Popular literature has skewed ever more simplistic, juvenile, and therefore boring and unremarkable. The Young Adult genre is now completely misnamed, since
the majority of people who enjoy it are over the age of 18. Western culture has become ever more infantilized and the YA genre, with its simplistic, feel-good stories and morals, appeals to the manchildren and womanchildren that are now so common in western countries. Many are too heavily influenced by Harry Potter, too, due to its huge popularity, and therefore feel very derivative and stale.
I can't speak for everyone, but I find myself drifting toward such genres for the simple fact that a mass majority of the slop you find within media has become... Well, demoralizing. That isn't to say I don't dip my toes into the more complex stuff, but when you have to trudge through a sea of sludge to find something golden, I often find myself reverting to the older classics of my youth, even if they are anything but in the canon of literature.
These days, I find myself reading a lot more web original content and the like. Stuff that again, would not necessarily be deemed a classic, but is often competent in its own fashion, and is relative easier to find that dead tree originals. I have searched in vain for anything to help ease my search for decent literature that might be up my alley, as it has been far too long since I last stumbled upon anything worthy of note. But alas, literature I find does not have the best means to find the good stuff, new or old easily. All I have are the words and snippets of random previews, but that hardly tells the whole story, does it?
The best I have been able to come up with is trawling through my dad's old audiobook collection, but not everything there is to my taste.
(As a side-note, I believe it is no coincidence that asian media is becoming bigger in the west in recent years, such as japanese games, anime, manga, vtubers, kpop, etc. The western mass media industrial complex is falling apart and people are trying to find alternatives.)
When your bar is merely not insulting your audience and just telling at least something half decent without become repetitive as all hell, (At least, more so than Western media these days.) it becomes an almost comically easy explanation as to why Asian media dominates its western counterpart.
This isn't to say all of Western media is in the dumps. From what I have heard on the grapevine, French and Dutch comics are doing quite fantastically, but have yet to make a foothold in the US as far as I am aware of. It's definitely a more diverse medium as far as comic books are concerned, broaching a variety of subjects and genres. Need to try and invest looking into that more.
But even at its simplest, media such as those from Japan satisfy a simple want/need in the psyche of many a young adult. Namely, escapism. Isekai is a famous(infamous) example of this, having become the go to generic slop of the modern era, regurgitating a formula that has since become bland, but nevertheless still manages to accrue its fair share of eyeballs and profit, if for no other reason that the shit state of the people who consume it, having little future prospects to go for.
When deprived of any other alternatives to advance your future, escapism often becomes the only resort for such folks, for better or ill. I can't say it is a productive one, but it's a very understandable one seeing as for these individuals, there's little hope of remedying or addressing the systemic issues that prevent them from going up in life.
Still, I find it a shame that Isekai in question has been reduced to such a state. It reminds me of a Miyazaki quote, mistakenly attributed to him, but nonetheless rings true in that anime in its current form is a "mistake". Not to say the media itself is terrible, but it has since been reduced from what it could and *should* have been.
It isn't a surprise that Isekai and other genres have been reduced to such a state in the name of profit, but it's such a damned missed opportunity. I for one wish to see more than the bog standard of the audience surrogate of some rando overpowered young'un that is thrown into yet another game world. Again, there's so much more you can do with the simple but potent idea of transplanting a person(s), or even entire communities therein and seeing how they adapt and overcome the new challenges brought by said transplantation, jiving with the locals, and using their own unique strengths to make the most of what happened to them.
Or hell, even the reverse of that in the classic sense, seeing a typical magical like community opening up a new path to new worlds and the like.
Or if you want to do the simplest thing possible, how about throwing an old man mentoring his young grandson or nephew who may or may not be destined to be some chosen one, and making him a pivotal leader of some form given a new chance at life?
But alas, that is not to be. Why bother with anything more complex when the simple sludge will suffice? Oh well.
I did mention it in the thread, and was pointed to an internet archive of all of SFDebris videos from 2010-2015. Mr Repzeon apparently still makes videos, but with a fraction of the viewers
Gotcha. I'll try to find it within this thread then. Post more if you can. Love to see em.