on yourself? Maybe to give yourself extra powers? But they’re not simple spells, I mean, we haven’t done any of those in class, I only know about them because I’ve been doing O.W.L. practice papers.”

It's probably for the best we never actually see the year 7 curriculum, because I'm guessing it wouldn't have seemed much more complicated than what they're doing now.

“Hermione,” Harry said, through gritted teeth, “will you shut up for a bit, please? I’m trying to concentrate.”

But all that happened, when Hermione fell silent, was that Harry’s brain filled with a sort of blank buzzing, which didn’t seem to allow room for concentration.

Been there, done that.

He stared hopelessly down the index of Basic Hexes for the Busy and Vexed. Instant scalping… but dragons had no hair

I mean, you can scalp a guy with no hair. I wonder, would casting the spell on a dragon cause the equivalent of a 404 error, or just strip a random, roughly human scalp sized patch of scales?

Harry barely slept that night. When he awoke on Monday morning, he seriously considered for the first time ever just running away from Hogwarts. But as he looked around the Great Hall at breakfast time, and thought about what leaving the castle would mean, he knew he couldn’t do it. It was the only place he had ever been happy … well, he supposed he must have been happy with his parents too, but he couldn’t remember that.

Molly Weasley: What's wrong with my bacon sandwiches?

Spiders: Apologise, young man!

Somehow, the knowledge that he would rather be here and facing a dragon than back on Privet Drive with Dudley was good to know; it made him feel slightly calmer.

True, the dragon is way less likely to eat you alive. Or fuck you, for that matter.

Cedric still didn’t know about the dragons … the only champion who didn’t, if Harry was right in thinking that Maxime and Karkaroff would have told Fleur and Krum.

Hagrid was one of those guys who was really angry when BatPat was announced. Harry, being a nice boy, tells Cedric himself about the dragons.

Why are you telling me?” he asked.

Harry looked at him in disbelief. He was sure Cedric wouldn’t have asked that if he had seen the dragons himself. Harry wouldn’t have let his worst enemy face those monsters unprepared — well, perhaps Malfoy or Snape …

“It’s just … fair, isn’t it?” he said to Cedric. “We all know now … we’re on an even footing, aren’t we?”

"We all know three years of Hogwarts doesn't mean much."

Cedric was still looking at him in a slightly suspicious way when Harry heard a familiar clunking noise behind him. He turned around and saw Mad-Eye Moody emerging from a nearby classroom.

“Come with me, Potter,” he growled. “Diggory, off you go.”

I hear James Gunn told Patterson much the same.

Harry followed him, wondering what was going to happen to him now. What if Moody wanted to know how he’d found out about the dragons? Would Moody go to Dumbledore and tell on Hagrid, or just turn Harry into a ferret? Well, it might be easier to get past a dragon if he were a ferret, Harry thought dully, he’d be smaller, much less easy to see from a height of fifty feet …

Uncle Vernon: Great, like we don't have enough furries in this family.

“That was a very decent thing you just did, Potter,” Moody said quietly.

Harry didn’t know what to say; this wasn’t the reaction he had expected at all.

“Sit down,” said Moody, and Harry sat, looking around.

He had visited this office under two of its previous occupants. In Professor Lockhart’s day, the walls had been plastered with beaming, winking pictures of Professor Lockhart himself.

I'm kind of surprised now that Harry never saw Quirrell's office. I'm guessing it was mostly taken up by various amusing pieces of headgear.

When Lupin had lived here, you were more likely to come across a specimen of some fascinating new Dark creature he had procured for them to study in class.

I wonder what "Dark" means specifically in the context of creatures.

Now, however, the office was full of a number of exceptionally odd objects that Harry supposed Moody had used in the days when he had been an Auror.

On his desk stood what looked like a large, cracked, glass spinning top; Harry recognized it at once as a Sneakoscope, because he owned one himself, though it was much smaller than Moody’s. In the corner on a small table stood an object that looked something like an extra-squiggly, golden television aerial. It was humming slightly.

It picks up improvised dialogue set to animation from across the multiverse.

What appeared to be a mirror hung opposite Harry on the wall, but it was not reflecting the room. Shadowy figures were moving around inside it, none of them clearly in focus.

One day, the wizards will reverse engineer our mirror technology.

Like my Dark Detectors, do you?” said Moody, who was watching Harry closely.

“What’s that?” Harry asked, pointing at the squiggly golden aerial.

“Secrecy Sensor. Vibrates when it detects concealment and lies … no use here, of course, too much interference — students in every direction lying about why they haven’t done their homework. Been humming ever since I got here. I had to disable my Sneakoscope because it wouldn’t stop whistling. It’s extra-sensitive, picks up stuff about a mile around. Of course, it could be picking up more than kid stuff,” he added in a growl.

These objects seem virtually useless in any place where humans congregate in large numbers.

“And what’s the mirror for?”

“Oh that’s my Foe-Glass. See them out there, skulking around? I’m not really in trouble until I see the whites of their eyes. That’s when I open my trunk.”

He let out a short, harsh laugh, and pointed to the large trunk under the window. It had seven keyholes in a row. Harry wondered what was in there, until Moody’s next question brought him sharply back to earth.

Shout out to the film version, where Real Moody is actively banging and crying out from inside the trunk and nobody cares. Also, imagine if Moody had managed to escape, and we got a mirror duel in the Great Hall or something.

So … found out about the dragons, have you?”

Harry hesitated. He’d been afraid of this — but he hadn’t told Cedric, and he certainly wasn’t going to tell Moody, that Hagrid had broken the rules.

“It’s all right,” said Moody, sitting down and stretching out his wooden leg with a groan. “Cheating’s a traditional part of the Tri-wizard Tournament and always has been.”

“I didn’t cheat,” said Harry sharply. “It was — a sort of accident that I found out.”

Moody grinned. “I wasn’t accusing you, laddie. I’ve been telling Dumbledore from the start, he can be as high-minded as he likes, but you can bet old Karkaroff and Maxime won’t be. They’ll have told their champions everything they can. They want to win. They want to beat Dumbledore. They’d like to prove he’s only human.”

As you say below, I assume that this was a "You can't back out, but murdering the other contestants before the tournament starts is totes legal and actually earns you style points!" historic event, where cheating was expected.

Point for Iridium. Honestly, I'm just glad Rowling's up front about it.

“So … got any ideas how you’re going to get past your dragon yet?” said Moody.

“No,” said Harry.

Yeah, False-Eye Moody's plan requires Harry to essentially win the tournament. You'd think the time and place to nab him (Voldemort requires Harry to be alive) would've been the Quidditch World Cup during all the chaos. You could maybe surmise there were anti-Apparition wards in place (it was a ticketed sporting event) but Harry also visits Hogsmeade, which has no such thing.

“Well, I’m not going to tell you,” said Moody gruffly. “I don’t show favoritism, me. I’m just going to give you some good, general advice. And the first bit is — play to your strengths.”

“I haven’t got any,” said Harry, before he could stop himself.

“Excuse me,” growled Moody, “you’ve got strengths if I say you’ve got them. Think now. What are you best at?”

Harry's going to form a regenerating mecha out of friendly spiders.

Harry tried to concentrate. What was he best at? Well, that was easy, really —

“Quidditch,” he said dully, “and a fat lot of help —”

“That’s right,” said Moody, staring at him very hard, his magical eye barely moving at all. “You’re a damn good flier from what I’ve heard.”

It sure would be swell if the first task involved retrieving a small, golden object!

Moody basically spells out that Harry should summon his Firebolt during the task, thus leading to him asking Hermione to help him with his Summoning Charm.

And so they practiced. They didn’t have lunch, but headed for a free classroom, where Harry tried with all his might to make various objects fly across the room toward him. He was still having problems. The books and quills kept losing heart halfway across the room and dropping like stones to the floor.

“Concentrate, Harry, concentrate. …”

“What d’you think I’m trying to do?” said Harry angrily. “A great big dragon keeps popping up in my head for some reason. … Okay, try again. …”

See, this would be a lot more engaging if we had any idea about the process of casting a Summoning Charm, even on the level of Expecto Patronum (think happy!) or Riddikulus (post cringe!).

He wanted to skip Divination to keep practicing, but Hermione refused point-blank to skive off Arithmancy, and there was no point in staying without her.

Man, that's some Lisa Simpson dedication to good grades. At least after Harry is fried alive Hermione will be able to get into all those witch universities that don't exist?

He therefore had to endure over an hour of Professor Trelawney, who spent half the lesson telling everyone that the position of Mars with relation to Saturn at that moment meant that people born in July were in great danger of sudden, violent deaths.

“Well, that’s good,” said Harry loudly, his temper getting the better of him, “just as long as it’s not drawn-out. I don’t want to suffer.”

That's the spirit!

Ron looked for a moment as though he was going to laugh; he certainly caught Harry’s eye for the first time in days, but Harry was still feeling too resentful toward Ron to care. He spent the rest of the lesson trying to attract small objects toward him under the table with his wand. He managed to make a fly zoom straight into his hand, though he wasn’t entirely sure that was his prowess at Summoning Charms — perhaps the fly was just stupid.

Like Mowgli, Harry has learned from the animals who raised him.

At two o’clock in the morning, Harry stood near the fireplace, surrounded by heaps of objects: books, quills, several upturned chairs, an old set of Gobstones, and Neville’s toad, Trevor.

Yeah, the Harry Potter franchise uhms and ahhs a lot about whether Summoning Charms can affect living things. I say they shouldn't, because then it'd be as common as Expelliarmus. Hogwarts Legacy tried hedging it by letting you use it on enemies, but claiming it only worked because you were technically targeting their clothing. And then it let you use it on like, wolves. Perhaps we should assume Trevor is wearing a darling knit jumper, or he died ages ago and nobody noticed.

Only in the last hour had Harry really got the hang of the Summoning Charm.

Well, that was a compelling arc!

Harry felt oddly separate from everyone around him, whether they were wishing him good luck or hissing “We’ll have a box of tissues ready, Potter” as he passed. It was a state of nervousness so advanced that he wondered whether he mightn’t just lose his head when they tried to lead him out to his dragon, and start trying to curse everyone in sight.

Don't do that, Harry, you'll just up killing Allan Quatermain with your lightning cock.

Time was behaving in a more peculiar fashion than ever, rushing past in great dollops, so that one moment he seemed to be sitting down in his first lesson, History of Magic, and the next, walking into lunch … and then (where had the morning gone? the last of the dragon-free hours?), Professor McGonagall was hurrying over to him in the Great Hall. Lots of people were watching.

“Potter, the champions have to come down onto the grounds now. You have to get ready for your first task.”

McGonagall must feel like the last fourteen years were a bit of a waste. Imagine being the rest of the Hogwarts staff while Dumbledore insists they be the one school that doesn't help their student.

He left the Great Hall with Professor McGonagall. She didn’t seem herself either; in fact, she looked nearly as anxious as Hermione. As she walked him down the stone steps and out into the cold November afternoon, she put her hand on his shoulder.

“Now, don’t panic,” she said, “just keep a cool head. … We’ve got wizards standing by to control the situation if it gets out of hand.

I assume this means "throw Harry back in if he tries to run."

Bagman looked somehow like a slightly overblown cartoon figure, standing amid all the pale-faced champions. He was wearing his old Wasp robes again.

“Well, now we’re all here — time to fill you in!” said Bagman brightly. “When the audience has assembled, I’m going to be offering each of you this bag” — he held up a small sack of purple silk and shook it at them — “from which you will each select a small model of the thing you are about to face! There are different — er — varieties, you see. And I have to tell you something else too … ah, yes … your task is to collect the golden egg!”

I'm just shocked they weren't lain by an actual goose.

Harry draws the Hungarian Horntail, and will be going last. Harry (and the reader) also doesn't get to watch the other champions attempt the task, because I guess Rowling wanted to make my job easier.

(Oh, Bagman tries to get Harry to let him give some unspecified pointers)

He saw everything in front of him as though it was a very highly colored dream. There were hundreds and hundreds of faces staring down at him from stands that had been magicked there since he’d last stood on this spot. And there was the Horntail, at the other end of the enclosure, crouched low over her clutch of eggs, her wings half-furled, her evil, yellow
“Accio Firebolt!” he shouted.

Harry waited, every fiber of him hoping, praying. … If it hadn’t worked … if it wasn’t coming … He seemed to be looking at everything around him through some sort of shimmering, transparent barrier, like a heat haze, which made the enclosure and the hundreds of faces around him swim strangely. …

And then he heard it, speeding through the air behind him; he turned and saw his Firebolt hurtling toward him around the edge of the woods, soaring into the enclosure, and stopping dead in midair beside him, waiting for him to mount.

I feel like there should be some sort of... haptic response when a spell works.

Harry manages to get the Golden Egg with only a minor arm injury. It's not a bad sequence, but I don't really have anything to say about it. Madam Pomfrey does, though:

“Dragons!” she said, in a disgusted tone, pulling Harry inside. The tent was divided into cubicles; he could make out Cedric’s shadow through the canvas, but Cedric didn’t seem to be badly injured; he was sitting up, at least. Madam Pomfrey examined Harry’s shoulder, talking furiously all the while. “Last year dementors, this year dragons, what are they going to bring into this school next?

Bureaucrats.

Harry didn’t want to sit still: He was too full of adrenaline. He got to his feet, wanting to see what was going on outside, but before he’d reached the mouth of the tent, two people had come darting inside — Hermione, followed closely by Ron.

“Harry, you were brilliant!” Hermione said squeakily. There were fingernail marks on her face where she had been clutching it in fear. “You were amazing! You really were!”

But Harry was looking at Ron, who was very white and staring at Harry as though he were a ghost.

“Harry,” he said, very seriously, “whoever put your name in that goblet — I — I reckon they’re trying to do you in!”

It was as though the last few weeks had never happened — as though Harry were meeting Ron for the first time, right after he’d been made champion.

As you can see, Ron has pulled his head in after seeing how serious the Tournament really is. The fanfic writers seem to have missed this part, and indeed, most of Ron's bits throughout the entire series.

“Caught on, have you?” said Harry coldly. “Took you long enough.”

Hermione stood nervously between them, looking from one to the other. Ron opened his mouth uncertainly. Harry knew Ron was about to apologize and suddenly he found he didn’t need to hear it.
“It’s okay,” he said, before Ron could get the words out. “Forget it.”

“No,” said Ron, “I shouldn’t’ve —”

“Forget it,” Harry said.

Ron grinned nervously at him, and Harry grinned back.

Hermione burst into tears.

“There’s nothing to cry about!” Harry told her, bewildered.

“You two are so stupid!” she shouted, stamping her foot on the ground, tears splashing down her front. Then, before either of them could stop her, she had given both of them a hug and dashed away, now positively howling.

“Barking mad,” said Ron, shaking his head. “Harry, c’mon, they’ll be putting up your scores. …”

#BoysRock.

“You were the best, you know, no competition. Cedric did this weird thing where he Transfigured a rock on the ground … turned it into a dog … he was trying to make the dragon go for the dog instead of him. Well, it was a pretty cool bit of Transfiguration, and it sort of worked, because he did get the egg, but he got burned as well — the dragon changed its mind halfway through and decided it would rather have him than the Labrador; he only just got away. And that Fleur girl tried this sort of charm, I think she was trying to put it into a trance — well, that kind of worked too, it went all sleepy, but then it snored, and this great jet of flame shot out, and her skirt caught fire — she put it out with a bit of water out of her wand. And Krum — you won’t believe this, but he didn’t even think of flying! He was probably the best after you, though. Hit it with some sort of spell right in the eye. Only thing is, it went trampling around in agony and squashed half the real eggs — they took marks off for that, he wasn’t supposed to do any damage to them.”

Shrek 5 got delayed because now it's a gritty thriller where he helps his blood brother Donkey get payback for his unborn children. So, what do the judges think?

“It’s marks out of ten from each one,” Ron said, and Harry, squinting up the field, saw the first judge — Madame Maxime — raise her wand in the air. What looked like a long silver ribbon shot out of it, which twisted itself into a large figure eight.

“Not bad!” said Ron as the crowd applauded. “I suppose she took marks off for your shoulder. …”

Mr. Crouch came next. He shot a number nine into the air.

“Looking good!” Ron yelled, thumping Harry on the back.

Next, Dumbledore. He too put up a nine. The crowd was cheering harder than ever.

Ludo Bagman — ten.
Ten?” said Harry in disbelief. “But … I got hurt. … What’s he playing at?”

“Harry, don’t complain!” Ron yelled excitedly.

Maybe having one of the judges be a guy who runs sports books on the side is a dumb idea.

And now Karkaroff raised his wand. He paused for a moment, and then a number shot out of his wand too — four.

What?” Ron bellowed furiously. “Four? You lousy, biased scumbag, you gave Krum ten!”

And maybe having most of the judges be the headmasters of the competing schools is even dumber!

But Harry didn’t care, he wouldn’t have cared if Karkaroff had given him zero; Ron’s indignation on his behalf was worth about a hundred points to him. He didn’t tell Ron this, of course, but his heart felt lighter than air as he turned to leave the enclosure.

How is Harry and Draco more popular than this?

Side note, it's well known that Cassandra Clare, author of The Mortal Instruments, first came to internet fame as the writer of The Draco Trilogy, which incidentally was the subject of a big plagiarism controversy, which is kind of impressive for a fanfic. What a lot of people don't know is that The Mortal Instruments takes its name from another of her fanfics, which was apparently a Ginny/Ron incest story. On the one hand, that's disgusting. On the other, at least someone was giving Ron love(?).

“Well done, all of you!” said Ludo Bagman, bouncing into the tent and looking as pleased as though he personally had just got past a dragon. “Now, just a quick few words. You’ve got a nice long break before the second task, which will take place at half past nine on the morning of February the twenty-fourth — but we’re giving you something to think about in the meantime! If you look down at those golden eggs you’re all holding, you will see that they open … see the hinges there? You need to solve the clue inside the egg — because it will tell you what the second task is, and enable you to prepare for it! All clear? Sure? Well, off you go, then!”

Translation, everyone but Harry and Cedric are immediately told what the next challenge is.

It was Rita Skeeter. She was wearing acid-green robes today; the Quick-Quotes Quill in her hand blended perfectly against them.

“Congratulations, Harry!” she said, beaming at him. “I wonder if you could give me a quick word? How you felt facing that dragon? How you feel now, about the fairness of the scoring?”

“Yeah, you can have a word,” said Harry savagely. “Good-bye.

And he set off back to the castle with Ron.

Make sure Rita isn't watching before the make-up sex.
 
Bureaucrats.

*shudder*

Only thing is, it went trampling around in agony and squashed half the real eggs — they took marks off for that, he wasn’t supposed to do any damage to them.”

By learning that no one died in the execution of this task is how we know that Hagrid wasn't watching it, or at the very least Krum's bit; his cries of anguish upon seeing this would have put a banshee to shame.

“Yeah, you can have a word,” said Harry savagely. “Good-bye.

It's good to see the old traditions (i.e., treating journalists like the subhuman scum they are) being upheld even by those affected by severe civilizational dislocation (i.e., wizards).
 
Like hell the Dursleys register as "regular" to anyone.
Mr. and Mrs. Dursley, of number four, Privet Drive, are proud to say that they are perfectly normal, thank you very much.
Hermione: Please, Harry, we don't have time for an obstacle course!
I so want to know what Goblet to Deathly Hallows would have looked like in the games if they stuck to the Diet Zelda formula. Battle of Hogwarts is just everyone standing around waiting for Harry to complete puzzles because both sides of the war are separated by classroom dungeons.
It's probably for the best we never actually see the year 7 curriculum, because I'm guessing it wouldn't have seemed much more complicated than what they're doing now.
"This year, class, we will be covering pointless RPG mechanics that amount to big meaningless numbers."
As you can see, Ron has pulled his head in after seeing how serious the Tournament really is. The fanfic writers seem to have missed this part, and indeed, most of Ron's bits throughout the entire series.
Well, you see, most people simply can't read Ron's dialogue. Time Ron wastes talking is time that could have been spent watching him get cucked.
Make sure Rita isn't watching before the make-up sex.
You know she's writing all the anti-Ron fics.
 
Been there, done that.
Man, Harry is an antagonistic ass in a very realistic teenage boy manner in this book. But he also has reason to be; he's anticipating death and public humiliation (hopefully in that order), and the only one in his corner right now (and who he was clearly hoping would have a solution for him) is trying to be emotionally supportive instead of solving the damn problem.

I wonder what "Dark" means specifically in the context of creatures.
"We don't like them.", I assume; thestrals seem very clearly coded to dark magics, and yet they have a fine place in wizarding society.

These objects seem virtually useless in any place where humans congregate in large numbers.
It does take a fair amount of cojones (or whatever they're called in magical Britian) to use Mad-Eye's personal spy suite while impersonating him and take the risk that his gear doesn't act like the Marauder's Map (or Draco's badges) and specifically misbehave to fuck you over, because of course Mad-Eye planned for this.

I will say that while the twists of the earlier books were perhaps overdeveloped and foreshadowed, I have been looking for subtle clues that might encourage the reader to piece things together, and while stuff is being summarized or skipped for brevity, I feel like there's both no real thematic hints as to what is going on, and that there are a lot of in-world logistical questions that feel very glossed-over.

Bureaucrats.
I am looking forward to the next book, yes.

Maybe having one of the judges be a guy who runs sports books on the side is a dumb idea.
Again, this feels very much like a set of traditions that sprang up when the judges that were too obvious and dishonest in their judgements got ganged up on by the other schools and/or the theoretically-neutral arbitrator, so having said arbitrator being expected to have a financial interest, but to also want to live to spend it.

I'll also say that while I enjoy having the bros back together, I remember this being more of a learning experience for Harry and less of a prize awarded for sticking to his guns. He was right, Ron was wrong, and a dramatic event was needed to show that, and while he recognized that once Ron understood his side of things he didn't need anything further, he still was rewarded for holding out.

It's very realistic, given Harry's age and personality, but I feel like as we move from "Children do stupid shit and learn about the consequences of their actions." to "Teenagers do ambiguous shit and consequences may happen, or maybe not, the world is complicated and the adults are definitely not in charge, have fun!", we will go fully from Boy's Adventure to Teen Drama.
 
Then, his wife... went back to France!)
That is a sad story. France.

Like hell the Dursleys register as "regular" to anyone.
Maybe the wizards thought they were undercover operatives posing as normal people.

It's probably for the best we never actually see the year 7 curriculum, because I'm guessing it wouldn't have seemed much more complicated than what they're doing now.
Year 7 is the only year actual magic gets taught.

I mean, you can scalp a guy with no hair. I wonder, would casting the spell on a dragon cause the equivalent of a 404 error, or just strip a random, roughly human scalp sized patch of scales?
Grows skin, then hair, then scalps it. On top of the scales.

Molly Weasley: What's wrong with my bacon sandwiches?

Spiders: Apologise, young man!
The spiders came with him to Hogwarts, but they can't hide from Molly, so he's not perfectly happy there.

I wonder what "Dark" means specifically in the context of creatures.
Bothersome and/or unwanted.

Man, that's some Lisa Simpson dedication to good grades. At least after Harry is fried alive Hermione will be able to get into all those witch universities that don't exist?
We just need to wait until the series lasts long enough for the main character to age out of primary education with the ratings high enough, then she can attend Weirdsister College.

Mr. and Mrs. Dursley, of number four, Privet Drive, are proud to say that they are perfectly normal, thank you very much.
You're sure they're not Local People?
 
Back
Top Bottom