But I do take your point. A lot of games change developers entirely, and the results feel like "we're really big fans" goobers totally failing to understand why the originals were good. The perfect example is Silent Hill.
I also tend to think of the Ys series as a more subtle example. Particularly once you get to Ys VIII: Lacrimosa of Dana, there's a feeling of "this is good, but it doesn't feel like Ys anymore."
............
So another thing that's been on my mind today....
... And this is a thing that seems to especially affect Japanese stuff, but... like, a lot of media gives me a feeling of "excess," to the point of completely losing their brains.
This has kind of been a thing for awhile to be honest--I even remember Jim Sterling doing a video about Tetsuya Nomura's version of Batman and what an ugly fuck that was, but metaphorically I feel a lot of things have a similar issue. Why does this show have a girl who is both a maid
and a catgirl? Because they're trying to up the ante. Or maybe a story will have a girl with a scythe that turns into nunchaku that turn into pistols....
It affects gaming as well. It always bothers me in like RPGs that classes like knights that are supposed to be purely physical, now have these abilities that are magic in all but name. I understand that in some types of games its a necessary evil, but why do we need it in, say, Dungeons & Dragons? Whatever happened to the days when the value of the Knight was that he was the front line fighter who did the most physical damage and maybe tanked so your wizard in back could prepare a fireball? Heck, whatever happened to the days when "put at Stinking Cloud spell at a choke point" was a valid strategy?
I also see this trend towards "excess" a lot in character archetypes. To use some autistic examples, when you go back to 1987 Michelangelo of the Ninja Turtles was the "Party Dude," and he was presented as laid-back and sometimes a pizza fiend but... he also behaved like a normal fucking person. Compare this to, say, Pinkie Pie from My Little Pony, who.... if you knew someone who acted like her in real life, you would be sick of her within weeks. To be fair, at least she sorta fits within the universe the show created, but I've seen characters like her that tend to feel like a Looney Tunes character escaped into a more serious show.
I think I'm just rambling... I just woke up... but again, hoping it makes sense to someone.