SJW Art and Extremes

[Kiki The Witch]

I think the Supergirl redesign looks more interesting and badass than the original, the problem is that the artist turned her into a fat angry feminist (at least this is what she looks like to me).

 

[Rayemond46]

That Supergirl redesign would of been good if it weren't for that random decapitated Superman in her hand... I'm not even a Superman fan and it still makes me roll my eyes. It just screams "Edgy feminist who kills all men." or something.

 

[[Insert Meme Here]]

Fat supergirl whose redesign seems out of character (since she wouldn't kill like that).

Not only is this out of character, it's a complete misunderstanding of the character.

• She doesn't need armor because her skin is super tough. Bullets bounce off her. Punches from gods don't hurt her. And in the event there is something that CAN hurt her, armor wouldn't help anyway. Not everyone gets Wonder Woman's bracelet's type of armor. All it would do is weigh her down and make it MORE difficult for her to move when flying and fighting. Also, if she catches someone midair, her wearing armor would hurt them at Mach 10. Not remotely practical for her fighting style.
• The S-shield isn't a literal fucking shield, idiot. It's a symbol.
• Her hair, like Superman's is uncutable and naturally flouncy. The whole reason Supes has the "S" thing in his hair is that it does that naturally and when he flies it comes undone. It's how her hair is 24/7. She's not human, why does her hair have to work like yours? It's also not bleached. She's a natural blonde. Have you not heard of blonde people before?
• Can't read the part about the boots, but they're fine.
• The fabric of her suit isn't normal material. It's special Kryptonian cloth, as her mother's side of the family were expert cloth makers. It's literally part of her backstory (at least currently) that this stuff is super special and durable. Hence why her and Clark's family sent it with them as babies.
• Minimalistic costume design is good! It's iconic and more memorable. Cluttered designs are harder to remember and less iconic, not to mention harder for the artist to draw over and over again.
• Her Injustice 2 costume was good, no complaints there. But y'all just stealing.
• STOP TRYING TO TURN EVERY FEMALE SUPERHERO INTO WONDER WOMAN. THERE'S MORE THAN ONE WAY TO BE A GOOD FEMALE SUPERHERO. Y'ALL STEALING SHIT FROM THE MOVIE.

Stuff like this is always made by people who haven't read the fucking comics... or a Wikipedia page.

 

[Hummingbird]

The thing with some professional comic creative teams is when they redo a character, they make them blander...

Spoiler: First example

Honestly, even if you're trying to base her figure off the lady wrestler, Nia Jax, the redone Salvo (GI Joe) is still ill-fitting. At least Nia has a look that catches your eye and doesn't seem like the kind of person who spends her time sitting on the couch, eating chips.

Spoiler: The original

Spoiler: Now for another

Now take the original Deathblow who was hardcore military man who was part of a genetic experiment that gave him powers and a tumor and he wants to make right before he dies. Here's how he was before...

While changing him into a black guy now that DC got the rights to the Wild Storm universe isn't bad, but they just nuetered him in looks and character. Given how the SJW climate growing in the comic industry hates machismo, big muscles on men and anything with flair, that's probably the reason he became that way. Diversity and Comics explains it more...

 

[Windelsiya]

Oh man. As you can guess from my profile-picture, I'm a fan of Supergirl. The design was nice and very fitting. Even the weight thing doesn't look that bad, in her redesign. But the idea of it, and the personality/reasoning for it ruined the redesign.
Many people forget that Supergirl, more or less, has identical powers to Superman. That armor wouldn't be necessary, as much as it looks good.
The laser "flaw" could be applied to all DC characters. In fact, most of the "issues" this artist has for Supergirl can be applied to the other heroes. Starfire, for example, has strength close, if not equal, to Kryptonians. Tamaraneans have less protection and clothes, but this is balanced by Tamaraneans getting energy and advantages by solar power. Both Tamaranean genders go by this, like Kryptonians. Yet, like Supergirl, Starfire is redesigned as if only the females of the two alien races are affected.
What's wrong with the hair? With Supergirl's strength, shield, and speed, that wouldn't be something that could get her killed. She's not powerless, or a weakling. She has fought against and with Superman many times, in lots of comics.
You see, the issue with these types of DC Comic redesigns is that the issues are made for every character. These artists probably did not have the confidence, freedom, or type of body to wear what they wanted, as teenagers, and made OCs that have flaws that would also make them not be able to dress more freely. Most female characters wearing what they want then makes said artists envious of the freedom they see others have, and switch the envy with a solution for everything to be like themselves.

 

[Ruin]

The thing I never get about people who whine about Supergirl having "impractical" clothing is that the primary function of clothing is to protect your body right? Isn't she a borderline invincible God who could walk around naked and be fine?

 

[One Man Bland]

It's also not bleached. She's a natural blonde. Have you not heard of blonde people before?

The best part is that, even if her hair were bleached, dyed hair would have no bearing on her crime fighting ability. If it was some crazy Tumblrina Danger Hair color like cyan or neon pink that might make it easier to link Supergirl's identity to her civilian one, but that still wouldn't be effecting her combat skills.

This is literally just a cosmetic change made solely because the artist apparently hates blondes, which is the most hilariously petty shit I've ever seen come out of a redesign.

 

[Bani]

The best part is that, even if her hair were bleached, dyed hair would have no bearing on her crime fighting ability. If it was some crazy Tumblrina Danger Hair color like cyan or neon pink that might make it easier to link Supergirl's identity to her civilian one, but that still wouldn't be effecting her combat skills.

This is literally just a cosmetic change made solely because the artist apparently hates blondes, which is the most hilariously petty shit I've ever seen come out of a redesign.

The Tumblrina who drew this would get along well with Andrew Dobson.

 

[Guardian G.I.]

Tumblr has a Tolkien fanbase, among other ones. Their favourite pastime, besides writing lesbian fanfics about Silmarillion, is racebending various characters.

Spoiler: This one is not too bad, but the facial proportions are a bit squished

Spoiler: LOOK AT THAT FACE GODDAMMIT (c)

Judging by the enormous noses, the artist who drew the Jew face meme recently decided to branch into fantasy illustrations.

 

[friedshrimp]

Ironic when you consider that Tolkien's works are also popular in the Neo-Nazi crowd.

 

[IdaRita]

ITT people getting incredibly buttmad and spergy over harmless little cartoons. lol calm the hell down.

Getting back on topic:

Spoiler: Actual characters

Tumblr declared Lena (older one) is a lesbian, based on her hairstyle alone, before she was shown in Ducktales, true story.

This blog makes me so uncomfortable.
https://genderwalker.tumblr.com/

Spoiler: big and weird

It's coincidence, because I logged today only to post this picture:

EVEN DROIDS AREN'T SAVE!

 

[Lackadaisy]

Tumblr declared Lena (older one) is a lesbian, based on her hairstyle alone, before she was shown in Ducktales, true story.

It's coincidence, because I logged today only to post this picture:

EVEN DROIDS AREN'T SAVE!

I think that's just a joke. What kind of tumblrina would call their trans C3PO "C3PHOE"?

 

[IdaRita]

They can use it ironically or "reappropriate term", I've never know when it comes to SJW art.

 

[Double Dragon]

Non binary Hannibal Lecter and Will Graham

 

[Jaimas]

What's wrong with her face?

Here's some redesigns like...
Fat supergirl whose redesign seems out of character (since she wouldn't kill like that).

And tubby Raven.

Why is she now a violent murderer?

 

[Hummingbird]

Why is she now a violent murderer?

Good question, I have yet to hear a response from the artist when I brought up a point on how out of character killing is for her.

 

[Utter Fool]

Tumblr has a Tolkien fanbase, among other ones. Their favourite pastime, besides writing lesbian fanfics about Silmarillion, is racebending various characters.

Spoiler: LOOK AT THAT FACE GODDAMMIT (c)

Judging by the enormous noses, the artist who drew the Jew face meme recently decided to branch into fantasy illustrations.

To be fair, that's some pretty good linework and the color is good as well.

 

[Synthesizer Patel]

Good question, I have yet to hear a response from the artist when I brought up a point on how out of character killing is for her.

I would be really surprised if you get any answer other than “lol keep reblogging this because it pisses off misogynists”.

Aside from the 2edgy decapitated head it looks like a cool costume design... but I know absolutely nothing about superhero comics. Could be another case of “I want to make my own character, but nobody will pay attention if it isn’t described as being feminist fanart”.

 

[friedshrimp]

It's coincidence, because I logged today only to post this picture:

EVEN DROIDS AREN'T SAVE!

I think she looks sexy. (JK, but I do wonder if you can even apply gender to a robot...)

View attachment 316802

Non binary Hannibal Lecter and Will Graham

They look like two old cracked out whores.

Why is she now a violent murderer?

Well the new Superman is a murderer, so she's just following in the family footsteps.

 

[milk+bottle]

The more you look at it the worse it gets