Rollins never recovered from that time he declared himself the best wrestler in the world and said WWE was the peak of wrestling when Ospreay was on an absolute tear in NJPW and AEW had just started.
The most mediocre member of the Shield patting himself on the back for wrestling the same match over and over was not a good look. His current character is zero charisma guy who dresses flamboyantly to try to have a gimmick who is married to someone who has already achieved more in her career than he ever will.