What are the long term effects of hitting a child?

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account

emptyblu

kiwifarms.net
Joined
Apr 15, 2021
We all know children who were sexually abused grow up to be mentally ill individuals but what are the consequences of a child who has been abused but without any sexual intentions from the adult? Are the results same? And I’m not talking about spanking or a light slap to the face, I mean violent abuse to the point where the child develops purple bruises on their skin and has to walk around with them and acknowledge them on a daily basis.

How does this shape their adulthood?
 
To answer the question in the title:
Depends on if someone see you hit that child.

But I would guess children that are getting hit, grow up to be violent. Those are the ones that kill their parents the most, aside from those who are just mentally deranged.
 
We all know children who were sexually abused grow up to be mentally ill individuals but what are the consequences of a child who has been abused but without any sexual intentions from the adult? Are the results same? And I’m not talking about spanking or a light slap to the face, I mean violent abuse to the point where the child develops purple bruises on their skin and has to walk around with them and acknowledge them on a daily basis.

How does this shape their adulthood?
They tend to either swing from completely violence free and scared of physical contact to a completely unhinged vagrant even more violent then their own parents. I was the first. I tended to avoid conflict as much as possible unless someone jumped me. Then you have other kids who subconsciously perceive violence as a form of care or love, because their small child brain can’t accept that their parents either don‘t love them or don’t care for them enough to stop their behavior, leading them to subconsciously associate violence with good feelings, which is really sad.

Edit: This is JUST from what I have noticed. I don’t have any indepth study.
 
Beating vs. Punishing are two distinct terms. What I got as a child would be considered "Beating" by today's standards yet back then it was common punishment. You learn really damn quick that if you do certain things you will get punished by a physical object on your ass or hands and that shit stings so don't do it.

That to me is a better lesson than "Don't do that as it's naughty and glad we had the talk so go play OK?"

The great analogy is "The stove is hot, don't touch the stove." They Touch The Stove. "You got burnt by touching the stove? Hurts doesn't it? Gonna do it again? No? Good. Now grab an icepack and goto your room and think about the thing you just did when I told you not to."

Cause and Effect and a lifetime of Do Not Touch a Hot Fucking Stove.
 
Spanking or hitting?

spanking, the long term effects are they learn discipline and act properly therefore never needing to be spanked again. (results demonstrated with most traditional Western White (and some Oriental) families at least up until recent years)

Hitting as in actual beating abuse, absolutely negative impact (results demonstrated with most non white , specifically negroid families (I hesitate to use the word families).
 
I suppose I fall into this category. Abused as a child, with no "profound" physical injuries and no reports to authorities. Parents were never suspected of such actions and were respected members of the community. I never talked about it.

The effects were pretty serious. I was an extremely awkward aloof child. Always uncomfortable in my own skin. "Smart" but terrible at school. Self-sabotaging, never "tried" at anything as failure was always presumed. Clumsy in social situations. Always felt like my head was full of static -- could never concentrate nor relax. Some behavioral issues and subsequent suspensions due to "acting out" and doing stupid shit -- I have never been violent with anyone.

As an adult I'm mostly functional and am kind and calm with my own children (who are incredibly healthy and successful by every standard metric) so I'd like to think I escaped the cycle in that one respect. But I also suffer from bouts of severe anxiety and depression and have been known to have some seriously "bad days." But I feel "lucky" compared to others with similar upbringings, who fell into drugs and crime and violence. Don't hit your kids, people.
 
Beating vs. Punishing are two distinct terms. What I got as a child would be considered "Beating" by today's standards yet back then it was common punishment. You learn really damn quick that if you do certain things you will get punished by a physical object on your ass or hands and that shit stings so don't do it.

That to me is a better lesson than "Don't do that as it's naughty and glad we had the talk so go play OK?"

The great analogy is "The stove is hot, don't touch the stove." They Touch The Stove. "You got burnt by touching the stove? Hurts doesn't it? Gonna do it again? No? Good. Now grab an icepack and goto your room and think about the thing you just did when I told you not to."

Cause and Effect and a lifetime of Do Not Touch a Hot Fucking Stove.
It's worth keeping in mind that the person who popularized ending physical discipline of children was dr. spock, was also responsible for getting people to put their baby on their belly for sleeping resulting in thousands of extra deaths across europe.
 
That to me is a better lesson than "Don't do that as it's naughty and glad we had the talk so go play OK?"
And yet you ended on this website. Maybe corporal punishment as discipline wasn't as good as you thought? Besides, lacklustre talking and explanation are just as bad as physical abuse.
 
Believe verbal abuse is even worse than physical abuse. A child eventually forgets most spankings. A child is likely to remember physical abuse. But believe a child always remembers the verbal abuse, every last bit. You have the child's authority figure/role model calling them abusive names, telling them they are no good, they'll never find anyone to marry, etc. The child will tend to take that seriously. It takes a tough, strong kid to be able to compartment the abuse and rise above it. Many do not. They live down to the abuse. When they are 30 and still living in the basement, should the parents complain, the child can always say, "You told me I would never amount to anything, so here I am." Or when reaching the age of majority, the child simply departs, never to be heard from again. From time to time, the child exacts payback when they laugh at/ignore an aged parent's request for help. Or the child doesn't bother attending the parent's funeral, or if they do show the child makes it plain they don't give a fuck.

Verbal abuse can plant very poisonous seeds in a child. As a parent themselves, unless the child works hard to break the cycle they are likely to verbally abuse their children.
 
Really depends on the mindset of the child. If they have had mental issues before the beatings, like depression that was passed on from your parents, I can see you having some self-esteem and trust issues. Lacking a bond with your parent can really damage you. This is more like extreme beatings, though. However, every kid is different. Some kids end up killing their families, some end up dying themselves, others are able to move on, and some let it follow them for the rest of their life.
I would look at websites with people who have expertise on this, though.
 
I say it depends on whether the parent is a a violent moron who's just taking out their frustrations on the kid or if it's educational after the kid did something stupid that crossed a certain line.

Examples from personal experience:
-When I took a handful of dirt and threw it at the freshly cleaned windows of my grandpas living room, he came out and brought a literal ass-beating with him.
-When we were badly behind schedule to catch a plane and my sibling started throwing a tantrum and tossing around his coloring pencils, my dad delivered a single, well placed slap to the face to put an immediate end to that nonsense.

It didn't happen often, maybe once or twice a year, and when it did I'd say it was either deserved or necessary. Not only that, we always got a talk afterwards, explaining why we got smacked. Even having been a recipient of this I wouldn't call it abuse. My parents were always in control of themselves when they did this. Most people probably wouldn't be.

I think it's important that the kid knows they did something really stupid or bad. If they don't feel they did anything to warrant this punishment, or if it's too severe it may cause some mental issues later on, especially if it happens often. I also believe a generally good upbringing is a mandatory basis for this to work. If it's already a spoiled asshole kid you can't just beat the bad out of him.
 
Back
Top Bottom