Law Louisiana becomes the first to legalize surgical castration for child rapists - Redditors mad

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
BATON ROUGE, La. (WAFB) - As of Thursday, August 1, for the first time in the country’s history, child rapists can now be ordered by a judge to have their testicles removed if the victim is under the age of 13 and if the offender is older than 17 years old. The law already allowed judges to issue an order of chemical castration.

“At the end of the day I hope that kids know that they can feel safer because there will be some real tough penalty actions that will occur when somebody violates their innocence,” said the bill’s author Sen. Regina Barrow (D-Baton Rouge).

The law also includes the crime of pornography involving juveniles as an underlying offense and it’s also not just limited to male offenders.

“Unfortunately, females are molesting children as well and that’s a very sad thing to see and to hear. As a matter of fact, one of the cases I was reading not too long ago, I read a case where that was actually happening with guards with children at a particular facility,” Sen. Barrow explained.

However, there are some circumstances where the convicted offender might not qualify for the procedure, but that would be up to the judge and a doctor at the State Department of Corrections.

Attorney Jill Craft says she understands what the law is intended to do but says she anticipates it to be challenged in the courts, arguing it falls under cruel and unusual punishment.

“The problem with something like this is multifaceted. It kinda harkens back to if you steal from me, I’m gonna cut off your hand. Okay, well how come we don’t do that in the United States, well because it’s cruel and unusual punishment,” said Craft.

Craft explains how in most incidents of forcible rape, the act is done not so much out of some sick sexual desire, but something much more sinister.

“It’s not the notion of having sex with somebody for some sort of pleasure. It is the notion of domination and control. I understand what they were trying to accomplish, it’s just this is not the way,” Craft continued.

Sen. Barrow says she ultimately hopes at the very least this new law will work as a deterrent for potential child rapists. And according to Craft, aside from Louisiana, the only other places on the globe that allow surgical castration are Madagascar, the Czech Republic, and one state in Nigeria.

https://www.wafb.com/2024/08/01/la-becomes-first-legalize-surgical-castration-child-rapists/ (Archive)

Mad redditors: https://old.reddit.com/r/news/comments/1ei8xry/la_becomes_the_first_to_legalize_surgical/
 
As John Adams so defended the British troops as a matter of personal principle, so shall those few upstanding posters of the Kiwi Farms fight tooth and nail to spare the imaginary condemned from cruel and unusual punishment through their posts of consequence.
I think due process is a good thing and that gathering credible evidence that proves the person is responsible for the crime is better than just believing he said she said nonsense to get the sentence you want. Everyone has a right to a fair trial for a good reason and you'll want it to stay like that when you are the one charged.
 
No I absolutely do not support this and I hope this indeed gets struck down for Cruel and Unusual Punishment.

Problem 1. Child Molesters will if given the chance abuse children again regardless of their ability to have sex. We have to fucking dispel this myth that pedos have a Humbert Humbert flowery love for children. They do not. They get off on hurting kids. And this move sounds like it's part of a plan to let Chomos out earlier with the expectation that without a sex drive they just won't have an interest. But all we have to do is look at the Stinkditch's and see THAT'S FUCKING WRONG. Remember Jonathan Yaniv? How about all the troons on discord who are obsessed with trans kids. PEDOPHILIA IS CHILD ABUSE. Child Abuse is not just molestation and rape.

Problem 2. However fucking rare it is there's still always a chance that a child has been "coached" by a guardian to claim they were molested. And that rareness alone warrants convicts be given however miniscule amount of respect that we don't inflict direct bodily harm. Either lock em up or give them the death sentence.

This is just a horrible idea.
 
As John Adams so defended the British troops as a matter of personal principle, so shall those few upstanding posters of the Kiwi Farms fight tooth and nail to spare the imaginary condemned from cruel and unusual punishment through their posts of consequence.
There was a very high profile case in Norway where the conviction was recently overturned. The man was convicted of raping and murdering two little girls together with his friend. The conviction was based only on the testimony of said friend, who testified that the man was actually the lead perpetrator and had actually forced the friend at knifepoint to rape and kill one of the girls. The friend received a lighter punishment as a result, and an innocent man spent more than 20 years in prison. It's not imaginary, and it's not a super contrived and impossible scenario like you seem to be suggesting.
 
There was a very high profile case in Norway where the conviction was recently overturned. The man was convicted of raping and murdering two little girls together with his friend. The conviction was based only on the testimony of said friend, who testified that the man was actually the lead perpetrator and had actually forced the friend at knifepoint to rape and kill one of the girls. The friend received a lighter punishment as a result, and an innocent man spent more than 20 years in prison. It's not imaginary, and it's not a super contrived and impossible scenario like you seem to be suggesting.
It's very funny seeing the cognitive dissonance on display here. "You can't trust the government on anything, they lie constantly, the justice system is two-tiered and corrupt, prosecution, defense, and judge all work together to fuck innocent people, and they're constantly pushing the envelope to fuck you over, but here's why giving them ultimate authority and dispensation will totally work out in my favor."
Get this, the people in power are all pedophiles or pedo adjacent. They are not going to enact laws that will potentially harm themselves. If they do, they're going to do so in such a way that they can weaponize it against their enemies, i.e. normal non pedos.
 
I know you are just trying to be cute, but obviously pedophiles are defective biological humans. The only way to completely eliminate evil is to eliminate humanity, because it's otherwise always going to be something our kind will struggle with. Even if you started with a new seed population with only good people, eventually mutations and recessive traits towards psychopathy would reemerge.
Don't put words in my mouth. I said what I meant and I meant what I said.

They are not people. End of story. Not much else to debate on that matter.
 
Personally I disagree with any permanent punishment, the justice system is not infallible.
Yup. Rare case where I'm like "this isn't right". I'd rather 100 guilty child rapists remain intact than one innocent person who slipped through the cracks (which we all fucking know happens all the time) sustain a permanent, life altering mutilation.
 
I would sooner see a million pedophiles go free than one innocent be punished for crimes he did not commit
Okay retard. And it will be your fault when millions of kids get raped just because an accident happened. I'd rather feed those pedos to live alligators ina contained area while having a team of trained snipers make sure there are no escapees. Also, of anyone manages to live through that, we put that nigger on a bungee cord noose and throw him/her off the highest building. It sucks one innocent man died, but at least a bunch of kids didn't get violated by sick men and we had a laugh about it too.

But let's be realistic: unleas you are actually diddling kids or looking at CP, it is basically impossible to get convicted for pedophilia. It's technically possible but forensics, basic bitch psychoanalysis and just general MO observations make it extremely remote. People that get convicted for being a pedo are pedophiles.
 
Okay retard. And it will be your fault when millions of kids get raped just because an accident happened. I'd rather feed those pedos to live alligators ina contained area while having a team of trained snipers make sure there are no escapees. Also, of anyone manages to live through that, we put that nigger on a bungee cord noose and throw him/her off the highest building. It sucks one innocent man died, but at least a bunch of kids didn't get violated by sick men and we had a laugh about it too.

But let's be realistic: unleas you are actually diddling kids or looking at CP, it is basically impossible to get convicted for pedophilia. It's technically possible but forensics, basic bitch psychoanalysis and just general MO observations make it extremely remote. People that get convicted for being a pedo are pedophiles.
I'm sure you'd be crowing the same tune if you were on the receiving end of a false allegation. You see the same thing in the PoundMeToo movement, with the creepy male feminists declaring "BELIEVE ALL WOMEN!" but then when allegations come out against them, "This never happened, I'm innocent!" You cannot have it both ways.
 
I don't live in Louisiana so I don't give a shit what they do with their garbage.

Why do so many people who don't live in an area give a fuck what the laws of that place are? I don't give a shit if they throw convicted pedophiles into woodchippers in Mexico, why would I care if they castrate them in a state as functionally remote as Mexico?

If people have a problem with this they should advocate their preference in law, for their state.
 
Honestly better off just executing. If you execute an innocent man he’s not gonna be in the news constantly bitching about how you cut his balls off for no reasons.
 
Back
Top Bottom