Business Costco is winning the war against retail theft, boasts it's 'not a big issue' as Target and Walmart shutter stores across the country — here's why

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Article Archive
Costco is winning the war against retail theft, boasts it's 'not a big issue' as Target and Walmart shutter stores across the country — here's why

Major U.S. retailers collectively lost a whopping $112 billion because of crime last year, according to a recent report from the National Retail Federation (NRF).

But Costco (NYSE:cOST) isn’t losing as much as its peers. “Thankfully, it's not a big issue for us,” chief financial officer Richard Galanti reportedly told investors last month during the company’s earnings call.

Here’s how one of the largest retailers in the country is circumventing one of the industry’s biggest threats to its collective bottom line

Retail theft crisis

A spike in reports of shoplifting have been seen across the country in recent months. Retail corporations have said that merchandise losses, or “shrink,” related to theft, including organized retail crime as well as employee theft, have ticked up recently.

The issue has pushed some retailers to shutter stores. Target (NYSE:TRGT) recently said it would shutter nine locations across the U.S. because of rising theft and crime. CVS (NYSE:cVS) said it would close 10% of its stores and migrate to online retail partly due to rising cases of shoplifting.

Walmart reportedly shuttered half of the chain’s Chicago locations in April and Walmart CEO Doug McMillon has previously said that if the problem persists more of its stores will close and prices will go up.

Altogether, theft accounts for 70% of the merchandise shrinkage experienced by major retailers, according to the NRF’s research.

Costco’s robust defenses

Costco has managed to keep a lid on the worsening nationwide theft issue.

According to the CFO, shrinkage was between “0.1% and 0.2%,” during the most recent quarter. That’s significantly lower than the nationwide average of 1.44%, as reported by the NRF.

Among the reasons Galanti cited for Costco’s relatively low shrinkage is the layout of its stores. Because Costco’s stores are structured like warehouses, with only a single point of entry or exit, they’re less vulnerable to thieves.

But Costco’s membership-based business model is one of its strongest defenses, according to Galanti. “You have to show your picture ID when you come into our warehouse,” he said, “so the fact that it's member-only is a positive.”

Costco items are also relatively more difficult to steal. The chain sells bulk items that are inconvenient for shoplifters. It might be hard to carry out 96 rolls of toilet paper out without someone noticing, for example. Costco goes a step further by packing even small items in large boxes.

However, the chain isn’t immune to theft. Costco executives admitted that shoplifting ticked up after they rolled out self-service checkouts three years ago. But the problem hasn’t worsened enough to stop the company from continuing to offer the feature.

This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.
 
There is a good reason why 13% of 50% of crimes meme is shooting up. It is a demographic that is molly-coddled to hell to the point they are the new de facto religion. And unironically, this masochistic 'sacrifice' libshits are doing for that 13% unironically is priming people to hate them even more than usual.

https://youtube.com/watch?v=PVQIB6tRaS0
Also, vid related in terms of Cosco doing well.


Ave. True to Caesar.

I unironically yearn for the day the Legion takes California. This place deserves that kind of government.

Soros DA: "Vote for me, and I'll make it legal for niggers to steal!"
White women: OMG SO SOCIALLY JUST
Niggers: ooga booga free stuff
White women: WHY IS TARGET CLOSED?!?!?!?!
 
What I fear more than anything is an alliance between Costco and Aldi. They could take over the country.
 
The reason is it requires a membership to get in the door, which niggers don't pay. You know, maybe there's a business idea here. Smaller businesses could all join a consortium where you have to pay $15/month to belong, and you can't get in the door if you don't pay. Make themselves virtually nigger-proof.

Yep, it really doesn't take much to weed them out. There were nice public beaches where I grew up. Most had free parking, and a couple charged eight bucks. That $8 was enough to keep all the hood rats and other riffraff to the free parking beaches.
 
I love Costco because it's one of the few places in our society where being a nigger is discouraged
 
Costco is a criminal enterprise.

It should be illegal to stock good stuff for months then randomly never stock it again like they do.
I also hate how they rearrange the store at random. IT IS AN ADVENTURE, LOL. Fuck off, I just want to buy my shit and get out.
 
This is like apples to oranges. I would love to see how Costco compared with Sam's Club and BJ's.
Personal anecdote. Ive shopped at Costco & Sam's Club before. The products are bulky and heavy. The checkouts are set up far from the entrance and since its a warehouse its a LONGGGG distance to walk out of there. Its hard to grab a 3 gallon tub of detergent and haul it across a warehouse to make your getaway. Target and Costco appeal to different demographics and locations too and play into this. Membership, the type of products they sell and location help them keep shrinkage low.
The other thing is Costco checks your receipts and they claim this isn't a shoplifting deterrent but it certainly is because it creates a powerful mental feeling that you're being watched as you are making your escape. And that impacts people who shoplift especially if they do it multiple times at the same store.
I disagree, theres the greeter at Walmart or some Targets who sometimes check. Even with security guards thieves don't care.
 
I disagree, theres the greeter at Walmart or some Targets who sometimes check. Even with security guards thieves don't care.
I genuinely think it's different since with Costco there's also usually a line up to get out and they read over your receipt. And it's a universal thing like you always know it's going to happen. It's not like at Walmart where the security guard is just going to stand around.

Additionally another big difference is Costco checks if you even have a membership card to get in. So you are identified and screened a total of 3 times. (At the door, at the till and at the exit). A would be thief who is just there to shoplift, not shop and shoplift is unlikely to want to deal with 3 separate checks especially if they don't have a membership since it's much more likely they'd be visually identified and tracked throughout the store. If they shop and shoplift it's utterly pointless because if they get caught the store has their name and payment information already on file because of their membership.

In just about every way wanting to steal from a Costco is significantly more risky and requires more effort on the part of the thief to do.

Another really big factor though as people have pointed out previously in the thread is actually location. Since Costcos are typically not located in the downtown areas they're usually in a location you need to drive to. Which is something that also prices out most would be thieves. It's something they didn't do to avoid shoplifting but it has that effect on people.
 
Hopefully more businesses don't take a lesson from this and try their own memberships and ID people. Because I could see quite a few wanting to try it out if they thought it'd eliminate theft.
 
Hopefully more businesses don't take a lesson from this and try their own memberships and ID people. Because I could see quite a few wanting to try it out if they thought it'd eliminate theft.
It all comes down to conscientious enforcement of whatever anti-theft measures they take. Without people taking it seriously, it doesn't work.
 
A lot of theft at big stores isn't people just walking in taking something and walking out. It's people walking in and buying some stuff and just shoplifting stuff while they're there. Additionally the things they shoplift aren't things you go to Costco for. Things like makeup, deodorant, baby powder etc. This is why Costco hasn't faced as much shrink as other stores. You wouldn't go to a Costco to shoplift especially since everything is in bulk so you'd need to make multiple trips to do it. You also need a Costco membership and pay monthly to even go there so that prices out a huge amount of people who would shoplift to begin with. They even usually check your membership card before you enter.

The other thing is Costco checks your receipts and they claim this isn't a shoplifting deterrent but it certainly is because it creates a powerful mental feeling that you're being watched as you are making your escape. And that impacts people who shoplift especially if they do it multiple times at the same store.

Shrink does still happen at Costco though it's why they sneakily make certain things behind glass or a display case like jewelry and high price electronics like hard drives or computers. It's rich seeing Costco say retail theft isn't a big deal considering they already designed their business decades ago to minimize shoplifting as much as possible.
TBH, most retail theft is done, one way or another, by employees.
 
Speaking of Costco and typical locations - there's one right on a train station in donwtown Vancouver and I'd love to be able to see its stats on shrinkage and whatever else. One of the less industrial locations and smaller stores, not sure how they handle the massive traffic either.
 
A lot of these thefts are actually an inside job. When you hire shitty employees and pay shitty wages and don't have cashiers, this is what you get.

1. Retailers say organized theft is biting into profits, but internal issues may really be to blame
2. Costco pays more, has fewer employees.
3. Profit.
Costco also has no warehouse and just moves everything from the trucks to the floor on pallets. No one is outside of public view with anything small enough to steal. You want to try to "accidentally" throw away a 50 pound sack of flour for your friend waiting behind the dumpster, be my guest. That combined with the fact that most Costcos are staffed by people who have worked there for 20 years and are capable of long-term thinking about the value of their paycheck vs. the risk of stealing something means they probably have the best internal theft metrics of any chain too.
 
It should be illegal to stock good stuff for months then randomly never stock it again like they do.
Aldi should also be charged with this crime. Not for their middle aisle stuff (a lot of which repeats itself year-in year-out), but for grocery products.
 
Back
Top Bottom