- Joined
- Feb 10, 2013
Proclaiming your desire to punch nazis is such a meaningless, meaningless phrase.
I just realized why it strikes a familiar bell in my mind: it reminds me of people at parties who will start ice-breaking conversations by saying "who here thinks they have the best method to survive a zombie apocalypse" or "hey guys, can I confess... I really love bacon."
It's saying something that is totally uninteresting, carries no unsafe weight or risk of new thought because it's predicated on a fantasy that you've never once thought would actually happen to you... but you feel secure knowing that everyone around you who is following the appropriate social contract - everyone who's a good person - will play along with you, respect you for bringing it up and show that respect by only agreeing with you. That you will receive empty praise for broaching a "controversial" subject even though you all understand it's being said specifically because it doesn't matter and the speaker expects no resistance. You can talk tough game about punching nazis, but you won't talk the same about punching republicans because you actually realize that republicans commonly exist around you and if you say that in public too loud then unlike nazis, one will actually appear and challenge your assertion.
It's... is it even virtue signaling? Or is it just signaling? It's like little kids who make you say the secret passphrase before they let you into their no-girlz-allowd fortress. What good for society are they accomplishing behind the walls of that fortress? NOTHING BECAUSE IT'S JUST LITTLE KIDS PLAYING MAKE-BELIEVE WHILE THE GROWN-UPS ARE OUT WORKING JOBS AND FIGHTING REAL FIGHTS.
I just realized why it strikes a familiar bell in my mind: it reminds me of people at parties who will start ice-breaking conversations by saying "who here thinks they have the best method to survive a zombie apocalypse" or "hey guys, can I confess... I really love bacon."
It's saying something that is totally uninteresting, carries no unsafe weight or risk of new thought because it's predicated on a fantasy that you've never once thought would actually happen to you... but you feel secure knowing that everyone around you who is following the appropriate social contract - everyone who's a good person - will play along with you, respect you for bringing it up and show that respect by only agreeing with you. That you will receive empty praise for broaching a "controversial" subject even though you all understand it's being said specifically because it doesn't matter and the speaker expects no resistance. You can talk tough game about punching nazis, but you won't talk the same about punching republicans because you actually realize that republicans commonly exist around you and if you say that in public too loud then unlike nazis, one will actually appear and challenge your assertion.
It's... is it even virtue signaling? Or is it just signaling? It's like little kids who make you say the secret passphrase before they let you into their no-girlz-allowd fortress. What good for society are they accomplishing behind the walls of that fortress? NOTHING BECAUSE IT'S JUST LITTLE KIDS PLAYING MAKE-BELIEVE WHILE THE GROWN-UPS ARE OUT WORKING JOBS AND FIGHTING REAL FIGHTS.
