Reddit’s CEO says r/popular ‘sucks,’ and it’s going away - Reddit is also limiting how many popular communities one person can moderate and pushing more personalized feeds. (multi sub mods btfo)

  • 🏰 The Fediverse is up. If you know, you know.
  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Reddit is “moving away” from r/popular, the default feed for new users, and plans to replace it with “better, more relevant and personalized feeds,” according to CEO Steve Huffman (aka Spez). Huffman also notes that r/popular “sucks.”
“For a long while, we were known as the ‘front page of the internet,’ but we’ve outgrown a singular front page for everyone,” Huffman says. “You have different interests than I do, and your Reddit should look different from mine. And from your neighbor’s, or your coworker’s, or your best friend’s.”
Regarding r/popular, he says that “in theory, it’s what’s most popular on Reddit, but it’s actually what is liked by the most active users on Reddit—which is not the same thing. Having it as a default feed gives the false impression of a singular Reddit culture, one that is neither representative of Reddit nor appealing to new users (or anyone at all, IMO).” So, in the “near future,” Reddit is going to “stop showing it to new users, and unless you read it regularly, we’ll remove it from the core group of feeds in the app.”

The changes to r/popular will start showing up to some users as early as this week, spokesperson Tim Rathschmidt tells The Verge. Reddit originally made r/popular the default for logged-out users in 2017.
Huffman didn’t go into detail on what the improved feeds might look like, and Rathschmidt says that the company is “still in early-stage testing and don’t have more to share at the moment.” However, Huffman did reply to a post asking for the return of News feed filters by saying that he’s “fully aligned here” and that “when I talk about more personalized and relevant feeds, this sort of functionality is what I’m referring to.”

Reddit is also in the process of changing its policies for moderators to prevent users from overseeing a large number of high-traffic communities, seemingly to reduce the number of so-called “powermods.” As announced in September, beginning March 31st, 2026, users will only be able to moderate up to five communities that have over 100K weekly visitors. The company says that the change will impact “less than 0.1% of active mods.”
“Distinct communities require distinct leaders,” Huffman says. “A situation where someone moderates an unlimited number of massive communities is not that, which is why we’re making a few changes.”
 
What is liked by the most active users on Reddit ...
... is neither representative of Reddit nor appealing to new users (or anyone at all, IMO)
Indirect and understated, but I'd like to think they've identified the problem: their groupthink userbase is so batshit that it drives away anyone normal, and so it must be hidden away from new users.

changing its policies for moderators to prevent users from overseeing a large number of high-traffic communities, seemingly to reduce the number of so-called “powermods.”
users will only be able to moderate up to five communities that have over 100K weekly visitors
This is the best step they could take to undo the TrannyJanny hivemind, but after years of letting them cull anything remotely normal, it might be too late. Like when dying media brands occasionally try to tack back to center, only to realize they're trapped by the hyper-Prog remains of their customer base.
 
Last edited:
Karma system has been gamed for 15 years. Nothing organically reaches the front page anymore. Just the nature of the beast.
 
as cancerous as updoots are making reddit into infinite personalized feed #31 seems even more retarded. I don't think the website can be repaired, but maybe fixing the problem of rabbid jannies having a stranglehold over a community just because they got the best url for the topic would be a better first step
 
Trying to hide something.
Yes, how terminally retarded their userbase/the various disinfo NGOs willing to bot votes to the front of /r/popular are.
By giving every user a custom feed, they can serve related ads to the user with more accurate viewership statistics to promote to advertisers instead of going off of various subreddit vote counts. Reddit's already the lowest-valued social media site in terms of per-user, per-view price, and every time reddit tries to renegotiate what they can charge to serve ads on their platform the advertising firms bring up how blatantly botted vote counts are on /r/popular in particular and how they can't take their traffic estimates remotely seriously.

Ditching any semblance of a universal feed for the site would also heavily disincentivize whoever organizes these bot campaigns, and the likelihood of every. single. submission. in a subreddit that can even tangentially be construed as being anti-Trump instantly being botted to the top of the sub's all-time feed will diminish somewhat.
 
So they're saying ragebait, karma farming, and propaganda aren't the main topics on reddit? Oh, it's porn. How could I forget that porn is the real purpose of reddit.
 
I want to see the meltdown that happens if reddit nukes everyone's karma back to 0 with the new system to see what rises to be popular with the new system. Don't you kind of need to do that? I mean it's just internet points and doesn't the problem of everything is astroturfed slop remain if you allow people who have spend decades running bots to place internet points in a circlejerk to just continue doing that?
 
Yes, how terminally retarded their userbase/the various disinfo NGOs willing to bot votes to the front of /r/popular are.
Reddit's already the lowest-valued social media site in terms of per-user, per-view price
These two aren't related. The latter has always been true, because of little doxxxxing, no incentivity to not run multiple throwaway accounts, and no RL social links. KiwiFarms's per-user, per-view price is likely negative.

I've always assumed peddit made money by running libshit propaganda. It may be that that money stream has thinned, or is diverted to consensus-manufacturing outfits that post on peddit and bypasses peddit itself.
 
The only people who hate Reddit are browns and NPCs jumping on the bandwagon driven by said browns. It should say something when the current CEO of Reddit is a white man compared to all other tech companies.
 
Whilst I'd like to think that this will be done to stop the default page being 50% "Orange man bad" posts in favour of more "cat playing a piano" posts, I suspect they will end up replacing the "cat playing a piano" posts to make it 100% "Orange man bad".
I may be wrong, of course, but I think expecting reddit to get better is as optimistic as panning for gold in your own toilet.
 
Problem with reddit destruction is that redditors will remain and make rest of the Internet even worse.
These changes are step in right direction, but it is equivalent of using adhesive bandage on severed leg
 
Back
Top Bottom