First off great list, super thorough I love it. I do have a few thoughts:
You say we have zero evidence of "being a whore before meeting their spouse" well, I disagree on the whore part although its hard to place timeline. My take is though, she was a hot popular chick and Nick was clearly a dork with money. I have seen this situation before. Also, are you forgetting her talking about getting molested and her tits felt up by a massage therapist like its a joke, Nick clearly getting off on how hot his wife is and everyone wants her. Also, she would act like a skank on videos. Maybe I'm crazy but looking at her I think she spent time on her knees but not in church in high school.
As for "The first to cheat (you're gonna take
April's word for that? - kay)" My theory was posited BEFORE April spoke. It was based on an assumption from a fact pattern, had nothing to do with a balldo fucking cokehead cumbucket, but she did corroborate the story and its important it came from her, a girl Nick was trying to fuck as I think (as I said) this was his "line" his sympathy card he used on e-thots that need viewers.
Two things about this:
1) Her cheating does NOT in any way make Nick the good guy in this. Quite the opposite. He is the bitter, resentful, wrathful fuck who destroyed his family out of spite. Nick was resentful of being stuck with a family and aging wife while at the height of his success, forced to masquerade as a trad when he just wanted to do drugs and fuck e-thots. Then BOOM Kayla cheats and he now has a free pass to indulge EVERY evil. He also is pissed at his family over pushing god, Kayla over getting old and monogamy. A real man would have just left her, fought for his kids and spent his money on hot chicks. Not Nick, he turned his wife into an abomination.
2) The fact pattern - it's not just skank slut coke whore April. Long before I just felt the below showed it:
- Why would Kayla go along with all of this? Why NOW after all these years. It's not just money, something changed. They're both dead inside.
- Your own admission of her "taking accountability" Yes, Nick is a gaslighting cocksucker and if she did cop to cheating he would make sure she felt every single thing that has gone wrong since is HER FAULT (not true obviously, Nick is unable to take ANY accountability)
- Her family begging her to stop being a punching bag, this would explain why she keeps taking it, he has snowed her into feeling she deserves all the humiliation.
- Timeline of "worst day" kicking this off coupled with it possibly being written by a chick he was hitting on and would have been using this as his pick up line.
- Other e-thots supposedly caught on the phone with him for hours sweeping for him, likely also snowed by him. Explains Anna and Nina and Melonie sweeping, poor Nick driven to drugs by his cheating wife. This is the narrative keep in mind. Nick is scum.
- Hey just occurred to me, remember when Nina supposedly had someone being inappropriate to her in the private chat who was a streamer and everyone assumed it was fatass AZ, well if it was Nick the timeline works and it explains why she didn't out him out of pity. She swept his balls like a fucking hoover with her bigass nose.
- No actor on earth, not Cape Fear level Deniro could conjur the bitterness Nick has at the prior married life from god to his kids that he has. Nick has this evil indignation of someone who feels he was suckered and now he continues to sucker himself worse.
- All of April's behavior shows she is suckered by a guy claiming he was cheating on who "deserves" so much more.
- Nick has shown utter contempt and let April just batter Kayla recently. He is still "with" her because he is doing the trad thing out of spite. He is punishing Kayla by being with her, making her life a living hell.
In the end don't get me wrong, I am not absolving Nick but looking for an explanation for his complete and utter destruction. The pure evil that is coursing through his veins as he destroys his family. It just make sense and the complete destruction of Kayla on a daily basis and now Aaron seems to be his goal. But like a fucking retard he is just destroying the mom of his kids and getting run around in circles by Aaron, a fucking baby huey bubba lovesponge rip off schmuck.
I think you stumbled upon something when you combine all this together.
Kayla didn't cheat on Nick with a neighbor or whatever.
She lied about her sexual history from the beginning, and came clean on that
dies horribilis.
And it was a lot more extensive than he had ever imagined.
Edit:
It was like this when he found out.
https://youtube.com/watch?v=cxWRWbdsTjc
It could have been a really nasty past, maybe she got gang banged. I do think after the masseuse fondling story she could totally have hooked up with a dude on a "fun" drunken girls night out. I also remember them going to some crazy wedding they all got drunk at, she could have ended up blowing a guy in a bathroom. She seems fairly loose and Nick seemed fine with it, one thing leads to another...bored housewife and now bitter breadwinner.
Either way I think all his behavior can be explained as the tantrum of an egotistical bitter man baby who wished he had never settled down before his "success" and in stead of just walking out he will vindictively punish her forever. He seems like a petty fuck who lives for vengeance and like with the aaron hacking thing he will go to no length for revenge...so what he is doing to Kayla is not that dissimilar to the illegal stuff with aaron.