Should Your Next Laptop Be an AI PC? - Despite all the buzz, there's no need to rush out and purchase neural processing. Not yet, anyway.

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Article / Archive

Should Your Next Laptop Be an AI PC?
Despite all the buzz, there's no need to rush out and purchase neural processing. Not yet, anyway.
Nicholas De Leon / Jan 24, 2025

The tech world loves to dream big, especially when it comes to innovations that promise to reshape how we live and work. From cutting-edge OLED TVs to high-performance PC graphics cards, there’s always something new to capture our attention—and hard-earned dollars.

But for every breakthrough that transforms daily life, there are dozens of products that, while impressive, leave you asking yourself, Do I really need this?

Right now, I’m wondering whether the AI PC falls into that bucket, at least for the everyday consumer.

What Are AI PCs?
Touted as the future of computing, these laptops and desktops seek to inject the power of artificial intelligence directly into a computer chip, offering—on paper, at least—smarter, faster, and more efficient performance for labor-intensive AI workloads.

What makes them especially well-suited for these workloads is a neural processing unit (NPU) designed to handle artificial intelligence tasks more efficiently than a traditional CPU (central processing unit) or GPU (graphics processing unit).

Just as you’d want a dedicated GPU to play the latest video games, so the thinking goes, you’ll want an NPU to run AI-enhanced software.

And, as it turns out, we don’t have to guess about the performance of these AI PCs, because we tested a handful of them when they were released in the latter half of 2024.

The Lenovo Yoga Slim 7i Aura Edition, for example, earned high marks in almost every metric we reviewed. The Dell XPS also received impressive scores, but our testers said the touchpad was a little small.

The thing is, plenty of laptops without an NPU score just as well in our labs, and often even better, including popular models like the LG Gram, Samsung Galaxy Book4 Ultra, and MSI Prestige.

More to the point, today’s most popular AI tools—ChatGPT, Google Gemini, and Microsoft Copilot—work just fine without an NPU.

They rely on cloud processing, performing the heavy lifting of AI tasks on remote servers. When you ask ChatGPT a question, it’s OpenAI’s computers, not yours, that do the work.

Are NPUs Pointless?
No, there are instances where they might help. But right now the pickings are mighty slim, especially for the average PC user.

The latest version of Microsoft Paint has an AI PC feature called “generative fill” that allows you to add a new element to a photo by simply typing a description into a box. You can, for example, request a “friendly-looking orange cat” and presto, you’ve got yourself a feline.

Neat, but not something you’re going to miss once the shine wears off. Adobe Photoshop has a similar feature (with the same name, no less) and it’s accessible on a run-of-the-mill laptop.

XSplit’s VCam uses AI to remove backgrounds from video calls. Once again, most laptops already handle this task just fine. But NPUs promise greater accuracy and speed, not to mention a reduction in that weird shimmering effect you see on virtual backgrounds.

Because all of this sounds a little thin to me—cool, but nothing vital to a consumer laptop—I asked the chip makers AMD and Intel for thoughts on what I’m missing. After all, it’s their NPUs that power these next-generation PCs. What exactly should consumers be on the lookout for?

“AI PCs won’t be defined by any one application,” AMD responded. What the company is looking at is more of a fundamental change in “how consumers interact with their PCs.”

Intel didn’t respond to our request for comment.

To start, natural speech will play a much bigger role in the user experience. With Samsung phones and laptops, for example, you’ll soon be able to request the photo you shot last summer of the kids and the dog racing around on the beach, and your device will be able to interpret your request, find that very image, and pull it from your library.

If you ask the device how to bump up the text on your screen so it’s easier to read, you’ll be sent straight to the appropriate setting. No more combing through menus in search of the right terminology. Accessibility features? Vision?

And when you ask the device for restaurant recommendations, you’ll be presented with the opportunity to update your calendar with the reservation date and time, and text a summarized review of the establishment to your guests.

In short, your devices will get better at anticipating what you’re trying to do, particularly when it comes to productivity tools, content creation, and security, according to AMD, with categories like gaming benefiting in the near future.

The popular media playback app VLC will soon add live subtitling, too. (That one did catch my attention.) Say you’re watching a movie in French but need English subtitles. At the moment, you have to download the subtitles from a website and then load them into the app.

It’s cumbersome, to be sure. But if your computer has an NPU—even a GPU, as it turns out—this new feature can feasibly create English subtitles in real time right there on your computer, VLC told us. The demo looks impressive. I look forward to trying the real thing out once it’s released. (No word yet on when that will happen.)

Still, the promise of AI PCs hinges on the idea that local AI processing will become increasingly critical as software evolves. And that may one day be true, particularly when sensitive personal habits and data are factored into the process. It’s possible that companies like Adobe, Microsoft, and Nvidia will create compelling new features that require the use of NPUs, too. But if you ask me, you should never buy a tech product based on what it might do in the future.

For now, the benefits are too niche and too incremental. Unless you’re a pro who works with high-end AI applications, stick with a plain ol’ laptop for a while longer.
 
Thanks, Microsoft.

Screenshot_2025-01-26_16-02-16.png
 
I built my frist PC over 20 years ago and my latest last year. It's looking more and more like my next one may be my last in 5-10 years. Even switching to linux hasn't solved most porblems because the internet has become openly hostile to privacy and it's making things a slog. AI slop and corporatization is running wild. Glad I'm pirating everything I want because technology is leaving me behind.
 
If it isn't inside a 60lbs Full tower case with fans running at max speed, doesn't have a CD/DVD burner and an FDD then it's not a real computer. It's just a niggerbox.
 
If it isn't inside a 60lbs Full tower case with fans running at max speed, doesn't have a CD/DVD burner and an FDD then it's not a real computer. It's just a niggerbox.
What would you even use a DVD burner for nowadays? Just copy your files onto an SSD. That'll last longer than a CD/DVD anyway.
 
I built my frist PC over 20 years ago and my latest last year. It's looking more and more like my next one may be my last in 5-10 years. Even switching to linux hasn't solved most porblems because the internet has become openly hostile to privacy and it's making things a slog. AI slop and corporatization is running wild. Glad I'm pirating everything I want because technology is leaving me behind.
Any of the quad-cores from the last 10 years or so are fine for many tasks. The weakest iGPUs are fine for games from 15+ years ago and some newer light stuff. You can get such a PC for $100. The market may be flooded soon with 4th/6th/7th gen Intel corporate PCs that can't run Windows 11 "officially" (Win10 support ends in October).

If you just happen to end up with one of these NPUs (thanks, Microsoft!) in a dGPU-less system, it could be OK for running Stable Diffusion or something.

What would you even use a DVD burner for nowadays? Just copy your files onto an SSD. That'll last longer than a CD/DVD anyway.
HDDs/SSDs are more convenient, but I think discs will beat SSDs on data retention if they are kept in a drawer for years. SSDs are getting worse as we move to QLC NAND (4 bits per cell), and even PLC in the next couple of years.
 
Any of the quad-cores from the last 10 years or so are fine for many tasks. The weakest iGPUs are fine for games from 15+ years ago and some newer light stuff. You can get such a PC for $100. The market may be flooded soon with 4th/6th/7th gen Intel corporate PCs that can't run Windows 11 "officially" (Win10 support ends in October).

If you just happen to end up with one of these NPUs (thanks, Microsoft!) in a dGPU-less system, it could be OK for running Stable Diffusion or something.


HDDs/SSDs are more convenient, but I think discs will beat SSDs on data retention if they are kept in a drawer for years. SSDs are getting worse as we move to QLC NAND (4 bits per cell), and even PLC in the next couple of years.
That really depends on the CD/DVD. My dad burned a lot of music compilations for himself and his friends back in the 2000's and a bunch of them are already rotting away or coming apart even though they were stored in a relatively clean environment. That doesn't seem to happen nearly as much to retail CDs/DVDs though.
 
What would you even use a DVD burner for nowadays? Just copy your files onto an SSD. That'll last longer than a CD/DVD anyway.
You can ship them via mail and they cost less than 50¢ a piece. Also, pre-bluetooth cars often support MP3 CD (you can fit hundreds of MP3 onto a CD).
Any of the quad-cores from the last 10 years or so are fine for many tasks.
I have an ancient Core2Quad workstation i use as a HTPC. It's upgraded to windows 10, SSD, GT1030 and maxed out with 4x1GB DDR2. For normal tasks it runs flawlessly (web browsing, streaming, pre-2015 games).

It really shows how Windows 11 limitations are arbitrary bullshit. A late windows XP era rig can handle W10 fine but a early Windows 10 era workstation can't run the new OS without rufus trickery (that isn't guaranteed to work long term).
 
Last edited:
Nah.

AIPCs are retarded. For most of the things you’d use it for, a GPU works just as well.

For those really into AI, who’d actually use it more than once a week, cloud based AI is way faster and more powerful than the NPUs they squeeze into laptops.

It’s just a scam to make people upgrade sooner.
 
It's finally happening in my lifetime.

I used to like new fancy cars with technology built in but as I get older I'm really craving to buy a late 80's samurai, something with less tech in it. I miss my old 99 Acura. Shit goes wrong so often with new PCMs and I think I might die on the spot if I ever have to say "Can't get to work, my car dashboard froze up."

It's happening with phones and computers now for me. I fucking hate AI assistance, ads in my start bar, everything being SAAS....

Maybe I'll go old school and build my next PC like I used to. Spray painting the inside of my case, CCFL lights and chintzy LED fans.
 
Nah.

AIPCs are retarded. For most of the things you’d use it for, a GPU works just as well.

For those really into AI, who’d actually use it more than once a week, cloud based AI is way faster and more powerful than the NPUs they squeeze into laptops.

It’s just a scam to make people upgrade sooner.
Cloud AI is usually censored or can be tracked, doing stuff locally could get around that. Of course, you can also rent big GPUs in the cloud and run whatever you want on those, and probably get away with it because you're treated like a business customer with privacy instead of niggercattle.

The ~10 TOPS NPUs are weaker than the integrated graphics the APUs came with. 40-50 TOPS NPUs may actually match the iGPU or be a bit faster. It's enough for basic LLMs, Stable Diffusion, image editor filters, etc., and is allegedly more power efficient than the iGPU. So it can extend battery life. This is not a compelling case for almost anybody, and definitely not a reason to run and out buy one. But you'll probably end up with this silicon eventually if Intel, AMD, Qualcomm, et al. put them into every laptop and desktop chip. It's a matrix math accelerator with benefits. The severely autistic will decry the die space being wasted since it could have been used to add a couple more iGPU cores or something, but Micro$oft has spoken. I think they might go to 100 TOPS in the next generation (e.g. Intel Panther Lake, AMD Zen 6 APUs).
 
Back
Top Bottom