I don't understand the praise for Andor. I tried watching the first episode and nearly fell asleep. I heard it was a "slow burn" show but it was just shit to me. Is it because the main character is Space Che Guevara? I know these Redditors have a fetish for the Gormans. I think it is hilarious that these leftards always dispute the existence of conspiracy theories in reality but can grasp the government pulling off a false flag operation in a television show.
I could go on and on about this show. It's a "gritty take" on star wars which for me kind of sits between something i like and something I find extremely gay. I definitely hadn't the childish vibe of the disney trilogy and wanted something more old school EU like but andor kind of goes way too far with it and gets masturbatory.
You're also correct that the show is boring as fuck and while i do think the slow burn works sometimes the show is not nearly as good as it
thinks it is. It's stuck up its own ass to a tarintino degree.
The real world parallells are obnoxiously on the nose. Lucas took things from history and smashed them together. Take geonosians for example:
Geonosians are
bugs who fight in a
roman collosseum and speak a
subsaharan african style language with clicks, with a
collectivist culture and are aligned with a
confederacy, that wants to seperate from a
republic. Everything in lucas' star wars is all over the place like this and it's better for it.
Meanwhile in andor, there's a planet that is
france. The architecture is french, they have french accents, they have a lot of sexy french girls, they're occupied by the empire (germany) who plays kind of nice with them, they're known for artsy fashion, they have a resistance that hides underground and communicates through radios using code language. It's exactly fucking france in world war 2. That's how andor handles every parallel, there's also an entire 3 episode arc about an ice operative raping an illegal brown woman on a farm.
All of that is kind of irrelevant though because the simple fact is that they clearly want to paint the picture that authoritarianism is bad at a time when really we need more of it. It's very clear that for the writers the empire = america, palpatine = trump, mon monthma = every wine aunt who think she's saving the world, and andor is an illegal immigrant.
Though despite the writer's obvious
intent the show fails even at being political propaganda. Every reddit thread and film critic has said this show is a warning against
fascism when really it's about
authoritarianism. The empire in this show is no more fascist than it is communist, that is to say we don't know anything about how they handle property rights, there's no evidence of them glorifying the past (in fact they hate the old republic and the jedi), they don't solve things through a "strong must rule" system but rather a "always obey the system" system which it has in common with communism. Palpatine doesn't plaster his face everywhere which is extremely disappointed for somebody like him.
The entire message of Andor boils down to: people in power are bad and you have to fight them. This message is 100%
aimed at for leftists who hate trump, but it's just as applicable to right wingers who hate the EU, right wingers in Canada, atheists in Iran, chinese who hate the CCP, anybody living in north korea, etc.
Basically it's the most reddit show ever made.