YouTube Historians/HistoryTube/PopHistory

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Sleazy Car Salesman said:
Shad? The guy who spends half his time bitching about SJWs? That Shad?
Click to expand...
I don't know. All the videos I've seen are him sperging over weapons and building fake castles. He must complain about SJWs on some side channel where he expresses personal opinions.
 
Prester John said:
I don't know. All the videos I've seen are him sperging over weapons and building fake castles. He must complain about SJWs on some side channel where he expresses personal opinions.
Click to expand...
Yep same one. He's a friend of a group called EFAP which is made up of anti-SJW media review culture vultures centered around Mauler and Rags, Shad spent a bunch of time bitching about DisneyWars, particularly The Last Jedi. I used to be subscribed to Shad but stopped watching him when his videos just became endless bitching about youtube "killing his channel" and not actually funny or interesting stuff.
 
NewFagWhore said:
I've been watching Historia Civilis for years, almost a decade now - and I've always had this unshakable feeling that he is Canadian, but I only know of his youtube and can't verify it.
I just found this thread, so does anyone know if my "canadar" is right?
Click to expand...
Are you retarded my man?

untitled.PNG
 
NewFagWhore said:
Is that an optional thing on Youtube or did Google start doxxing indians like X. (I havent opened an "about" page for a channel in years)
Click to expand...
afaik it's a thing on every channel and the channel creator updates it.
 
LordOfZhbagva said:
IIRC, he quoted a Canadian "literally who"communist in his work video.
Click to expand...
Yeah that work video is embarrassing, aside from politsperging its just completely wrong. Imagine making a video comparing leisure/work time ratio and not defining what either is.
Sleazy Car Salesman said:
afaik it's a thing on every channel and the channel creator updates it.
Click to expand...
Aight, good to know. as far as I remember, the "about" page was only for channel description and the business enquiry email.
 
NewFagWhore said:
Yeah that work video is embarrassing, aside from politsperging its just completely wrong. Imagine making a video comparing leisure/work time ratio and not defining what either is.
Click to expand...
I'd argue that some things don't need to be defined. But then again, he'd need to deliver a lot of primary sources, experimental archeology and a lot of citations for me to consider such a take seriously. He might be onto something, but he's not approaching it in a correct way.
 
LordOfZhbagva said:
I'd argue that some things don't need to be defined. But then again, he'd need to deliver a lot of primary sources, experimental archeology and a lot of citations for me to consider such a take seriously. He might be onto something, but he's not approaching it in a correct way.
Click to expand...
my point was that, as far as i remember, in the video he talks about medieval "work" only in the context of working in the field - not the hours and hours of menial shit you had to do like repairing your house, collecting water, taking care of livestock etc. All the things you don't have to do today because you can get a professional to do it for you, (which you can afford cause you "work" more hours).
This is fine if he stated at the start that work = doing things you get paid for, but then that would disqualify fieldwork as well because serfs didnt get paid for it. thus highlighting the importance of defining what you mean by "work".

But yes, the video is amateurish in more ways than one and is overly ambitious with its goals with little credible sources backing it up.
 
NewFagWhore said:
my point was that, as far as i remember, in the video he talks about medieval "work" only in the context of working in the field - not the hours and hours of menial shit you had to do like repairing your house, collecting water, taking care of livestock etc.
All the things you don't have to do today because you can get a professional to do it for you, (which you can afford cause you "work" more hours).
But yes, the video is amateurish in more ways than one and is overly ambitious with its goals with little credible sources backing it up.
Click to expand...
HistoriaCivilis has always been shit.
 

1771261748950.png

Kraut accuses a liberal of being a communist for citing "material reasons" (they used ethnic cleansing a century ago) as evidence for why other groups were not magically better at resolving ethnic disputes. Any reference to the material world is a reference to materialism I guess.

NewFagWhore said:
I've been watching Historia Civilis for years, almost a decade now - and I've always had this unshakable feeling that he is Canadian, but I only know of his youtube and can't verify it.
I just found this thread, so does anyone know if my "canadar" is right?
Click to expand...

He briefly changed his name to Historia Antifas and started fighting culture war on Twitter.
 
NewFagWhore said:
xe is a biased troony leftist but that can be ignored easily.
Click to expand...
In other words, he's shit. You posted the reason you tolerate the shit he peddles, not an argument for why it isn't shit. His Rome videos are just Unbiased History for redditors, but done completely earnestly.
 
1000006889.jpg
I wonder how are they going to spin this one to make it about Drumpf. /sneed
Lol
They never mention that Hitler was illegal immigrant. And if he was deported after Beer hall Putch. NSDAP would remain just footnote in history.

Slap47 said:
Kraut accuses a liberal of being a communist for citing "material reasons" (they used ethnic cleansing a century ago) as evidence for why other groups were not magically better at resolving ethnic disputes. Any reference to the material world is a reference to materialism I guess.
Click to expand...
Wtf is Trout sperging about?
Cyprus is easy counter argument. To his take.
Also Hungary has pretty good relations with most of its neighbors despite fact that ethnic Hungarians live on their territory.
1000006930.jpg
Hungarian and Slovak PM.
There is one exception Ukraine.
And why you ask?
Well Ukraine is forcibly conscripting ethnic Hungarians. Cracking down on their rights... And there are many other reasons why Hungary is hostile to Ukraine.
So no Hungarian government is not revanchist. They don't want to change borders, but they are interested in protection of Hungarians living outside Hungary.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom