- Joined
- Dec 16, 2019
Absolutely. This is the contract upon which cat ladies' favorite genres - romantasy, rom-coms, and peak BioWare's romances - are built on.Using Taylor as an example again, she can't be sexual in their eyes. She can't want to be seen as someone who is content with her body or her appearance. She has to be the love lovebroken best friend, the pretty girl next door. Granted, Taylor built that image herself, but some swifties cling to it because it doesn't threaten their confidence. Sexy Taylor inspires envy, Dorky Taylor does not.
The same can be applied here.
It is implicitly understood that the heroine is special, beautiful, magnificent. But, she cannot acknowledge this. As long as she stumbles around in a cloud of contrived innocence, totally and absolutely confused as to why she has 16 hot men all begging for a taste of her pure virginal
This is why Miranda isn't so hot with these cat ladies, as she knows she is perfect looks-wise and she keeps throwing that out. But Leliana, so deadly but so endearing naive and sweet and "Oh? You love me? YOU REALLY LOVE ME? awww, I can't imagine it but I am so happy!" UwU, that makes her "relatable" - she never acts like or acknowledges that she is the hot shit.
(Note that Leliana became confident and poised only in games where she is no longer a romanceable option.)
This is also where Dragon Age: The Veilguard failed. Part of the contract is also that the protagonist is an active part of the love interest's transformation.
Lucanis's issues with Spite is resolved in basically a prep talk that you basically just sit in, so his romance never had that "I CHANGED BECAUSE I STUCK MY DICK INTO YOUR MAGICALLY WHOLESOME VAGINA/BUSSY!" vibes that cat ladies love.
Harding never changed into a confident and daring woman after you fucked her, when any self-respecting romantasy pimp will make it so that your character fucked her doubts and insecurities away.
Taash never changed before and after you fucked her, although you may have an undiagnosed trauma if she is your first choice for romance after sitting through her scenes. DItto Neve.
Most significantly, Rook is never the central focus of the love interest's life. They go on picnics, have book talks, and throw parties without involving him. This downplays the importance of Rook in the love interest's life - another big no no.
David Gaider, for all the shrunken shouting man-goblin buffoon that he is, understands this contract. Ditto the people writing Baldur's Gate 3.
Of course, you don't have to do this if your game stands on other aspects like gameplay, but BioWare more than most studios need to fulfill this contract as the other aspects of their games are not the main draw for the cat ladies that make up their sizable present day audience.
Last edited:
