The Quest for... Win?: White-Kettle Shufflepunk Reads Harry Potter

  • ⚙️ Performance issue identified and being addressed.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
If I were writing it, I'd have made AK a cast from lifeforce spell, where it can be buffered by hatred and Dark corruption, but leaves scars on your soul; it's an "This will absolutely kill your target if you perform it correctly, but either you die, or are spiritually maimed, or have enough Dark built up in you that murder doesn't move the needle on who you are."
I always thought it'd be neat to explain it like energybending in The Last Airbender - AK kills by creating some spiritual connection where the caster's soul directly throttles the target's soul. Just without the "also the target can reverse it and take you out just as easily" bit from energybending.
 
It's funny that in this book it's "We don't need books." and the next one is "WE ONLY NEED BOOKS. GOVERNMENT APPROVED BOOKS."
It’s funny that the murderous psychopathic criminal is arguably the second best Defense teacher they ever get. Snape’s definitely less effective, especially at teaching Harry for obvious reasons, but he does seem to try to comprehensively teach practical skills and knowledge. Lupin stays winning though, even if his class is borderline Magical Creatures.
 
Jinxing Defense Against the Dark Arts really was Voldemort's best strategic move. I still think these should be two different classes.
Oh absolutely. Care of Magical creatures ought to also include "being careful about magical creatures" and "magical self defense" should focus on what wizards do to each other.

He decided what colour blue was.
Bah. He wasn't even remotely pluripotent, nevermind omnipotent.

What a weird typo, mixing up Harry and Hermione's names like that.
Harry was too busy feeling the spider's pain to speak.

So, it's pretty obvious that, in-universe, Avada Kedavra filtered into Muggle mass consciousness in the form of "Abracadabra", probably the most famous magic words in the world. So, I guess the spell most Muggles were likely to encounter wasn't "double ham" or "pick up rock", but "you die now!" Doesn't speak well of ancient wizards, honestly.
Ancient wizards just got so pissed off at the mundanes saying Abracadabra they made avada kedavra purely out of spite.
(Fun word fact, Abracadraba is I create like the word while Avada is "Thus iy is destroyed")

Either that or have Neville try the Cruciatus Curse on Snape.
Snape only lets Hardbroom Cruciatus him.

Literally anything solid between you and the curse blocks it.
So long as you're not holding or wearing it, AK has 0 penetration power.
 
and then pointing out later that it was also still focusing on Lavender when the rest of the lesson is going on is kind of creepy when you think about it.
Yeah I figured that's what Lavender (or was it Parvati?) meant when she later she says that eye is creepy and shouldn't be allowed. And yet Moody's still somehow less of a pedo creep than Krum or Fenrir Greyback.
 
Imagine reading this and assuming Rowling is making a point about black people.
That's actually the sort of thing advocates for the Peculiar Institution did say in its defense. That was mostly bullshit of course, but you might be surprised to learn that it wasn't entirely. The practice of slavery was incredibly varied across the breadth of the South, and it wasn't always whips and chains. After the war, there were a number of cases of freed slaves remaining loyal to their former masters.
 
Early next morning, Harry woke with a plan fully formed in his mind, as though his sleeping brain had been working on it all night. He got up, dressed in the pale dawn light, left the dormitory without waking Ron, and went back down to the deserted common room. Here he took a piece of parchment from the table upon which his Divination homework still lay and wrote the following letter:

Dear Sirius,

I reckon I just imagined my scar hurting, I was half asleep when I wrote to you last time. There’s no point coming back, everything’s fine here. Don’t worry about me, my head feels completely normal.

Harry

To his credit, Harry has a perfectly good reason to prefer Sirius stay away (he doesn't want his soul sucked out, rendering him equivalent of both a Funko Pop and someone who likes Funko Pops) but it's still so authentically teenage. I wonder how many adolescents (boys especially) die of shit like cancer because they don't want to make shit awkward. Also, I would point out that Sirius has probably set off for Scotland well before his letter got here, but that seems like the kind of thing a kid would overlook.

The Owlery was a circular stone room, rather cold and drafty, because none of the windows had glass in them. The floor was entirely covered in straw, owl droppings, and the regurgitated skeletons of mice and voles.

Much like the Great Hall.

He spotted Hedwig nestled between a barn owl and a tawny, and hurried over to her, sliding a little on the dropping-strewn floor.

It took him a while to persuade her to wake up and then to look at him, as she kept shuffling around on her perch, showing him her tail. She was evidently still furious about his lack of gratitude the previous night. In the end, it was Harry suggesting she might be too tired, and that perhaps he would ask Ron to borrow Pigwidgeon, that made her stick out her leg and allow him to tie the letter to it.

Man, imagine all the kids who bought owls as pets because of Harry Potter, only to discover they were not in fact borderline sapient carrier pigeons.

Harry did his best not to worry about Sirius over the next couple of weeks. True, he could not stop himself from looking anxiously around every morning when the post owls arrived, nor, late at night before he went to sleep, prevent himself from seeing horrible visions of Sirius, cornered by dementors down some dark London street, but between times he tried to keep his mind off his godfather. He wished he still had Quidditch to distract him; nothing worked so well on a troubled mind as a good, hard training session.

I imagine whoever the new captain was supposed to be is fucking seething right now. Or relieved he's been spared Wood's curse. Also, what exactly does training drills look like for a seeker? "See that small fast thing? get it!"

To their surprise, Professor Moody had announced that he would be putting the Imperius Curse on each of them in turn, to demonstrate its power and to see whether they could resist its effects.

“But — but you said it’s illegal, Professor,” said Hermione uncertainly as Moody cleared away the desks with a sweep of his wand, leaving a large clear space in the middle of the room. “You said — to use it against another human was —”

“Dumbledore wants you taught what it feels like,” said Moody, his magical eye swiveling onto Hermione and fixing her with an eerie, unblinking stare. “If you’d rather learn the hard way — when someone’s putting it on you so they can control you completely — fine by me. You’re excused. Off you go.”

I'm reminded of how, after the Dunblane Massacre, British became so strict, their Olympic shooting team had to practise in places like Northern Ireland and the Isle of Man. You know, in case if these elite athletes decided to shoot up a school with their pistols. If you're wondering why they could practise in Northern Ireland and the Isle of Man despite those two places both being British territory, Northern Ireland has an unusual degree of autonomy in some areas because of the Good Friday Agreement. For example, Northern Ireland separately legalised gay marriage some six years after the rest of the UK. So, for a while there, you could own a gun, but not marry another dude. Feel free to decide how you feel about that, but do tell me if the kids start making Rhodesia edits about Ulster. The Isle of Man on the other hand is what's called an Overseas Crown Dependency, which means that while the UK is in charge of its military and foreign policy, it is technically still a self-governing country in its own right. For instance, it only decriminalised gay... anything until 1992. I assume that had something to with the legend that if ever there was not a man made fire burning somewhere on Manx soil, the entire isle would be pulled back into fairyland. One imagines Keir Starmer now has crack teams of put-outers scouring the land.

Also, we've seen that the Imperius Curse effects animals, and later we see it can be used on magical nonhumans like goblins--do you think there's special licensing for people in Hagrid adjacent fields?

Moody began to beckon students forward in turn and put the Imperius Curse upon them. Harry watched as, one by one, his classmates did the most extraordinary things under its influence. Dean Thomas hopped three times around the room, singing the national anthem.

Do British wizards sing "God Save the Queen" (or King if we're talking Current Year) or do they have their own version? Enya's "The Celts" perhaps?

Lavender Brown imitated a squirrel. Neville performed a series of quite astonishing gymnastics he would certainly not have been capable of in his normal state. Not one of them seemed to be able to fight off the curse, and each of them recovered only when Moody had removed it.

“Potter,” Moody growled, “you next.”

That was like seven episodes of Bewitched in five minutes.

Harry moved forward into the middle of the classroom, into the space that Moody had cleared of desks. Moody raised his wand, pointed it at Harry, and said, “Imperio!”

It was the most wonderful feeling. Harry felt a floating sensation as every thought and worry in his head was wiped gently away, leaving nothing but a vague, untraceable happiness. He stood there feeling immensely relaxed, only dimly aware of everyone watching him.

And then he heard Mad-Eye Moody’s voice, echoing in some distant chamber of his empty brain: Jump onto the desk … jump onto the desk. …

Rowling's magic is overall quite slapdash and thin, but when she zeroes in on a specific idea, she can be quite interesting or evocative. This, for instance, is a nicely insidious conception of a mind-control trance.

Harry bent his knees obediently, preparing to spring.

Jump onto the desk. …

Why, though? Another voice had awoken in the back of his brain.

Stupid thing to do, really, said the voice.

Jump onto the desk. …

No, I don’t think I will, thanks, said the other voice, a little more firmly … no, I don’t really want to. …

Jump! NOW!

The next thing Harry felt was considerable pain. He had both jumped and tried to prevent himself from jumping — the result was that he’d smashed headlong into the desk, knocking it over, and, by the feeling in his legs, fractured both his kneecaps.

Something very British about this depiction of a guy resisting mind-control. "Nah, no thanks."

“Now, that’s more like it!” growled Moody’s voice, and suddenly, Harry felt the empty, echoing feeling in his head disappear. He remembered exactly what was happening, and the pain in his knees seemed to double.

“Look at that, you lot … Potter fought! He fought it, and he damn near beat it! We’ll try that again, Potter, and the rest of you, pay attention — watch his eyes, that’s where you see it — very good, Potter, very good indeed! They’ll have trouble controlling you!”

I like to think if False-Eye Moody had somehow survived this scheme, Voldemort would've used these sessions to determine who among Harry's age cohort might be worth the trouble of bewitching.

“The way he talks,” Harry muttered as he hobbled out of the Defense Against the Dark Arts class an hour later (Moody had insisted on putting Harry through his paces four times in a row, until Harry could throw off the curse entirely)

As you can see, Barty is fucking method.

“you’d think we were all going to be attacked any second.”

“Yeah, I know,” said Ron, who was skipping on every alternate step. He had had much more difficulty with the curse than Harry, though Moody assured him the effects would wear off by lunch-time.

Harry, so far every year of secondary has ended with you nearly being murdered and/or spiritually obliterated by depression demons. Last year, you found out your best mate's pet rat was a turncoat who signed your parents' death warrant. The guy who actually killed them's closest followers still have the ear of the government. If anything, you should think Mad-Eye is too happy-go-lucky.

Maybe my mistake is assuming Harry's life has only been this way since he started Hogwarts. Maybe he's been fending off assassins and evildoers since kindergarten, and he no longer even registers that level of danger as something to worry about. Hell, now he's knows "Expelliarmus" instead of just "cricket bat."

“No wonder they were glad to get shot of him at the Ministry. Did you hear him telling Seamus what he did to that witch who shouted ‘Boo’ behind him on April Fools’ Day?

He wasn't even startled, he just felt she needed to be punished for such a lame fucking April Fools. Admittedly, hardly any worse than most April Fools jokes.

(That CollegeHumor one where they made a clip of "the movie where Sinbad plays a genie" was pretty tight, though)

All the fourth years had noticed a definite increase in the amount of work they were required to do this term. Professor McGonagall explained why, when the class gave a particularly loud groan at the amount of Transfiguration homework she had assigned.

“You are now entering a most important phase of your magical education!” she told them, her eyes glinting dangerously behind her square spectacles. “Your Ordinary Wizarding Levels are drawing closer —”

“We don’t take O.W.L.s till fifth year!” said Dean Thomas indignantly.

“Maybe not, Thomas, but believe me, you need all the preparation you can get! Miss Granger remains the only person in this class who has managed to turn a hedgehog into a satisfactory pincushion. I might remind you that your pincushion, Thomas, still curls up in fright if anyone approaches it with a pin!”

One way I think you can categorise fantasy stories is whether they're "about" magic. Not whether they have magic in them (though even that isn't always a given) but if the nature of magic is a central conflict or more a plot device or flavouring. The Magic Goes Away by Larry Niven and Robert Jordan's Wheel of Time are both great (but very different) examples of the former sort of story--there's a problem with magic itself the characters have to deal with. Most of Brandon Sanderson's works centre around elaborate, highly specific magic systems. On the other hand, you have works like say, The Lord of the Rings, or Once and Future King, where magic and fantastical elements are very present and relevant, but not the point.

To clarify, the latter type of story's magic isn't necessarily less well thought out than the former's, just as a story with a "hard" magic system can still have good characters and deep human themes. Tolkien clearly put a lot of thought into the metaphysics of his world (especially in regards to his Catholicism) and the logic of how the various good and evil miracle workers do what they do. But Lord of the Rings is much more concerned with how Frodo and Sam made it to Mount Doom without being corrupted (yes, I know Frodo succumbed, he still got there) than say, how the Lord Ruler combines Allomancy and Feruchemy to overcomes the limitations of both.

Harry Potter is most definitely the second type of story, which is fortunate, because Rowling's magic remains very slapdash in ways I think matter. As I said, Rowling's not bad at coming up with say, individual magical objects or spells. I think the Secret Keeper is a cool concept, I like Riddikulus as a very literal metaphor for coping with fear via laughter, the Put-Outer is classic imagery, etcetera. The educational aspect feels really half-baked. There's no real hint of depth or cohesion. We're told Harry's studies are getting harder and harder, but he seems to doing the same whimsical Transfiguration exercises he's been assigned since he was eleven. You never really get the sense of Harry increasing in his understanding of either the practise or theory of magic. As I said, Harry Potter isn't really a story about Harry becoming a master sorcerer, and that's fine, but I do think it could've complemented his character growth, especially since this is the sort of universe where things like love and the soul (both things Rowling is clearly quite concerned with) are concrete forces that have material effects on the world.

Harry and Ron were deeply amused when Professor Trelawney told them that they had received top marks for their homework in their next Divination class. She read out large portions of their predictions, commending them for their unflinching acceptance of the horrors in store for them — but they were less amused when she asked them to do the same thing for the month after next; both of them were running out of ideas for catastrophes.

This is how you get dead fics.

Meanwhile Professor Binns, the ghost who taught History of Magic, had them writing weekly essays on the goblin rebellions of the eighteenth century.

Not surprised, it's all he talks about. Could be worse, though. He could be making you study the goblin rebellion of the late nineteenth century...

Professor Snape was forcing them to research antidotes. They took this one seriously, as he had hinted that he might be poisoning one of them before Christmas to see if their antidote worked.

It's a shame wizards don't seem to have invented lawsuits.

Professor Flitwick had asked them to read three extra books in preparation for their lesson on Summoning Charms.

A reminder that later on, Harry is able to perform a spell with just the incantation, without even knowing what it does.

Even Hagrid was adding to their workload. The Blast-Ended Skrewts were growing at a remarkable pace given that nobody had yet discovered what they ate.

Has someone done a headcount of the students lately?

Hagrid was delighted, and as part of their “project,” suggested that they come down to his hut on alternate evenings to observe the skrewts and make notes on their extraordinary behavior.

“I will not,” said Draco Malfoy flatly when Hagrid had proposed this with the air of Father Christmas pulling an extra-large toy out of his sack. “I see enough of these foul things during lessons, thanks.”

I mean, rude, but I understand the sentiment.

“Yeh’ll do wha’ yer told,” he growled, “or I’ll be takin’ a leaf outta Professor Moody’s book. … I hear yeh made a good ferret, Malfoy.”

Dudley: FINISH WHAT YOU STARTED, GIANT.

The Gryffindors roared with laughter. Malfoy flushed with anger, but apparently the memory of Moody’s punishment was still sufficiently painful to stop him from retorting. Harry, Ron, and Hermione returned to the castle at the end of the lesson in high spirits; seeing Hagrid put down Malfoy was particularly satisfying, especially because Malfoy had done his very best to get Hagrid sacked the previous year.

Normally I'm down for mistreating Draco, but it's hard for me to cheer for Hagrid when he's wasting a year of instruction on what amounts to an illegal vanity project.

TRIWIZARD TOURNAMENT

The delegations from Beauxbatons and Durmstrang will be arriving at 6 o’clock on Friday the 30th of October. Lessons will end half an hour early —


“Brilliant!” said Harry. “It’s Potions last thing on Friday! Snape won’t have time to poison us all!”

Students will return their bags and books to their dormitories and assemble in front of the castle to greet our guests before the Welcoming Feast.

White-Kettle Shufflepunk will again bitch about the movie version.

“Only a week away!” said Ernie Macmillan of Hufflepuff, emerging from the crowd, his eyes gleaming. “I wonder if Cedric knows? Think I’ll go and tell him. …”

“Cedric?” said Ron blankly as Ernie hurried off.

“Diggory,” said Harry. “He must be entering the tournament.”

“That idiot, Hogwarts champion?” said Ron as they pushed their way through the chattering crowd toward the staircase.

“He’s not an idiot. You just don’t like him because he beat Gryffindor at Quidditch,” said Hermione. “I’ve heard he’s a really good student — and he’s a prefect.”

Ron: Having Cedric Diggory be Hogwarts champion is a humiliation ritual!

(I try not to do jokes that'll be indecipherable a week later, but let me have this.)

She spoke as though this settled the matter.

“You only like him because he’s handsome,” said Ron scathingly.

“Excuse me, I don’t like people just because they’re handsome!” said Hermione indignantly.

Ron gave a loud false cough, which sounded oddly like “Lockhart!”

Lockhart has been molested ten times since his return.

The appearance of the sign in the entrance hall had a marked effect upon the inhabitants of the castle. During the following week, there seemed to be only one topic of conversation, no matter where Harry went:

--Gaza.

the Triwizard Tournament.

--is a distraction from Gaza.

Rumors were flying from student to student like highly contagious germs: who was going to try for Hogwarts champion, what the tournament would involve, how the students from Beauxbatons and Durmstrang differed from themselves.

The movie: One are girls, one are boys!

Harry noticed too that the castle seemed to be undergoing an extra-thorough cleaning. Several grimy portraits had been scrubbed, much to the displeasure of their subjects, who sat huddled in their frames muttering darkly and wincing as they felt their raw pink faces.

Man, imagine if Ecce Homo was a wizard painting:

1771742164666.png


Christ our Lord and Saviour: KILL MEEEEEEEEE!

“Longbottom, kindly do not reveal that you can’t even perform a simple Switching Spell in front of anyone from Durmstrang!” Professor McGonagall barked at the end of one particularly difficult lesson, during which Neville had accidentally transplanted his own ears onto a cactus.

McGonagall, it's not Neville's fault you've been teaching nothing but stupid gimmicks for four years. These kids don't even know how to make antimatter yet.

Harry, Ron, and Hermione sat down beside Fred and George at the Gryffindor table. Once again, and most unusually, they were sitting apart from everyone else and conversing in low voices. Ron led the way over to them.

“It’s a bummer, all right,” George was saying gloomily to Fred. “But if he won’t talk to us in person, we’ll have to send him the letter after all. Or we’ll stuff it into his hand. He can’t avoid us forever.”

Ah, shit, the twins have become KPop stans.

“You two got any ideas on the Triwizard Tournament yet?” Harry asked. “Thought any more about trying to enter?”

“I asked McGonagall how the champions are chosen but she wasn’t telling,” said George bitterly. “She just told me to shut up and get on with transfiguring my raccoon.”

Is Minerva just a zoosadist?

“Who are the judges?” Harry asked.

“Well, the Heads of the participating schools are always on the panel,” said Hermione, and everyone looked around at her, rather surprised, “because all three of them were injured during the Tournament of 1792, when a cockatrice the champions were supposed to be catching went on the rampage.”

Fun fact, cockatrices are said to be able to kill with a glance, like a basilisk. This seems a poor choice for a spectator event.

he noticed them all looking at her and said, with her usual air of impatience that nobody else had read all the books she had, “It’s all in Hogwarts, A History. Though, of course, that book’s not entirely reliable. A Revised History of Hogwarts would be a more accurate title. Or A Highly Biased and Selective History of Hogwarts, Which Glosses Over the Nastier Aspects of the School.”

Goblet of Fire is a reminder that this sort of overbearing activist has been with us a long time. The main thing that's changed is how much they've dominated culture the last decade or so.

"What are you on about?” said Ron, though Harry thought he knew what was coming.

Ron: She's going to try and cancel Martin Miggs, isn't she?
“House-elves!” said Hermione, her eyes flashing. “Not once, in over a thousand pages, does Hogwarts, A History mention that we are all colluding in the oppression of a hundred slaves!”

Do you think Hermione is going to fall into the classic Anglo trap of assuming that the Europeans are much more Sensible and Enlightened about house-elves, without reading up about their actual policies and attitudes? Seriously, so many Americans I've seen who don't know most European countries set a twelve-to-fourteen week limit on abortion.

Harry shook his head and applied himself to his scrambled eggs. His and Ron’s lack of enthusiasm had done nothing whatsoever to curb Hermione’s determination to pursue justice for house-elves. True, both of them had paid two Sickles for a S.P.E.W. badge, but they had only done it to keep her quiet. Their Sickles had been wasted, however; if anything, they seemed to have made Hermione more vociferous. She had been badgering Harry and Ron ever since, first to wear the badges, then to persuade others to do the same, and she had also taken to rattling around the Gryffindor common room every evening, cornering people and shaking the collecting tin under their noses.

“You do realize that your sheets are changed, your fires lit, your classrooms cleaned, and your food cooked by a group of magical creatures who are unpaid and enslaved?” she kept saying fiercely.

I will say this, as clumsy and silly as Hermione is being, I do respect her a lot more than I do most of her real life equivalents. Your average adolescent social justice warrior usually supports causes that already enjoy widespread sympathy and endorsement from tastemakers and institutions, and--let's be real--is probably mostly doing it out of boredom or a desire for social cachet. Hermione meanwhile is doing what's doing because of genuine moral outrage, and is at least willing to risk social censure for it--she's not a clout chaser, is what I'm saying. Seriously, apparently Greta Thunberg is the one young person without climate anxiety.

Ron now rolled his eyes at the ceiling, which was flooding them all in autumn sunlight, and Fred became extremely interested in his bacon (both twins had refused to buy a S.P.E.W. badge). George, however, leaned in toward Hermione.

“Listen, have you ever been down in the kitchens, Hermione?”

“No, of course not,” said Hermione curtly, “I hardly think students are supposed to —”

“Well, we have,” said George, indicating Fred, “loads of times, to nick food. And we’ve met them, and they’re happy. They think they’ve got the best job in the world—”

Really, if Hermione wanted to improve the lives of the Hogwarts castelves, she'd campaign to have Dudley enrolled.

House-elf, deliriously happy: I haven't slept in weeks!

“That’s because they’re uneducated and brainwashed!”

I am still curious whether Rowling imagined house-elves as mystical embodiments of hard work or like, a race the wizards had reduced to helotage long ago. These days, I kind of lean towards the former, partly because it's honestly more interesting from a spec fic perspective, partly because house-elves are clearly a lot stronger than wizards.

Hedwig arrives with a letter from Sirius--he's back in the country, wants Harry to keep him up-to-date on everything, but also suggests Harry not use the same owl twice.

Anyway, it's time to welcome the visiting students:

Something large, much larger than a broomstick — or, indeed, a hundred broomsticks — was hurtling across the deep blue sky toward the castle, growing larger all the time.

“It’s a dragon!” shrieked one of the first years, losing her head completely.

“Don’t be stupid … it’s a flying house!” said Dennis Creevey.

I'm glad Dennis can now partake in the time honoured custom of belittling ickle firsties.

Dennis’s guess was closer. … As the gigantic black shape skimmed over the treetops of the Forbidden Forest and the lights shining from the castle windows hit it, they saw a gigantic, powder-blue, horse-drawn carriage, the size of a large house, soaring toward them, pulled through the air by a dozen winged horses, all palominos, and each the size of an elephant.

The front three rows of students drew backward as the carriage hurtled ever lower, coming in to land at a tremendous speed — then, with an almighty crash that made Neville jump backward onto a Slytherin fifth year’s foot, the horses’ hooves, larger than dinner plates, hit the ground. A second later, the carriage landed too, bouncing upon its vast wheels, while the golden horses tossed their enormous heads and rolled large, fiery red eyes.

Harry just had time to see that the door of the carriage bore a coat of arms (two crossed, golden wands, each emitting three stars) before it opened.

You sure you want to do this cool intro? Why not a stupid little dance?

A boy in pale blue robes jumped down from the carriage, bent forward, fumbled for a moment with something on the carriage floor, and unfolded a set of golden steps. He sprang back respectfully. Then Harry saw a shining, high-heeled black shoe emerging from the inside of the carriage — a shoe the size of a child’s sled — followed, almost immediately, by the largest woman he had ever seen in his life. The size of the carriage, and of the horses, was immediately explained. A few people gasped.

Harry had only ever seen one person as large as this woman in his life, and that was Hagrid; he doubted whether there was an inch difference in their heights. Yet somehow — maybe simply because he was used to Hagrid — this woman (now at the foot of the steps, and looking around at the waiting, wide-eyed crowd) seemed even more unnaturally large. As she stepped into the light flooding from the entrance hall, she was revealed to have a handsome, olive-skinned face; large, black, liquid-looking eyes; and a rather beaky nose. Her hair was drawn back in a shining knob at the base of her neck. She was dressed from head to foot in black satin, and many magnificent opals gleamed at her throat and on her thick fingers.

This is Madam Maxine, headmistress of Beauxbatons. If there was an official Harry Potter RPG (and I'm kind of surprised there isn't) she'd probably be an illegal character. I'll explain later.

“My dear Madame Maxime,” he said. “Welcome to Hogwarts.”

“Dumbly-dorr,” said Madame Maxime in a deep voice. “I ’ope I find you well?”

“In excellent form, I thank you,” said Dumbledore.

“My pupils,” said Madame Maxime, waving one of her enormous hands carelessly behind her.

Harry, whose attention had been focused completely upon Madame Maxime, now noticed that about a dozen boys and girls, all, by the look of them, in their late teens, had emerged from the carriage and were now standing behind Madame Maxime. They were shivering, which was unsurprising, given that their robes seemed to be made of fine silk, and none of them were wearing cloaks. A few had wrapped scarves and shawls around their heads. From what Harry could see of them (they were standing in Madame Maxime’s enormous shadow), they were staring up at Hogwarts with apprehensive looks on their faces.

In the films, both Beauxbatons and Durmstrang are single-sex schools--girls and boys respectively. In the books, they're both co-ed. This is because both the French speaking world and Northern Europe both have men and women in them. Perhaps in the films' world, mainland Europe is divided between an oppressive patriarchy and gynarchy, Gender Games style, with the opposite sex denied education and only kept around for breeding. Or maybe it's an Amazon and Gagarin setup where they meet up once every ten years to breed.

Yeah, I don't like how the film handles the foreign schools. I think if the only way you can distinguish the luxury-loving wizards and witches of southern Europe with the grim, dark magic practising sorcerers of the far north is by sex, you're not being very creative with your visual storytelling. Plus, it basically makes the delegations look like clones of Krum and Fleur, which is dull.

“My steeds require — er — forceful ’andling,” said Madame Maxime, looking as though she doubted whether any Care of Magical Creatures teacher at Hogwarts could be up to the job. “Zey are very strong. …”

“I assure you that Hagrid will be well up to the job,” said Dumbledore, smiling.

“Very well,” said Madame Maxime, bowing slightly. “Will you please inform zis ’Agrid zat ze ’orses drink only single-malt whiskey?”

“It will be attended to,” said Dumbledore, also bowing.

Surely French horses only drink wine!

Harry listened; a loud and oddly eerie noise was drifting toward them from out of the darkness: a muffled rumbling and sucking sound, as though an immense vacuum cleaner were moving along a riverbed. …

“The lake!” yelled Lee Jordan, pointing down at it. “Look at the lake!”

From their position at the top of the lawns overlooking the grounds, they had a clear view of the smooth black surface of the water — except that the surface was suddenly not smooth at all. Some disturbance was taking place deep in the center; great bubbles were forming on the surface, waves were now washing over the muddy banks — and then, out in the very middle of the lake, a whirlpool appeared, as if a giant plug had just been pulled out of the lake’s floor. …
What seemed to be a long, black pole began to rise slowly out of the heart of the whirlpool … and then Harry saw the rigging. …

“It’s a mast!” he said to Ron and Hermione.

Slowly, magnificently, the ship rose out of the water, gleaming in the moonlight. It had a strangely skeletal look about it, as though it were a resurrected wreck, and the dim, misty lights shimmering at its portholes looked like ghostly eyes. Finally, with a great sloshing noise, the ship emerged entirely, bobbing on the turbulent water, and began to glide toward the bank. A few moments later, they heard the splash of an anchor being thrown down in the shallows, and the thud of a plank being lowered onto the bank.

Again, are we sure we don't want the students to just dance into the Great Hall, for that full Glee vibe?

People were disembarking; they could see their silhouettes passing the lights in the ship’s portholes. All of them, Harry noticed, seemed to be built along the lines of Crabbe and Goyle

Insert joke about Soviet lady athletes here.

but then, as they drew nearer, walking up the lawns into the light streaming from the entrance hall, he saw that their bulk was really due to the fact that they were wearing cloaks of some kind of shaggy, matted fur. But the man who was leading them up to the castle was wearing furs of a different sort: sleek and silver, like his hair.

“Dumbledore!” he called heartily as he walked up the slope. “How are you, my dear fellow, how are you?”

“Blooming, thank you, Professor Karkaroff,” Dumbledore replied.

Karkaroff had a fruity, unctuous voice; when he stepped into the light pouring from the front doors of the castle they saw that he was tall and thin like Dumbledore, but his white hair was short, and his goatee (finishing in a small curl) did not entirely hide his rather weak chin. When he reached Dumbledore, he shook hands with both of his own.

That just makes me picture Karkaroff shaking his own hands.

Karkaroff beckoned forward one of his students. As the boy passed, Harry caught a glimpse of a prominent curved nose and thick black eyebrows. He didn’t need the punch on the arm Ron gave him, or the hiss in his ear, to recognize that profile.

“Harry — it’s Krum!”

1771745851309.png

Can Oblina and Ickis be far behind? Well, Oblina is probably on the Beauxbatons carriage.
 
In the films, both Beauxbatons and Durmstrang are single-sex schools--girls and boys respectively. In the books, they're both co-ed. This is because both the French speaking world and Northern Europe both have men and women in them. Perhaps in the films' world, mainland Europe is divided between an oppressive patriarchy and gynarchy, Gender Games style, with the opposite sex denied education and only kept around for breeding. Or maybe it's an Amazon and Gagarin setup where they meet up once every ten years to breed.
Let's be real, the reason the films made them all single gender is that if a Hot Goth Girl Durmstrang chick showed up in the movie everyone would be asking "Why the fuck didn't Ron hook up with her, he has real Step on me Dommy Mommy energy"
 
Let's be real, the reason the films made them all single gender is that if a Hot Goth Girl Durmstrang chick showed up in the movie everyone would be asking "Why the fuck didn't Ron hook up with her, he has real Step on me Dommy Mommy energy"
Actually I don't remember female Durmstrangs being mentioned, only a male Beauxbatons student
 
I am still curious whether Rowling imagined house-elves as mystical embodiments of hard work or like, a race the wizards had reduced to helotage long ago. These days, I kind of lean towards the former, partly because it's honestly more interesting from a spec fic perspective, partly because house-elves are clearly a lot stronger than wizards.
I also suspect the former, as it lines up nicely with the idea that Hermione's SPEW campaign was meant to evoke a particular sort of feminist activist who genuinely meant well but simply could not understand the position of those whose lives they wanted to improve and thus not communicate to them effectively at all.

Again, are we sure we don't want the students to just dance into the Great Hall, for that full Glee vibe?
I don't know, during the middle of the show I could see the show having a set piece for a musical number with giant flying horses and a skeletal ship rising from the water that gets used exactly once and then gets called out by Jane Lynch for being absurd and wasteful.
 
Actually I don't remember female Durmstrangs being mentioned, only a male Beauxbatons student
IIRC there's more than one male Beauxbatons student mentioned later on, as well as one female Durmstrang student seen in the great hall. Karkaroff and Maxime only brought a small group of students whom they deemed to be potential Triwizard champions. If Karkaroff has a low opinion of women it seems perfectly in character, he's a former death eater after all.
 
McGonagall, it's not Neville's fault you've been teaching nothing but stupid gimmicks for four years. These kids don't even know how to make antimatter yet.
You know, in settings like this, I think a fun detail is that advanced science doesn't work and never has; 'scientists' have just been wizards who have let certain magical advances catch on, but specifically in a misleading way, exactly so that if muggles get ahold of magical processes, they will waste their time trying to manipulate nonsense concepts like subatomic particles instead of catching up on actual magic and possibly becoming dangerous.

Goblet of Fire is a reminder that this sort of overbearing activist has been with us a long time. The main thing that's changed is how much they've dominated culture the last decade or so.
I recommend to the class that you check out some classic Kipling, specifically "Gods of the Copybook Headings", from time to time. It's also a very good reminder that the sins of modernity are themselves very, very old, and while they cause great harm, they haven't actually achieved total domination and taken over the entire world so far.

Do you think Hermione is going to fall into the classic Anglo trap of assuming that the Europeans are much more Sensible and Enlightened about house-elves, without reading up about their actual policies and attitudes? Seriously, so many Americans I've seen who don't know most European countries set a twelve-to-fourteen week limit on abortion.
Actually, question for my less-enlightened Anglo posters; how much Anglo solidarity is there in this modern era (and a few decades previously)? Do Brits assume they have more in common with European mainlanders than Americans or other ex-colonists?

Also, if we are going to go in on the metaphor, does that mean that there are huge numbers of house-elves trafficked both historically and fairly recently to the middle east, because they kept them castrated and thus needed to keep importing them?

...Man, there is definitely a very dark joke I could make about cross-dressing house-elf dancers at this point, but I think I will leave that degeneracy to others for now.

--she's not a clout chaser, is what I'm saying.
Yeah, say what you will about the tea-swilling limeys, they actually have extremely solid historic credentials in the "Crusade against slavery for reasons of morality and ideology rather than any personal or economic benefit." department.

That being said, this does feel...I dunno, slightly artificial? I feel that if maybe we had at least one line of Hermione referencing that she was also studying Muggle history and was specifically drawing from the proud heritage of her people, and that was enough to give her a plan and keep her galvanized even if the rest of the wizarding world was completely indifferent, it would be something, but I think that the presence of the clout-chaser means we could benefit from explicitly showing that she's not just a bad clout-chaser, she's legitimately after another goal (and just bad at that goal, since there are no book of collected house-elf interviews and philosophy).

...partly because house-elves are clearly a lot stronger than wizards.
I don't know if they are. They feel more like competent, practiced, but extremely-specific-in-focus adult wizards; they can do some powerful tricks, but nothing we see them do seems to exceed, e.g., Dumbledore's own utility magic, and they are made of meat and die when you poke holes with them as well. I'd say that the average house-elf is probably in the 75% to 90% of average wizarding ability, but the wizard power distribution is not a goddamn bell curve, and we see more outliers at both ends, so "clearly a lot stronger than most wizards" is how I'd phrase it.

But man, I can definitely feel that increasing page count. Stuff is still happening in the books, but there are entire plotlines that have only barely been established and need to be fully developed. I don't think it's bad yet, but I definitely perceive even with the Quest-format eliding, the growing length of the books.
 
You know, in settings like this, I think a fun detail is that advanced science doesn't work and never has; 'scientists' have just been wizards who have let certain magical advances catch on, but specifically in a misleading way, exactly so that if muggles get ahold of magical processes, they will waste their time trying to manipulate nonsense concepts like subatomic particles instead of catching up on actual magic and possibly becoming dangerous.

The Technocratic Union thanks you for your support, Sleeper.
 
You know, in settings like this, I think a fun detail is that advanced science doesn't work and never has; 'scientists' have just been wizards who have let certain magical advances catch on, but specifically in a misleading way, exactly so that if muggles get ahold of magical processes, they will waste their time trying to manipulate nonsense concepts like subatomic particles instead of catching up on actual magic and possibly becoming dangerous.

Me: So, if the Killing Curse passes through air without impediment, what about water?

Wizard: Silly Muggle, air isn't actual matter.

But man, I can definitely feel that increasing page count. Stuff is still happening in the books, but there are entire plotlines that have only barely been established and need to be fully developed. I don't think it's bad yet, but I definitely perceive even with the Quest-format eliding, the growing length of the books.

Oh, for sure.

“I don’t believe it!” Ron said, in a stunned voice, as the Hogwarts students filed back up the steps behind the party from Durmstrang. “Krum, Harry! Viktor Krum!”

“For heaven’s sake, Ron, he’s only a Quidditch player,” said Hermione.

I'm impressed Hermione's humoured the boys this long.

Only a Quidditch player?” Ron said, looking at her as though he couldn’t believe his ears. “Hermione — he’s one of the best Seekers in the world!

See, being the best Seeker in the world feels a bit like being the best at Candy Crush. I'm not denying there's skill involved, but there's so much dumb luck involved, and the outcome so binary (catch the Snitch, don't catch the Snitch) that it doesn't feel terribly interesting.

I had no idea he was still at school!”

That feels like an odd thing to not know. You'd think all the Quidditch magazines and shit would make a big deal about the seventeen-year-old wunderkind playing professional Quidditch during the summer holidays. Or the slightly-less-winter holidays, as the case may be. Hell, shouldn't Ron have just realised based on his age? Is this like how black kids are often perceived to be older than say, white kids their age, but with Hungarian guys?

As they recrossed the entrance hall with the rest of the Hogwarts students heading for the Great Hall, Harry saw Lee Jordan jumping up and down on the soles of his feet to get a better look at the back of Krum’s head. Several sixth-year girls were frantically searching their pockets as they walked —

Luckily, Krum was well warded against cock stealing spells.

Nope, they’re upstairs in my bag,” said Harry.

They walked over to the Gryffindor table and sat down. Ron took care to sit on the side facing the doorway, because Krum and his fellow Durmstrang students were still gathered around it, apparently unsure about where they should sit. The students from Beauxbatons had chosen seats at the Ravenclaw table. They were looking around the Great Hall with glum expressions on their faces. Three of them were still clutching scarves and shawls around their heads.

“It’s not that cold,” said Hermione defensively. “Why didn’t they bring cloaks?”

You know what's very English? Having more contempt for the French than the dark wizard kids. I mean, based, but still.

Viktor Krum and his fellow Durmstrang students had settled themselves at the Slytherin table. Harry could see Malfoy, Crabbe, and Goyle looking very smug about this. As he watched, Malfoy bent forward to speak to Krum.

“Yeah, that’s right, smarm up to him, Malfoy,” said Ron scathingly. “I bet Krum can see right through him, though … bet he gets people fawning over him all the time. … Where d’you reckon they’re going to sleep? We could offer him a space in our dormitory, Harry … I wouldn’t mind giving him my bed, I could kip on a camp bed.”

Fred and/or George: Man, Peter leaves school, and Ron immediately starts looking for a new bed warmer.

“They look a lot happier than the Beauxbatons lot,” said Harry.

The Durmstrang students were pulling off their heavy furs and looking up at the starry black ceiling with expressions of interest; a couple of them were picking up the golden plates and goblets and examining them, apparently impressed.

I assume at Durmstrang, the ceiling is tuned to the supermassive black hole at the centre of the galaxy (or if you prefer, the physical aspect of Azathoth, the atomic chaos), in order to remind the students of the inevitability of death. Also, glad they arrived on one of three cloudless nights Hogwarts probably gets a year.

Up at the staff table, Filch, the caretaker, was adding chairs. He was wearing his moldy old tailcoat in honor of the occasion. Harry was surprised to see that he added four chairs, two on either side of Dumbledore’s.

“But there are only two extra people,” Harry said. “Why’s Filch putting out four chairs, who else is coming?”

The prophet Elijah and his boyfriend. Duh.

When all the students had entered the Hall and settled down at their House tables, the staff entered, filing up to the top table and taking their seats. Last in line were Professor Dumbledore, Professor Karkaroff, and Madame Maxime. When their headmistress appeared, the pupils from Beauxbatons leapt to their feet. A few of the Hogwarts students laughed. The Beauxbatons party appeared quite unembarrassed, however, and did not resume their seats until Madame Maxime had sat down on Dumbledore’s left-hand side. Dumbledore remained standing, and a silence fell over the Great Hall.

In a different type of story, I think you could do a lot with comparing and contrasting the culture and pedagogical approaches of the three schools, and how each is influenced by the cultures which produced them. Unlike some of my other comments about Rowling's worldbuilding, this is less me criticising her for a lapse so much as me acknowledging the other kinds of story you could tell with these ingredients.

“Good evening, ladies and gentlemen, ghosts and — most particularly — guests,” said Dumbledore, beaming around at the foreign students. “I have great pleasure in welcoming you all to Hogwarts. I hope and trust that your stay here will be both comfortable and enjoyable.”

One of the Beauxbatons girls still clutching a muffler around her head gave what was unmistakably a derisive laugh.

“No one’s making you stay!” Hermione whispered, bristling at her.

I like that Hermione is the one with the most French hatred.

The plates in front of them filled with food as usual. The house-elves in the kitchen seemed to have pulled out all the stops; there was a greater variety of dishes in front of them than Harry had ever seen, including several that were definitely foreign.

“What’s that?” said Ron, pointing at a large dish of some sort of shellfish stew that stood beside a large steak-and-kidney pudding.

“Bouillabaisse,” said Hermione.

“Bless you,” said Ron.

“It’s French,” said Hermione, “I had it on holiday summer before last. It’s very nice.”

“I’ll take your word for it,” said Ron, helping himself to black pudding.

"I'll stick to my eel pudding, thanks."

I love that Ron has been to fucking Egypt, but not France, despite coming from a culture with access to teleportation, fireplace portals, and flight.

The Great Hall seemed somehow much more crowded than usual, even though there were barely twenty additional students there; perhaps it was because their differently colored uniforms stood out so clearly against the black of the Hogwarts’ robes. Now that they had removed their furs, the Durmstrang students were revealed to be wearing robes of a deep blood red.
Clearly this is one of those days where Hogwarts has closer to a hundred and fifty students than a thousand.

Hagrid sidled into the Hall through a door behind the staff table twenty minutes after the start of the feast. He slid into his seat at the end and waved at Harry, Ron, and Hermione with a very heavily bandaged hand.

“Skrewts doing all right, Hagrid?” Harry called.

“Thrivin’,” Hagrid called back happily.

“Yeah, I’ll just bet they are,” said Ron quietly. “Looks like they’ve finally found a food they like, doesn’t it? Hagrid’s fingers.”

Oh, God, Hagrid is definitely breastfeeding a Skrewt with his own blood, like that movie with the vampire baby.

At that moment, a voice said, “Excuse me, are you wanting ze bouillabaisse?”

It was the girl from Beauxbatons who had laughed during Dumbledore’s speech. She had finally removed her muffler. A long sheet of silvery-blonde hair fell almost to her waist. She had large, deep blue eyes, and very white, even teeth.

Anime girls before the generations of unethical line breeding. Ron immediately assumes she's a veela, which Hermione thinks is a silly idea, because the boys are merely very interested in her, rather than say, trying to kill themselves in such a way their bodies wind up closer to her.

“I’m telling you, that’s not a normal girl!” said Ron, leaning sideways so he could keep a clear view of her. “They don’t make them like that at Hogwarts!”

“They make them okay at Hogwarts,” said Harry without thinking. Cho happened to be sitting only a few places away from the girl with the silvery hair.

I see Harry's more into dragon ladies than bird women.

The two extra guests as it turns out are Ludo Bagman and Barty Crouch.

“The moment has come,” said Dumbledore, smiling around at the sea of upturned faces. “The Triwizard Tournament is about to start. I would like to say a few words of explanation before we bring in the casket —”

“The what?” Harry muttered.

Ron shrugged.
Oh, shit, we're kicking off the tournament with a chthonic sacrifice.


Ron: Not it!

“Mr. Bagman and Mr. Crouch have worked tirelessly over the last few months on the arrangements for the Triwizard Tournament,” Dumbledore continued, “and they will be joining myself, Professor Karkaroff, and Madame Maxime on the panel that will judge the champions’ efforts.”

You'd think having the headmasters judge the champions would cause issues with favouritism. I'm guessing the addition of two extra judges was a patch job introduced centuries ago to end the endless deadlocks.

Filch, who had been lurking unnoticed in a far corner of the Hall, now approached Dumbledore carrying a great wooden chest encrusted with jewels. It looked extremely old. A murmur of excited interest rose from the watching students; Dennis Creevey actually stood on his chair to see it properly, but, being so tiny, his head hardly rose above anyone else’s.

Okay, are the Creeveys Muggleborn wizards, or elven changelings?

“The instructions for the tasks the champions will face this year have already been examined by Mr. Crouch and Mr. Bagman,” said Dumbledore as Filch placed the chest carefully on the table before him, “and they have made the necessary arrangements for each challenge. There will be three tasks, spaced throughout the school year, and they will test the champions in many different ways … their magical prowess — their daring — their powers of deduction — and, of course, their ability to cope with danger.”

"You'd think this would make for a perfect tie-in game, but no."

“As you know, three champions compete in the tournament,” Dumbledore went on calmly, “one from each of the participating schools. They will be marked on how well they perform each of the Tournament tasks and the champion with the highest total after task three will win the Triwizard Cup. The champions will be chosen by an impartial selector: the Goblet of Fire.”

Which despite being in the title does not actually factor into things much at all. It kind of reminds me of how some lit fic books will be called, like, The Perfumist of Treblinka, and then he only turns up in one chapter. I can't blame Rowling for going with that, though. Harry Potter and the Triwizard Tournament somehow reads like the name of a fanfic an eleven-year-old wrote because they were impatient.

Dumbledore now took out his wand and tapped three times upon the top of the casket. The lid creaked slowly open. Dumbledore reached inside it and pulled out a large, roughly hewn wooden cup. It would have been entirely unremarkable had it not been full to the brim with dancing blue-white flames.

Shout out to the film making it a huge stone basin for whatever reason. Reminds me of how much smaller the Mona Lisa is in person that one expects.

Dumbledore closed the casket and placed the goblet carefully on top of it, where it would be clearly visible to everyone in the Hall.

“Anybody wishing to submit themselves as champion must write their name and school clearly upon a slip of parchment and drop it into the goblet,” said Dumbledore. “Aspiring champions have twenty-four hours in which to put their names forward. Tomorrow night, Halloween, the goblet will return the names of the three it has judged most worthy to represent their schools. The goblet will be placed in the entrance hall tonight, where it will be freely accessible to all those wishing to compete.

Oh, in case you're wondering, the kids from the visiting schools who don't get picked don't go home, they just hang out at Hogwarts the rest of the year. I wonder if they go to class with the Hogwarts seventh years, study amongst themselves, or if magical education is largely fake, and thus it doesn't really matter if they essentially drop out their last year.

“Finally, I wish to impress upon any of you wishing to compete that this tournament is not to be entered into lightly. Once a champion has been selected by the Goblet of Fire, he or she is obliged to see the tournament through to the end. The placing of your name in the goblet constitutes a binding, magical contract. There can be no change of heart once you have become a champion. Please be very sure, therefore, that you are wholeheartedly prepared to play before you drop your name into the goblet. Now, I think it is time for bed. Good night to you all.”

Hogwarts/various tinpot dictatorships--forcing athletes to compete with dire threats.

"An Age Line!” Fred Weasley said, his eyes glinting, as they all made their way across the Hall to the doors into the entrance hall. “Well, that should be fooled by an Aging Potion, shouldn’t it? And once your name’s in that goblet, you’re laughing — it can’t tell whether you’re seventeen or not!”

Yes, the magic cup which can determine if you're a skilled and courageous witch or wizard based entirely on your name can't possibly also know how old you are.

“But I don’t think anyone under seventeen will stand a chance,” said Hermione, “we just haven’t learned enough …”

McGonagall hasn't taught you nearly enough ways of torturing small animals.

“Speak for yourself,” said George shortly. “You’ll try and get in, won’t you, Harry?”

Harry: Can I not have a year off for once?

“Where is he?” said Ron, who wasn’t listening to a word of this conversation, but looking through the crowd to see what had become of Krum. “Dumbledore didn’t say where the Durmstrang people are sleeping, did he?”

Ron is going to become Krum's sleep paralysis demon.

But this query was answered almost instantly; they were level with the Slytherin table now, and Karkaroff had just bustled up to his students.

“Back to the ship, then,” he was saying. “Viktor, how are you feeling? Did you eat enough? Should I send for some mulled wine from the kitchens?”

Harry saw Krum shake his head as he pulled his furs back on.

“Professor, I vood like some vine,” said one of the other Durmstrang boys hopefully.

“I wasn’t offering it to you, Poliakoff,” snapped Karkaroff, his warmly paternal air vanishing in an instant. “I notice you have dribbled food all down the front of your robes again, disgusting boy —”

Remember, Poliakoff is probably still one of Karkaroff's favourite students. Unless he only brought along fuck-ups to ensure Krum would be picked, which I could believe.

And then Karkaroff froze. He turned his head back to Harry and stared at him as though he couldn’t believe his eyes. Behind their headmaster, the students from Durmstrang came to a halt too. Karkaroff’s eyes moved slowly up Harry’s face and fixed upon his scar. The Durmstrang students were staring curiously at Harry too. Out of the corner of his eye, Harry saw comprehension dawn on a few of their faces. The boy with food all down his front nudged the girl next to him and pointed openly at Harry’s forehead.

“Yeah, that’s Harry Potter,” said a growling voice from behind them.

Christian Bale Batman is also one of the judges.

“You!” he said, staring at Moody as though unsure he was really seeing him.

“Me,” said Moody grimly. “And unless you’ve got anything to say to Potter, Karkaroff, you might want to move. You’re blocking the doorway.”

I wonder how Harry would've fared at Durmstrang.

The next day:

“Anyone put their name in yet?” Ron asked a third-year girl eagerly.

“All the Durmstrang lot,” she replied. “But I haven’t seen anyone from Hogwarts yet.”

Poliakoff tried drinking from it, which was pretty metal.

“Done it,” Fred said in a triumphant whisper to Harry, Ron, and Hermione. “Just taken it.”

“What?” said Ron.

“The Aging Potion, dung brains,” said Fred.
One drop each,” said George, rubbing his hands together with glee. “We only need to be a few months older.”

I assume the Aging Potion is mostly used in factory farming and sideways child sex trafficking.

“We’re going to split the thousand Galleons between the three of us if one of us wins,” said Lee, grinning broadly.

Don't be greedy, Lee, your mum's a doctor and your dad has that Big Finish money.

Harry watched, fascinated, as Fred pulled a slip of parchment out of his pocket bearing the words Fred Weasley — Hogwarts. Fred walked right up to the edge of the line and stood there, rocking on his toes like a diver preparing for a fifty-foot drop.

I like that the omniscient magic cup needs you to write what school you go to--in case it thinks you're the Fred Weasley from Saint Cyprian's or Brakebills.

Then, with the eyes of every person in the entrance hall upon him, he took a great breath and stepped over the line.

For a split second Harry thought it had worked — George certainly thought so, for he let out a yell of triumph and leapt after Fred — but next moment, there was a loud sizzling sound, and both twins were hurled out of the golden circle as though they had been thrown by an invisible shot-putter. They landed painfully, ten feet away on the cold stone floor, and to add insult to injury, there was a loud popping noise, and both of them sprouted identical long white beards.

The entrance hall rang with laughter. Even Fred and George joined in, once they had gotten to their feet and taken a good look at each other’s beards.

Now they're old enough to rent ultra porn!

“I did warn you,” said a deep, amused voice, and everyone turned to see Professor Dumbledore coming out of the Great Hall. He surveyed Fred and George, his eyes twinkling. “I suggest you both go up to Madam Pomfrey. She is already tending to Miss Fawcett, of Ravenclaw, and Mr. Summers, of Hufflepuff, both of whom decided to age themselves up a little too. Though I must say, neither of their beards is anything like as fine as yours.”

1772177901198.png


Honestly, if your X-gene made this happen this hard, you probably kinda wanted it.

The decorations in the Great Hall had changed this morning. As it was Halloween, a cloud of live bats was fluttering around the enchanted ceiling, while hundreds of carved pumpkins leered from every corner. Harry led the way over to Dean and Seamus, who were discussing those Hogwarts students of seventeen or over who might be entering.

“There’s a rumor going around that Warrington got up early and put his name in,” Dean told Harry. “That big bloke from Slytherin who looks like a sloth.”

Harry, who had played Quidditch against Warrington, shook his head in disgust.

“We can’t have a Slytherin champion!”

1772177993483.png


Average Slytherin after generations of unethical line breeding.

“And all the Hufflepuffs are talking about Diggory,” said Seamus contemptuously. “But I wouldn’t have thought he’d have wanted to risk his good looks.”

I love how everyone talks about Cedric like how people used to talk about Robert Pattinson before we got to know him. Sometimes, the films' casting was so good, it transcended time itself.

“Listen!” said Hermione suddenly.

People were cheering out in the entrance hall. They all swiveled around in their seats and saw Angelina Johnson coming into the Hall, grinning in an embarrassed sort of way. A tall black girl who played Chaser on the Gryffindor Quidditch team, Angelina came over to them, sat down, and said, “Well, I’ve done it! Just put my name in!”

I assume our finest race-baiters are taking a break from being mean to a guy with a neurological disorder to figure out how Ange's name is racist.

A look of great excitement suddenly dawned on Hermione’s face.

“I’ve just realized — I haven’t asked Hagrid to join S.P.E.W. yet!” she said brightly. “Wait for me, will you, while I nip upstairs and get the badges?”

“What is it with her?” said Ron, exasperated, as Hermione ran away up the marble staircase.

Hermione: Unfortunately, I have discovered that when some house-elves are freed, they go mad, turning their magic upon the innocent--

Hagrid: Sign me up!

“What d’you reckon’ll happen to the ones who aren’t chosen?” Ron muttered to Harry as the veela-girl dropped her parchment into the Goblet of Fire. “Reckon they’ll go back to school, or hang around to watch the tournament?”
“Dunno,” said Harry. “Hang around, I suppose. … Madame Maxime’s staying to judge, isn’t she?”

Seems a tiny bit excessive for three events plus a dance spread out over a school year.

When all the Beauxbatons students had submitted their names, Madame Maxime led them back out of the hall and out onto the grounds again.

“Where are they sleeping, then?” said Ron, moving toward the front doors and staring after them.

Ask Cedric, he's booked to stand staring over their sleeping forms Wednesday night.

As they neared Hagrid’s cabin on the edge of the Forbidden Forest, the mystery of the Beauxbatons’ sleeping quarters was solved. The gigantic powder-blue carriage in which they had arrived had been parked two hundred yards from Hagrid’s front door, and the students were climbing back inside it. The elephantine flying horses that had pulled the carriage were now grazing in a makeshift paddock alongside it.

Harry knocked on Hagrid’s door, and Fang’s booming barks answered instantly

“ ’Bout time!” said Hagrid, when he’d flung open the door. “Thought you lot’d forgotten where I live!”

To be fair, the hut moves around a fair bit in the movies.

Hagrid was wearing his best (and very horrible) hairy brown suit, plus a checked yellow-and-orange tie. This wasn’t the worst of it, though; he had evidently tried to tame his hair, using large quantities of what appeared to be axle grease. It was now slicked down into two bunches — perhaps he had tried a ponytail like Bill’s, but found he had too much hair. The look didn’t really suit Hagrid at all. For a moment, Hermione goggled at him, then, obviously deciding not to comment, she said, “Erm — where are the skrewts?”

So, even if you aren't very familiar with this story, I imagine you can guess what Hagrid will be doing in his subplot. Also, is Hagrid a virgin for the safety of womankind? The public needs to know.

“Out by the pumpkin patch,” said Hagrid happily. “They’re gettin’ massive, mus’ be nearly three foot long now. On’y trouble is, they’ve started killin’ each other.”

“Oh no, really?” said Hermione, shooting a repressive look at Ron, who, staring at Hagrid’s odd hairstyle, had just opened his mouth to say something about it.

“Yeah,” said Hagrid sadly. “ ’S’ okay, though, I’ve got ’em in separate boxes now. Still got abou’ twenty.”

It probably isn't a surprise that the Skrewts are an enemy in the video-game, which makes sense, because they seem to have the ecology of a video-game enemy.

Hagrid’s cabin comprised a single room, in one corner of which was a gigantic bed covered in a patchwork quilt. A similarly enormous wooden table and chairs stood in front of the fire beneath the quantity of cured hams and dead birds hanging from the ceiling.

Where does this man shit?

They ended up having lunch with Hagrid, though they didn’t eat much — Hagrid had made what he said was a beef casserole, but after Hermione unearthed a large talon in hers, she, Harry, and Ron rather lost their appetites.

I'm reminded of when the Nazis tried reverse breeding aurochs back from cattle, a bit like a low tech version of when that company produced some mutant wolf cubs that morphologically resembled dire wolves a bit.

A light rain had started to fall by midafternoon; it was very cozy sitting by the fire, listening to the gentle patter of the drops on the window, watching Hagrid darning his socks and arguing with Hermione about house-elves — for he flatly refused to join S.P.E.W. when she showed him her badges.

“It’d be doin’ ’em an unkindness, Hermione,” he said gravely, threading a massive bone needle with thick yellow yarn. “It’s in their nature ter look after humans, that’s what they like, see? Yeh’d be makin’ ’em unhappy ter take away their work, an’ insultin’ ’em if yeh tried ter pay ’em.”

I wonder if any house-elves have attached themselves to Muggle households. It's worth noting that most stories of brownies (aka, house-elves) depict them doing their chores at night when nobody's around, because it wouldn't be folklore if there were actual hideous little men running around in broad daylight fixing shoes. I think one of the disadvantages of how Rowling segregates the magical and Muggle worlds is that you lose the element of normal people encountering the supernatural, which is... kind of the backbone of folklore? Like, c'mon, Muggles can't even become ghosts?

“But Harry set Dobby free, and he was over the moon about it!” said Hermione. “And we heard he’s asking for wages now!”

“Yeah, well, yeh get weirdos in every breed. I’m not sayin’ there isn’t the odd elf who’d take freedom, but yeh’ll never persuade most of ’em ter do it — no, nothin’ doin’, Hermione.”

Hermione looked very cross indeed and stuffed her box of badges back into her cloak pocket.

Wait, is Hagrid recognising broad demographic trends while still acknowledging individuality within those groups? I was told my choices were blank slativisim or thinking women shouldn't be taught maths and that literally all Muslims are pedophile jihadists!

By half past five it was growing dark, and Ron, Harry, and Hermione decided it was time to get back up to the castle for the Halloween feast — and, more important, the announcement of the school champions.

“I’ll come with yeh,” said Hagrid, putting away his darning. “Jus’ give us a sec.”

Hagrid got up, went across to the chest of drawers beside his bed, and began searching for something inside it. They didn’t pay too much attention until a truly horrible smell reached their nostrils. Coughing, Ron said, “Hagrid, what’s that?”

He just answered my earlier question.

“Eh?” said Hagrid, turning around with a large bottle in his hand. “Don’ yeh like it?”

“Is that aftershave?” said Hermione in a slightly choked voice.

“Er — eau de cologne,” Hagrid muttered. He was blushing. “Maybe it’s a bit much,” he said gruffly. “I’ll go take it off, hang on …

He stumped out of the cabin, and they saw him washing himself vigorously in the water barrel outside the window.

“Eau de cologne?” said Hermione in amazement. “Hagrid?”

What do giants grind to make their perfume? Gay guys?

Hagrid had just straightened up and turned ’round. If he had been blushing before, it was nothing to what he was doing now. Getting to their feet very cautiously, so that Hagrid wouldn’t spot them, Harry, Ron, and Hermione peered through the window and saw that Madame Maxime and the Beauxbatons students had just emerged from their carriage, clearly about to set off for the feast too. They couldn’t hear what Hagrid was saying, but he was talking to Madame Maxime with a rapt, misty-eyed expression Harry had only ever seen him wear once before — when he had been looking at the baby dragon, Norbert.

Hagrid is a babyscalie confirmed.

“He fancies her!” said Ron incredulously. “Well, if they end up having children, they’ll be setting a world record — bet any baby of theirs would weigh about a ton.”

1772198150193.png



To make a long story still quite long, the champions are selected.

“Bravo, Viktor!” boomed Karkaroff, so loudly that everyone could hear him, even over all the applause. “Knew you had it in you!

My man Poliakoff was robbed.

“The champion for Beauxbatons,” said Dumbledore, “is Fleur Delacour!”

“It’s her, Ron!” Harry shouted as the girl who so resembled a veela got gracefully to her feet, shook back her sheet of silvery blonde hair, and swept up between the Ravenclaw and Hufflepuff tables.

“Oh look, they’re all disappointed,” Hermione said over the noise, nodding toward the remainder of the Beauxbatons party. “Disappointed” was a bit of an understatement, Harry thought. Two of the girls who had not been selected had dissolved into tears and were sobbing with their heads on their arms.

I assume the boys who weren't selected are just smoking themselves to death.

Excellent!” Dumbledore called happily as at last the tumult died down. “Well, we now have our three champions. I am sure I can count upon all of you, including the remaining students from Beauxbatons and Durmstrang, to give your champions every ounce of support you can muster. By cheering your champion on, you will contribute in a very real —”

But Dumbledore suddenly stopped speaking, and it was apparent to everybody what had distracted him.

The fire in the goblet had just turned red again. Sparks were flying out of it. A long flame shot suddenly into the air, and borne upon it was another piece of parchment.

Automatically, it seemed, Dumbledore reached out a long hand and seized the parchment. He held it out and stared at the name written upon it. There was a long pause, during which Dumbledore stared at the slip in his hands, and everyone in the room stared at Dumbledore. And then Dumbledore cleared his throat and read out —

Harry Potter.

Shock twist!
 
Fred and/or George: Man, Peter leaves school, and Ron immediately starts looking for a new bed warmer.
If it is between getting pegged by Hermonie and pegged by Krum, I wouldn't blame Ron for going with Krum. Krum probably rolls over and grunts afterwards, I bet Hermonie yaps all night.
 
Unlike some of my other comments about Rowling's worldbuilding, this is less me criticising her for a lapse so much as me acknowledging the other kinds of story you could tell with these ingredients.
I often feel that one of the reasons the Harry Potter fanfic scene took off so hard was because other people wanted to tell those stories, and the HP universe gave them space to.

I like that Hermione is the one with the most French hatred.
I'm also assuming that this is basic mate-guarding, and being threatened by those foreign hussies.

I like that the omniscient magic cup needs you to write what school you go to--in case it thinks you're the Fred Weasley from Saint Cyprian's or Brakebills.
Yeah, this was definitely a "We need it this way for the plot to get set up" situation; I as a reader still have no idea why the Triwizard Tournament is done this specific way with this specific Firey Goblet, other than Tradition.

I assume our finest race-baiters are taking a break from being mean to a guy with a neurological disorder...
Sir, this is a KiwiFarms. We never take breaks.

Also, is Hagrid a virgin for the safety of womankind? The public needs to know.
Hagrid, as we see, clearly has specific preferences in his romantic partners, much to the sadness of overly-ambitious monsterfuckers everywhere.

I could also see young Hagrid possibly running into a rusalka, siren, or other sexy-trap monster, but the problem with that is I feel like even young Hagrid would be too canny to magical creatures to be tricked, and would instead gently relocate them and start feeding them ethically-sourced died-of-natural-causes Muggle meat.

Wait, is Hagrid recognising broad demographic trends while still acknowledging individuality within those groups?
Well, he is portrayed as consistently thick and dull-witted...

Although, jokes aside, this is another neat little progression on selling Hermione as learning throughout the books. In the last book, she learned that adults can and will turn their eyes from an injustice and that if she doesn't take action, it may well be that no one does. So, here she is, and here she does.

The problem is that thick or no, Hagrid is legitimately an expert on magical creatures, and what he says here is borne out by the rest of the books. It does show growth that Hermione is disregarding a teacher in their area of expertise, but also that she is still a child and has not yet learned to slow her roll, get out of her head, and confirm her assumptions before rushing off half-cocked (which, in fairness, many adults never learn either).
 
Which despite being in the title does not actually factor into things much at all. It kind of reminds me of how some lit fic books will be called, like, The Perfumist of Treblinka, and then he only turns up in one chapter. I can't blame Rowling for going with that, though. Harry Potter and the Triwizard Tournament somehow reads like the name of a fanfic an eleven-year-old wrote because they were impatient.

In fairness, while the Goblet appears only briefly, that appearance is absolutely pivotal to the plot. Rowling also said she liked how it had a "cup of destiny" feel to it, for whatever that's worth.

That being said, the earliest promotional material (which I actually saw once or twice at the local Waldenbooks) advertised Book 4 as "Harry Potter and the Doomspell Tournament," which still sounds kind of fanfictiony but which is still a hundred times more badass. Not sure when the title changed, or if it would have ever been referred to as "Doomspell Tournament" in the text itself.

So, even if you aren't very familiar with this story, I imagine you can guess what Hagrid will be doing in his subplot. Also, is Hagrid a virgin for the safety of womankind? The public needs to know.

I am now picturing a Diagon Alley bordello where for a few extra Galleons one of the ladies will swill an Engorgement Potion for you.

Where does this man shit?

Clearly Hagrid keeps to the old ways of Hogwarts waste management, which specifics I shall not repeat here for the sake of dignity. But the ability to Vanish his own waste does imply a higher level of magical skill than we've been led to believe he possesses.
 
Clearly Hagrid keeps to the old ways of Hogwarts waste management, which specifics I shall not repeat here for the sake of dignity. But the ability to Vanish his own waste does imply a higher level of magical skill than we've been led to believe he possesses.
Hagrid was able to do a botched transfiguration on Dudley without saying anything, he was also able to let the boat row on it's own in the first book.

I'd say Hagrid is a somewhat average wizard, maybe above average, considering he is working with a subpar wand
 
Hagrid was able to do a botched transfiguration on Dudley without saying anything, he was also able to let the boat row on it's own in the first book.

I'd say Hagrid is a somewhat average wizard, maybe above average, considering he is working with a subpar wand
Worse than subpar, broken. Plus he probably hadn't had any teaching after that, plus it's not like he could ever openly practice the craft...that said, his giants blood probably lets him shrug off a number of the backfires he should be experiencing.

I'm surprised it doesn't come up more often but thinking about it, Ron's first wand was Charlie's first (and then also broken) and Neville was using his father's wand too which probably led to some sub-par performance before replacement.

There could be other wizards that aren't main characters that are stuck with hand me downs and suffer in their spellcasting because of it...
 
Back
Top Bottom